What's new

Jinnah's emissaries to SM Abdullah (Kashmir)

Kabira

BANNED
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
14,383
Reaction score
-20
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
He (Quaid-e-Azam) sent Shaukat Hayat Khan to Kashmir a month ahead of the birth of Pakistan, a visit confirmed by a long letter Khan wrote to the Quaid-e-Azam from Srinagar on July 11, 1947 (published in the Frontline and the Hindu in 2007):

People in Kashmir, particularly the National Conference rank-and-file, believe that Muhammad Ali Jinnah had ignored Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah in the run-up to the subcontinent’s independence and partition. But this is not true. A number of emissaries were sent to persuade Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah to join Pakistan but his efforts bore no fruit.

He (Quaid-e-Azam) sent Shaukat Hayat Khan to Kashmir a month ahead of the birth of Pakistan, a visit confirmed by a long letter Khan wrote to the Quaid-e-Azam from Srinagar on July 11, 1947 (published in the Frontline and the Hindu in 2007):

Faesal for all party meetings on daily basis
“I went underground to meet Ghulam Mohiuddin, their (the National Conference’s) underground leader. He has achieved considerable amount of popularity…. He is not at all averse to Pakistan, but says he is handicapped by our silence. If, he says, a little sympathy was shown to them, they would see that (the) Pakistan issue is not decided upon adversely. They feel that the interests of thirty lakh of your subjects were being sacrificed at the altar of Hyderabad and Bhopal.

Though they understood that your moves have (a) greater strategy in view on account of various repressions, they were impatient of (the) delay and may be reluctant to make greater sacrifices required of them. It was suggested that even a little bit of sympathy from us, in the form of a statement for (the) release of Abbas (and) Shaukat of the Muslim Conference, and Sheikh Abdullah of the National Conference, in addition to a recommendation for the grant of basic civil rights to the people would give an excuse for them to support Pakistan openly.

Also Read | In Defence of Sheikh Abdullah - II
They discounted the news of Abdullah’s assurance to the Maharaja and said that he was in favour of a referendum. My impression was that this party is still (the) most powerful and had the support of the intelligentsia. They had (the) advantage of having a good many honest workers. I did not think that they were in the pay of the Congress…. They are curiously torn between two loyalties, one to Pakistan and the other to Abdullah. They are indeed bewildered. They pray for Pakistan and for the release of Abdullah in almost the same breath. If Abdullah fights against Pakistan, it would be a very hard test for these poor people and God knows what the result is going to be?”

When Muhammad Ali Jinnah’s emissary, Shaukat Hayat Khan, met Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah, who had then assumed office as the state’s emergency administrator, he asked him why he had opted for India against the wishes of the people.

Abdullah responded angrily.

“Who are you to question my decision?” he said. “I want to give an independent empire to Kashmiris. Go away or I (will) get you arrested.”

Also Read | Farooq hopes new Govt will do justice with Kashmir
Khan had to go into hiding. The chilly weather told adversely upon his health, and he contracted pneumonia. But the Quaid-e-Azam’s emissary escaped from Kashmir with the help of Dr. Jagat Mohini, who had been a neighbour of his father, Sir Sikandar Hayat Khan, in Lahore.

Married to Dr. Omkar Nath, a widower running a hospital named after Ratan Rani, his late wife, the lady doctor recounted the story to the author during an interview in December 2007:

“In January 1948, a man came to me saying that a patient needed my consultation. I was reluctant at first, but then he disclosed the patient’s name.”

`He is the son of Sir Sikander Hayat Khan. He is hiding in a houseboat in the Nigeen Lake.’

“I was moved, and decided to accompany the man. But my husband warned me against the adventure. So I took his associate, Comrade Noor Muhammad, a member of the Radical Democrats, along.

Also Read | 'Feels like I have won the World Cup, says Imran Khan on arrival after first US visit
“Fortunately, penicillin had been invented around the same time. Nehru had gifted a pack of injections to Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah who gave it to Dr Peshin. He would sell them at Rs 100 per vial. We got some for Khan, and he recovered. Then I arranged an ambulance and took him

to Uri. He crossed over safely.”

