Kashmir Conflict - Who is Right, India or Pakistan?

[Man of Thoughts]

Why this rant again and again
I can say same thing for lots of Pakistani areas also
But now Kashmir is purely India`s internal matter

Can you mention one of them please which is similar to Kashmir...........?? Just ONE

 

[Sacha_SIKH]

...............

 

[JonAsad]

That is utter nonsense, I have a classmate who is from Srinagar and a Muslim, and he considers himself as much Indian as I am or any other Indian member here.

Most of the Kashmiris say that so you dont discriminate them, If they starts chanting Freedom, what will you do to them? Think.

I have a colleague here, he is from Srinagar and is a Muslim and yes he studied in India, you should hear him abusing india

 

[JonAsad]

Why this rant again and again
I can say same thing for lots of Pakistani areas also
But now Kashmir is purely India`s internal matter

Enough with this BS of yours, i need you to back up your claim (bolded part)

 

[Jade]

Most of the Kashmiris say that so you dont discriminate them, If they starts chanting Freedom, what will you do to them? Think.

Kashmiris enjoy has much freedom as any Indian would enjoy...Are not the misguided youth who chanted "freedom" this summer enjoying the freedom as guaranteed to them by the Indian constitution

I have a colleague here, he is from Srinagar and is a Muslim and yes he studied in India, you should hear him abusing india

That is what even I am trying to tell...just because somebody is from Srinagar and is a Muslim doesn't mean that he does not consider himself Indian

 

[Ammyy]

Enough with this BS of yours, i need you to back up your claim (bolded part)

Just read this

http://www.defence.pk/forums/kashmir-war/80549-jammu-kashmir-out-u-n-list-disputes.html

 

[Fact_ur_mine]

dont be naive or act stupid, let me say it again the partition of subcontinent was baised on religion, you or the hindus at that time included.

You are showing yourself stupid.
It was based on religion for you and muslims, not indians.
Your second assumption is wrong, which shows your outlook is so much effected by your religious approach to everything.
Am not hindu and as always pakistan wents wrong with you.

 

[shekhar]

^^ thats mostly because you are not a Muslim, isnt it?

it HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH RELIGION
if religion is so important to you then you (Ur nation) wouldn't have let go BD which is 90% Muslim population

 

[PakSher]

But the 2 UN pending resolutions still stand, another situation like Kargil and it will take 5 minutes to be added back in the list. Pakistan holds many cards and time will tell, where Kashmir is going to go.

 

[Abu Zolfiqar]

Kashmir is right.

Pakistan Nation accomodates to them. Time and time again the Kashmiris have shown their gratitude to Pakistan --one of them being that they celebrate 14th August as a day of victory for them too

 

[Abu Zolfiqar]

Kashmiris enjoy has much freedom as any Indian would enjoy

right!!

You aint fooling anybody here, buddy.

...Are not the misguided youth who chanted "freedom" this summer enjoying the freedom as guaranteed to them by the Indian constitution

you don't want me to start posting links to completely debunk your statement do you?

you can't even send a text message in occupied Kashmir, you can't even upload pictures of peaceful demonstrations on facebook; and ur talkin bout enjoying freedom


maybe you should apply AFSPA in all hindustan, rather than a forcefully occupied territory then maybe we can continue this discussion

till then, time to blow the candles out and return to reality


That is what even I am trying to tell...just because somebody is from Srinagar and is a Muslim doesn't mean that he does not consider himself Indian[/QUOTE]

 

[Tin Man]

Let us examine from the indian viewpoint. Kashmir holds a lot of strategic importance and gives a considerable amount of tactical advantage. If pakistan intends to make a claim on religous grounds , india has a similiar claim. India holds the second largest muslim population in the world second to indonesia. Handing over a strategically important location to a nation where anti india propaganda is the order of the day , to me is a tad bit impractical. And to drive the point home, india has sacrificed countless souls to the kashmir cause to back off now.