What's new

Kashmir, The Way Forward : Shaykh Imran Hosein

Status
Not open for further replies.
This guy used to say back in 2011/2012 that in there would be war in 2 years ( or something like that), I stopped listening to him after that because clearly the stuff he said didn't happen, I cannot say he is good or bad because there might be things he say which are correct, but I think people should be careful and think with their mind when listening to anyone who make predictions or whatever they say

He is an Aalim (the guy with knowledge) not a seer (future sighter) or a prophet (who makes prophecies). Listen to him knowing he is an imperfect human with errors and try to learn from his knowledge. That is only as far as he (or anyone) can go; becoming an informed person with imperfections.

No one is perfect except Allah, and expect no one will be perfect among us. Forgive this imperfect Aalim and try to learn from what he knows. That is it.
 
.
He has dangerous ideas. I think his supporters are very likely to fall into the realm of conspiracy theorists.
 
. . .
I finally got a chance to look at his video and the response by Orya saab.

I must say that Imran Hosein has totally lost it.

If he thinks apologizing will change the behavior of war mongering states, then he has another thing coming.

Even if Mughals or Ottomans we’re wrong according to his belief (which i disagree with,) how can he justify the oppression and massacres on Kashmiris and Bosnians, Kosovars, Crimean Tatars, Circassians, etc.?

Do you think the apologizing would have stopped the Spanish Inquisition?
 
.
I finally got a chance to look at his video and the response by Orya saab.

I must say that Imran Hosein has totally lost it.

If he thinks apologizing will change the behavior of war mongering states, then he has another thing coming.

Even if Mughals or Ottomans we’re wrong according to his belief (which i disagree with,) how can he justify the oppression and massacres on Kashmiris and Bosnians, Kosovars, Crimean Tatars, Circassians, etc.?

Do you think the apologizing would have stopped the Spanish Inquisition?

Yugoslavia should reunite screw Alijia,Tudjman,and Milosevic Tito was best leader they had and Albanians in general are pro yankee and Israel than Slavs Yugoslavia needs to come back
 
.
I can prove that Imran Hosein is an illiterate. does not know conversational Arabic nor does he know the literal meanings of Quranic words. He either reads from cue card or memorizes short pieces of text parrot fashion

I knew him personally when he lived in the US. He is a one subject scholar, akin to Western scholars, but he does not qualify as an alim in the Islamic sense.

His knowledge of Riba, Dajjal, Israel, Yajuj Majuj, and Yawm ul akhir (last day) is impressive. He studied with Dr. Israr Ahmad and from Allama Iqbal heavily. I still read his books from the last 90s, early 2000s.

Since he distanced himself from Pakistanis, he has been unwittingly been co-opted by Non-Muslims to criticize Islamic history and make takfir on Islamic states, notable Turkey and Pakistan.

He is senile, and he is slowly losing followers and relevance. He has totally lost touch with reality.

Recently, he is on the verge of preaching some kind of omnism, namely that every religion is correct and they should follow the truth in their own faith.

This is completely contrary to Islam, which tells us to go out and preach Islam to the masses (Da’wah.)
 
.
My comments are not about you or your research. It is about the folly of One Subject Mullahs who in their desperation skew scripture to suit their forecasts and predictions.

Look buddy, I don't care one way or another whether my fellow countrymen want to listen to him or not. The fact is he himself proclaims that he can be wrong and always encourages his audiences to research the subject themselves. If you think he's a one subject scholar, then that is your problem. For Imran Hosein's first book was written on Islam & Bhuddism. He has a doctorate in International Relations and Monetary Economics for the Graduate Institute of Geneva, Switzerland. Imran Hosein has written books on Riba since 1990s, a subject no one has touched and one of the reasons why all Muslim countries have interest based economies. He has written books on fasting, dreams in Islam and even alcoholism. So much for your "One Subject" scholar.

Also, for those who say he hates Pakistan, he doesn't. His wife and children are Pakistani, born and bred. His teacher was Dr. Fazlur Rahman Ansari, also a Pakistani. He is an ardent reader of Allama Iqbal, who was the mentor of his teacher, Dr. Ansari. He has a home in Pakistan, he did his Master's Degree from Karachi University. Imran Hosein has even written a book on Allama Iqbal. If Imran Hosein hated Pakistan so much, he wouldn't care to even bother commenting about Pakistan in his lectures so much. So please, give it a rest about Imran Hosein hating Pakistan. His only rule is to study the Holy Quran and seek it's guidance to form his analysis. Tell me, how many of us Pakistanis ever bother to do that?