Sends another Emissary:

Biographical accounts also suggest that the Quaid-e-Azam may not have given up efforts to bring the Sher-e-Kashmir round to his point of view. Even after Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah’s haughty treatment of Shaukat Hayat Khan, Jinnah is said to have sent another emissary to Srinagar in the post-partition era. KH Khurshid, also known as Khurshid Hassan, who as a young, educated Kashmiri had made an impression on the Quaid during one of his early visits to the Valley and gone on to become his private secretary and win his confidence, was dispatched to Srinagar to meet Abdullah. But he was arrested.

The news upset Jinnah so much that he wrote to Jawaharlal Nehru, the Prime Minister of India: “My work is suffering greatly and I want Khurshid back.” (My Leader by Jinnah’s biographer, NA Husain).

Also Read | Soz pitches for heritage status to Sheikh Abdullah's Soura residence
Khurshid was released after 13 months in exchange of a soldier, Ghansara Singh. But by then the Quaid-e-Azam had passed away.
https://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/opinion/jinnahs-emissaries-to-sm-abdullah/
 
. . . .
This is eye opening for people who say Jinnah ignored Kashmir.

Jinnah never ignored Kashmir, he understand nehru and Hindu Zehniyat more than anyone, he saw the crackdown of Kashmiri people by the Maharaja to suppress the call to Join Pakistan only then he ask Gen Gracy to seize the moment and Attack, if that British mothafcuker did follow the order, and we captured the Hari Singh a long with his stooge, Today Kashmir would have been in Pakistan . And if not for those Traitors who sell our SSG guys to Indian forces in 1965, Things would have been different .
 
. .
soo they did have a choice??? their fate wasnt decided by a hindu maharaja???

Yes and no. Abdullah was their leader but he had delusional dreams of independent "secular" Kashmir. Another bacha khan basically. He would rather join pro socialist Nehru India then feudal muslim league Pakistan. He was son of wood worker or tarkhan. He didn't think much ahead like Jinnah who quickly changed his stance after coming across hindutvas.

If somehow he was taken care of then Kashmir would have become part of Pakistan by hook or crock. The fact that Jinnah was sending emissaries to him meant that indeed more then Maharaja it was Abdullah decision. It was like Jinnah offer to Sikh leader at that time. By the time of 1948 invasion it was already too late. But if Abdullah had agreed with Jinnah vision then today things could have been different.

Now their descendants who have been Indian puppets since then, today said their elders made huge mistake.
 
. .
Sheikh Abdullah lead himself and the Kashmiri people towards oppression and occupation. History will remember him as a fool.

I don't consider him fool for wanting independent Kashmir for his people and not joining Pakistan. But fool to trust pseudo sickular hindutva Nehru to actually allow that once they toke full control of IoK from British.
 
.
I Wish The So Called "Lion of Kashmir" Was Alive To See His People Suffering and Cursing Him As A Result of His Choices

That Sher-e-Kashmir was a close ally and political friend of another Sher, the Sher-e-Sarhad Bacha Khan. I think both hated to join Pakistan in 1947 as both had socialist/secular mindset.
 
. .
He (Quaid-e-Azam) sent Shaukat Hayat Khan to Kashmir a month ahead of the birth of Pakistan, a visit confirmed by a long letter Khan wrote to the Quaid-e-Azam from Srinagar on July 11, 1947 (published in the Frontline and the Hindu in 2007):

People in Kashmir, particularly the National Conference rank-and-file, believe that Muhammad Ali Jinnah had ignored Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah in the run-up to the subcontinent’s independence and partition. But this is not true. A number of emissaries were sent to persuade Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah to join Pakistan but his efforts bore no fruit.

He (Quaid-e-Azam) sent Shaukat Hayat Khan to Kashmir a month ahead of the birth of Pakistan, a visit confirmed by a long letter Khan wrote to the Quaid-e-Azam from Srinagar on July 11, 1947 (published in the Frontline and the Hindu in 2007):

Faesal for all party meetings on daily basis
“I went underground to meet Ghulam Mohiuddin, their (the National Conference’s) underground leader. He has achieved considerable amount of popularity…. He is not at all averse to Pakistan, but says he is handicapped by our silence. If, he says, a little sympathy was shown to them, they would see that (the) Pakistan issue is not decided upon adversely. They feel that the interests of thirty lakh of your subjects were being sacrificed at the altar of Hyderabad and Bhopal.

Though they understood that your moves have (a) greater strategy in view on account of various repressions, they were impatient of (the) delay and may be reluctant to make greater sacrifices required of them. It was suggested that even a little bit of sympathy from us, in the form of a statement for (the) release of Abbas (and) Shaukat of the Muslim Conference, and Sheikh Abdullah of the National Conference, in addition to a recommendation for the grant of basic civil rights to the people would give an excuse for them to support Pakistan openly.

Also Read | In Defence of Sheikh Abdullah - II
They discounted the news of Abdullah’s assurance to the Maharaja and said that he was in favour of a referendum. My impression was that this party is still (the) most powerful and had the support of the intelligentsia. They had (the) advantage of having a good many honest workers. I did not think that they were in the pay of the Congress…. They are curiously torn between two loyalties, one to Pakistan and the other to Abdullah. They are indeed bewildered. They pray for Pakistan and for the release of Abdullah in almost the same breath. If Abdullah fights against Pakistan, it would be a very hard test for these poor people and God knows what the result is going to be?”

When Muhammad Ali Jinnah’s emissary, Shaukat Hayat Khan, met Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah, who had then assumed office as the state’s emergency administrator, he asked him why he had opted for India against the wishes of the people.

Abdullah responded angrily.

“Who are you to question my decision?” he said. “I want to give an independent empire to Kashmiris. Go away or I (will) get you arrested.”

Also Read | Farooq hopes new Govt will do justice with Kashmir
Khan had to go into hiding. The chilly weather told adversely upon his health, and he contracted pneumonia. But the Quaid-e-Azam’s emissary escaped from Kashmir with the help of Dr. Jagat Mohini, who had been a neighbour of his father, Sir Sikandar Hayat Khan, in Lahore.

Married to Dr. Omkar Nath, a widower running a hospital named after Ratan Rani, his late wife, the lady doctor recounted the story to the author during an interview in December 2007:

“In January 1948, a man came to me saying that a patient needed my consultation. I was reluctant at first, but then he disclosed the patient’s name.”

`He is the son of Sir Sikander Hayat Khan. He is hiding in a houseboat in the Nigeen Lake.’

“I was moved, and decided to accompany the man. But my husband warned me against the adventure. So I took his associate, Comrade Noor Muhammad, a member of the Radical Democrats, along.

Also Read | 'Feels like I have won the World Cup, says Imran Khan on arrival after first US visit
“Fortunately, penicillin had been invented around the same time. Nehru had gifted a pack of injections to Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah who gave it to Dr Peshin. He would sell them at Rs 100 per vial. We got some for Khan, and he recovered. Then I arranged an ambulance and took him

to Uri. He crossed over safely.”

Sends another Emissary:

Biographical accounts also suggest that the Quaid-e-Azam may not have given up efforts to bring the Sher-e-Kashmir round to his point of view. Even after Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah’s haughty treatment of Shaukat Hayat Khan, Jinnah is said to have sent another emissary to Srinagar in the post-partition era. KH Khurshid, also known as Khurshid Hassan, who as a young, educated Kashmiri had made an impression on the Quaid during one of his early visits to the Valley and gone on to become his private secretary and win his confidence, was dispatched to Srinagar to meet Abdullah. But he was arrested.

The news upset Jinnah so much that he wrote to Jawaharlal Nehru, the Prime Minister of India: “My work is suffering greatly and I want Khurshid back.” (My Leader by Jinnah’s biographer, NA Husain).

Also Read | Soz pitches for heritage status to Sheikh Abdullah's Soura residence
Khurshid was released after 13 months in exchange of a soldier, Ghansara Singh. But by then the Quaid-e-Azam had passed away.
https://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/opinion/jinnahs-emissaries-to-sm-abdullah/
One thing that I agree with Indians that the people responsible for Kashmir suffering are truly the Abdullah's and no matter how saddened I'm to the plight of Kashmir I'm happy that they may finally be free from them
 
.
soo they did have a choice??? their fate wasnt decided by a hindu maharaja???

Maharaja had already fled KAshmir because of the rise of the local population against him. His forces were being beaten left and right.
It's the Muslim Kashmiri leadership that disapointed Kashmiris from battling indian forces as they arrived in Sri Nagar.
 
.
I don't consider him fool for wanting independent Kashmir for his people and not joining Pakistan. But fool to trust pseudo sickular hindutva Nehru to actually allow that once they toke full control of IoK from British.

He could have whatever personal ideology he wants, but reality is reality. Not a single princely state became independent in the aftermath of the British exodus. This fool thought his province was somehow special. His stupidity led him to an Indian jail and his people to curfews and oppression.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom