Kala Bagh Dam Rs 772 Billion per year benefits

[hamilcar of carthage]

only the people who object this dam will care about flood in kpk or in sindh when it comes every year anyways, why not worry about countries water shortage rather than province and even in province their are handful of people we call it qoam prast. Kalabagh is for Pakistan but some nationalist think that Punjab will have upper hand cuz they wll supply water to sindh which is true but again its for Pakistan not for punjab or kpk. i only understand of this dam's opposing reason if Sindh is planning to be seprate then we understand other wise there is no reason for not to built.

because people think of themselve before others and kalabagh is a security risk in case of war as one hit and you flood sindh and kp, that would be disaster.

the purpose of the dam is to store water and to release the water during the irrigation period, especially knowing that sindh needs water 1 month in advance to punjab req. due to heat....
the second is generation of electricity..
the notion that it will deprive sindh of water is foolishness... currently due to floods sindh takes a huge toll... with the construction of kalabagh dam the flooding will be minimized and will increase irrigation possibilities in Punjab and Sindh


irrespective of who controls it.... the biggest factor coming in will be when sindh requires water for irrigation it will be available as it will be controlled and for punjab kpk will have a revenue stream due to energy creation and will provide cheap energy to the adjoining areas....
please dont only look at areas of conflict but rather what can be achieved as whole new paradigms can be opened up

nope you also reduce the water to kabul river and we cant be at the mercy of punjab government.

i

data available indicates that the dam is not harmful for either KPK or Sindh.

The project unfortunately became victim of politics.

it is really bad for kp and sindh, more on grounds of real problems.

Racist parties think it would benefit Punjab bas yahi takleef ha unko.

obviously, we know who runs pakistan, giving more power is a problem. North punjab will get more power and nobody wants an imbalance.

Zehni Ghulam spotted.
By the time you people will realize importance of this Dam your future generations would be dying of Food and Water shortage. Just to give you an example Karachi and major cities of sindh faces acute water shortage and soon you will cross redline of death and starvation. Sindh is the only looser in this game considering All other provinces have ample supply of water to meet their needs after construction new dams.



Said every Haramkhor Afghanis after eating away even share of starving Pakistanis. It is because of ungrateful garbage like this person that we need to send these Afghanis packing.

what does that even mean, build desilination plant, you wont get billions from kalabagh. Just stop with afghani and pakistani talks, you dont know where i live was born and am.

 

[Pandora]

what does that even mean, build desilination plant, you wont get billions from kalabagh. Just stop with afghani and pakistani talks, you dont know where i live was born and am.

Desalination plants can only provide at max 10-20% of water and unless you have a magic wand or 20-30 Billion dollars lying around to build enough desalination plants it is simply not enough. Only a Dam will provide water for the people of Sindh nothing else.

As for you being Afghanis it is fact which you cant deny. You sit in our land and sow CAOS among st its people.

 

[KAI KAI Baloch]

because people think of themselve before others and kalabagh is a security risk in case of war as one hit and you flood sindh and kp, that would be disaster.


nope you also reduce the water to kabul river and we cant be at the mercy of punjab government.

i

it is really bad for kp and sindh, more on grounds of real problems.


obviously, we know who runs pakistan, giving more power is a problem. North punjab will get more power and nobody wants an imbalance.


what does that even mean, build desilination plant, you wont get billions from kalabagh. Just stop with afghani and pakistani talks, you dont know where i live was born and am.

Excuse ME!!! we cant be at the mercy of Punjab Govt?????
whose mercy are you on when there is flooding and if india stops your water!!!!!
You have such a myopic thinking......
we are Pakistan get this in your head first!!!!

If sindh leadership had so much thought out for Sindh people, you wouldnt have nawabshah , larkana , thar desert in shambles.....

Kalabagh will increase our water security for generations to come, but i am sorry people like you will never understand!!
My vote is for Kalabagh and it should and must be made before more stupid people come start objecting to it....

Excuse ME!!! we cant be at the mercy of Punjab Govt?????
whose mercy are you on when there is flooding and if india stops your water!!!!!
You have such a myopic thinking......
we are Pakistan get this in your head first!!!!

If sindh leadership had so much thought out for Sindh people, you wouldnt have nawabshah , larkana , thar desert in shambles.....

Kalabagh will increase our water security for generations to come, but i am sorry people like you will never understand!!
My vote is for Kalabagh and it should and must be made before more stupid people come start objecting to it....

and also for your information india is making dam on kabul river in afghanistan..... lets see if you get water after that....

 

[shahbaz baig]

Show me any dam arround the world which cause any probem for any country ?

Stupids, pseudo intellectuals those are opposing yet.

 

[hamilcar of carthage]

Excuse ME!!! we cant be at the mercy of Punjab Govt?????
whose mercy are you on when there is flooding and if india stops your water!!!!!
You have such a myopic thinking......
we are Pakistan get this in your head first!!!!

If sindh leadership had so much thought out for Sindh people, you wouldnt have nawabshah , larkana , thar desert in shambles.....

Kalabagh will increase our water security for generations to come, but i am sorry people like you will never understand!!
My vote is for Kalabagh and it should and must be made before more stupid people come start objecting to it....


and also for your information india is making dam on kabul river in afghanistan..... lets see if you get water after that....

They can but afghanis will not because one can build another upstream in pakistan which would solve the problem but waste resources, pakistan will handle it through proper channel.

Desalination plants can only provide at max 10-20% of water and unless you have a magic wand or 20-30 Billion dollars lying around to build enough desalination plants it is simply not enough. Only a Dam will provide water for the people of Sindh nothing else.

As for you being Afghanis it is fact which you cant deny. You sit in our land and sow CAOS among st its people.

30 billion dollars is nothing if pakistan stabilize the economy. you can get help from china, when theres a will there always a way.

 

[AZ1]

30 billion dollars is nothing if pakistan stabilize the economy. you can get help from china, when theres a will there always a way.

No country will lend you this huge amount of money unless they see some great return. It's not just 30 but main focus should be BILLIONS DOLLARS.

 

[PaklovesTurkiye]

Dam reservoir will be in KP, turbines amd control station in Punjab, and will be handled by sindh? What do you want? Also give the swimming rights to Balochistan

LMAO

 

[KAI KAI Baloch]

They can but afghanis will not because one can build another upstream in pakistan which would solve the problem but waste resources, pakistan will handle it through proper channel.


30 billion dollars is nothing if pakistan stabilize the economy. you can get help from china, when theres a will there always a way.

Do u know the flow of river kabul???
Dam up stream??? On river kabul???
About waste resources, please share how much percentage of water is bring lost in arabian sea... can you please share the stats....
Do you even know the purpose of dam?? And what benefits it give????
What you are saying is all politically motivated nothing more....
If u ever went to interior sindh u would know about the water wastage being done by waderas...
My advise to you rather than making political statements focus of stats.....
By your conversation you look like those people who argue k ager pani se bijli nikal li to main pani ka kia karun ga...

 

[Erroroverload]

Zardari:- Lets Make a deal.
Imran Khan:- What deal? Dont you know that I will not a make a deal with you regarding corruption you have done.
Zardari:- I will help you to build Kalabagh Dam, Sindh will not make any obstacles and after that you drop all charges on me and my family and let us go. We rather will pass resolution in favor to build KalaBagh Dam on priority basis.
Imran Khan:- We have a deal Bra.
Pmln:- Imran or Zardari Bhai Bhai....

Hence Imran Khan is not thinking out of the box the upper mentioned scenario is the way to go. Drop all charges of Zardari Family and in return Sindh will allow to build this Dam. If IK has some political sense left do it for the people of Pakistan or wait untill The Mighty Bhutto will be dead.
At some point of time you have to make compromises and this is the best time to do that.
Regards

 

[Sheikh Rauf]

because people think of themselve before others and kalabagh is a security risk in case of war as one hit and you flood sindh and kp, that would be disaster.


nope you also reduce the water to kabul river and we cant be at the mercy of punjab government.

i

it is really bad for kp and sindh, more on grounds of real problems.


obviously, we know who runs pakistan, giving more power is a problem. North punjab will get more power and nobody wants an imbalance.


what does that even mean, build desilination plant, you wont get billions from kalabagh. Just stop with afghani and pakistani talks, you dont know where i live was born and am.

Let the expert decide but politician made it wrost so major population think its feseable for Pakistan and it gibes heart attack to india wonder why india investing so much money to sobotage it.

 

[ghazi52]

Look this guy from our area.................................What he had done so far and what his Grand father did ( He did a great job).

 

[hamilcar of carthage]

Do u know the flow of river kabul???
Dam up stream??? On river kabul???
About waste resources, please share how much percentage of water is bring lost in arabian sea... can you please share the stats....
Do you even know the purpose of dam?? And what benefits it give????
What you are saying is all politically motivated nothing more....
If u ever went to interior sindh u would know about the water wastage being done by waderas...
My advise to you rather than making political statements focus of stats.....
By your conversation you look like those people who argue k ager pani se bijli nikal li to main pani ka kia karun ga...

it was river kunar that i m talking about.

No country will lend you this huge amount of money unless they see some great return. It's not just 30 but main focus should be BILLIONS DOLLARS.

i said stabilize economy and with that revenue increases, loans might be couple of billions rest from our pockets.

 

[Pandora]

They can but afghanis will not because one can build another upstream in pakistan which would solve the problem but waste resources, pakistan will handle it through proper channel.


30 billion dollars is nothing if pakistan stabilize the economy. you can get help from china, when theres a will there always a way.

Yeah we have trees in Pakistan that grow dollars. Secondly Investment is done in project where you expect a return so what kind of return you expect from a desalination plant? Grow up Afghan this is not your fantasy world but a world with realities.

 

[Baghial]

Washington in 1963, President Muhammad Ayub Khan impressed upon the World Bank (WB) the need for a Development Plan beyond Tarbela Dam. He said that WAPDA started investigations in 1977 and feasibility reports on Kalabagh dam were prepared twice. Work was completed in 1988. The World Bank has indicated that Kalabagh Dam Project would generate a large amount of low cost hydro-electric power close to major load centres...........

THAT WAS 57 YRS AGO, AND.... and 10.billion dollars cheaper.

where will pakistan find the 15. billion dollars needed????????? to build the dam?