To conclude, don't watch Imran Hosein's lectures. No one is forcing you to watch them. Don't listen to Imran Hosein, no one is imposing this act upon you. But do NOT make false claims that Imran Hosein hates Pakistan, because that is a nasty lie and unbecoming of a Muslim.
 
.
To conclude, don't watch Imran Hosein's lectures. No one is forcing you to watch them. Don't listen to Imran Hosein, no one is imposing this act upon you. But do NOT make false claims that Imran Hosein hates Pakistan, because that is a nasty lie and unbecoming of a Muslim.

We have every right to critique the false statements of this man.

Actually anyone who promotes falsehoods about Islam, Mughals, Partition, Pakistan, Kashmir, and Ghazwa Hind will come under our radar.

Not only are his statements incorrect, but dangerous as it gives tacit approval of evil states like India (and others) to justify and increase their oppression of Muslims like those in Kashmir.

Dr. Israr Ahmad was a true scholar worthy of being called an Alim, and most of all fervently loyal to cause of Pakistan (Quaid and Allama Iqbal) and proud of the Islamic history of Bara Sagheer (the subcontinent.)

Check his lectures on the subjects of the Endtimes, they are still valid today.

Sheikh Imran Hosein of the 90s and early 2000s was on the correct understanding of Islam and its place in history. Since then, he has deviated from the truth and absorbed the talking points of the enemies of Islam. May Allah swt guide him back.

It will not be long before his ideal of Orthodox and Hindu will surprise him again, just like he was surprised about Kashmir and 370. Yet we knew this was going to happen all along, as our tariqa was the correct one.

We still have Dr. Shahid Masood and Orya Maqbool Jan (two students of Dr. Israr) whose analysis of the endtimes and Ghazwa Hind is available everywhere on the internet.
 
. .
The fact is he himself proclaims that he can be wrong and always encourages his audiences to research the subject themselves. If you think he's a one subject scholar, then that is your problem

He states that he is open to alternative opinions and thoughts and with the same breath chastises them.

Him being a one subject mullah (like many others) isn't just my problem... Its a problem for the Muslims at large being led astray by charlatans.... Simple minded fools are easily mislead by the wicked and cunning.

Imran Hosein hates Pakistan, because that is a nasty lie and unbecoming of a Muslim.

He has on multiple occasions blamed Pakistan for being a client state and has stated the Muslim and Islam was a crime against Hindu India. Go re-listen to his lectures.

He is a Hindu apologist.

Check his lectures on the subjects of the Endtimes, they are still valid today.
How valid is this BS he was pedalling 10 years ago... And has now changed his tune about the glorious Taliban saviors????

Not only are his statements incorrect, but dangerous as it gives tacit approval of evil states like India (and others) to justify and increase their oppression of Muslims like those in Kashmir.
+1 excellent comment

To conclude, don't watch Imran Hosein's lectures. No one is forcing you to watch them. Don't listen to Imran Hosein, no one is imposing this act upon you.

Why are you so worried about people calling out falsehood??... Should we allow jahil Mullahs to spread falsehood and fithna to the simple minded on YouTube??
 
.
How valid is this BS he was pedalling 10 years ago... And has now changed his tune about the glorious Taliban saviors????

I meant Dr. Israr Ahmad here.

Check his lectures on the subjects of the Endtimes, they are still valid today.
 
.
I knew him personally when he lived in the US. He is a one subject scholar, akin to Western scholars, but he does not qualify as an alim in the Islamic sense.

His knowledge of Riba, Dajjal, Israel, Yajuj Majuj, and Yawm ul akhir (last day) is impressive. He studied with Dr. Israr Ahmad and from Allama Iqbal heavily. I still read his books from the last 90s, early 2000s.

Since he distanced himself from Pakistanis, he has been unwittingly been co-opted by Non-Muslims to criticize Islamic history and make takfir on Islamic states, notable Turkey and Pakistan.

He is senile, and he is slowly losing followers and relevance. He has totally lost touch with reality.

Recently, he is on the verge of preaching some kind of omnism, namely that every religion is correct and they should follow the truth in their own faith.

This is completely contrary to Islam, which tells us to go out and preach Islam to the masses (Da’wah.)
Dajjal is supposed to be a great deceiver, to the point of misleading the entire world. If we give Sheikh Imran Hussain the benefit of doubt in this regard, that he understood all about Dajjal with present-age realities, then Dajjal is not a master deceiver but very predictable.

There is a hadith which highlight Dajjal's connection to Isfahan. Go figure.

Now he is talking about a global nuclear war in which Russian Orthodox Christians will somehow survive and come to the aid of Muslims who also have somehow survived, to counter Dajjal after his arrival. He have gone as far as to misread Quranic verses in this regard. This guy have truly lost it and setting a very dangerous precedent.
 
Last edited:
.
Dajjal is supposed to be a great deceiver, to the point of misleading the entire world. If we give Sheikh Imran Hussain the benefit of doubt in this regard, that he understood all about Dajjal with present-age realities, then Dajjal is not a master deceiver but very predictable.

There is a hadith which highlight Dajjal's connection to Isfahan. Go figure.

Now he is talking about a global nuclear war in which Russian Orthodox Christians will somehow survive and come to the aid of Muslims who also have somehow survived, to counter Dajjal after his arrival. He have gone as far as to misread Quranic verses in this regard. This guy have truly lost it and setting a very dangerous precedent.

Prophet Muhammad saws launched the Tabuk campaign against the Orthodox Christians in his lifetime (9 AH.) That and the solitary shahadat of Hazrat Ayyub al Ansari raa at the gates of Constantinople proves without a doubt that the Turkish armies which assailed Constantinople and the ghazwa which saw the city eventually taken over by Sultan Mehmet el Fatih ra were blessed by Allah swt.

Throughout that whole time, not one church of the Christians was turned into a masjid, except the royal church of the enemy Byzantines, which was the symbol of their power and influence. It was more of a political gesture, along with the change of the name of the city.

The word Istanbul or Istambul comes from the Turkified name for Constantinople, so its not much different.

Regarding the Turks taking Christian ruling family noble boys from their families, this is another exaggeration by the Sheikh. Those boys were taken with full consent of their families to be raised as Janissaries/Yeñiçeriler in the royal guard of the Sultan of the Ottoman Empire. They wielded considerable political, economic, and military power in the empire and became advisors, governors, and generals of the army. This was done to create an army of faithful loyal soldiers, which did not have ties to rival Turkish or Muslim tribes, hence ensuring longevity to the state.

However like the Hindus, the Orthodox Christians under Russia, Serbia, and Greece have created a parallel history embellished with falsehoods, lies, exaggerations to show the Turks as barbaric, evil, and villainous people worthy of being slaughtered and erased from the world. At times this mindset influences state policy of these countries, like the massacres during Russo-Turkish war, Graeco-Turkish war, and the breakdown of Yugoslavia leading to the subsequent massacres of Kosovars and Bosnians.
 
.
Prophet Muhammad saws launched the Tabuk campaign against the Orthodox Christians in his lifetime (9 AH.) That and the solitary shahadat of Hazrat Ayyub al Ansari raa at the gates of Constantinople proves without a doubt that the Turkish armies which assailed Constantinople and the ghazwa which saw the city eventually taken over by Sultan Mehmet el Fatih ra were blessed by Allah swt.

Throughout that whole time, not one church of the Christians was turned into a masjid, except the royal church of the enemy Byzantines, which was the symbol of their power and influence. It was more of a political gesture, along with the change of the name of the city.

The word Istanbul or Istambul comes from the Turkified name for Constantinople, so its not much different.

Regarding the Turks taking Christian ruling family noble boys from their families, this is another exaggeration by the Sheikh. Those boys were taken with full consent of their families to be raised as Janissaries/Yeñiçeriler in the royal guard of the Sultan of the Ottoman Empire. They wielded considerable political, economic, and military power in the empire and became advisors, governors, and generals of the army. This was done to create an army of faithful loyal soldiers, which did not have ties to rival Turkish or Muslim tribes, hence ensuring longevity to the state.

However like the Hindus, the Orthodox Christians under Russia, Serbia, and Greece have created a parallel history embellished with falsehoods, lies, exaggerations to show the Turks as barbaric, evil, and villainous people worthy of being slaughtered and erased from the world. At times this mindset influences state policy of these countries, like the massacres during Russo-Turkish war, Graeco-Turkish war, and the breakdown of Yugoslavia leading to the subsequent massacres of Kosovars and Bosnians.
If I could, I would have given you positive rating for this beautiful post but I do not have this option. But thank you, brother.

I wish WE could meet in person.
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom