What's new

Jinnah: Turning in his grave

fatman17

PDF THINK TANK: CONSULTANT
Joined
Apr 24, 2007
Messages
32,563
Reaction score
98
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Welcome to The Friday Times

A new anthology of writings on, and sayings of, the Quaid-e-Azam, Mohammad Ali Jinnah, was launched in Karachi last week before a distinguished gathering of intellectual and media elites. In its preface, the authors, Liaquat Merchant (President of the Jinnah Society) and Professor Sharief al Mujahid, wrote that the book "includes thematic essays on some critical aspects of Jinnah's politics and Leadership - such as the sort of constitutional set-up visualized by him...., his role in emancipating and empowering women...". Mr. Merchant dwelt at length, amidst clapping, on the sort of democratic, constitutional, just and secular Pakistan envisioned by Mr. Jinnah in which all sects and minorities, regardless of colour, caste or creed, would be equal citizens of the new state of Pakistan.

The same day, every newspaper carried headlines from Sufi Mohammad, the leader of the Tehreek-e-Nifaz-e-Shariat-e-Mohammadi (TNSM), and Muslim Khan, the spokesman of the Tehreek-e-Taliban (TTP), the conquorer of Swat, that the constitution of Pakistan approved by every political party of the country, was un-islamic and un-acceptable; that the Supreme Court, for whose supremacy and independence the country has recently witnessed nothing less tha a revolutionary upsurge, was un-islamic and un-acceptable; that democracy for tens of millions of Pakistanis have fought and voted over the last sixty years, was un-islamic and un-acceptable; that women, whose heroic struggle for emancipation and representation which has been backed by all mainstream political leaders across the spectrum, are mere chattel who deserve no education and have no human rights. Both gentlemen proclaimed their determination to extend their "Islamic system and views" to the rest of Pakistan by force. The same day Buner, a neighbouring district of Swat in the NWFP, fell to the TTP.

As on the fateful day in 1971 when General A.K.Niazi signed the surrender document in Dacca dis-membering Pakistan, Mr. Jinnah must have turned in his grave the day Pakistan's suppine parliament approved the Nizam-e-Adl regulation giving legitimacy to an un-holy peace deal signed between TSNM and the NWFP government on the point of a TTP gun.

The tragic irony is that President Asif Zardari did not want to sign that document into law, and dragged his feet over it for months, because he believed it was inimical to Pakistan's interest. But a chorous of agressive voices, from the Awami National Party that succumbed to the fear of the Taliban, to a hoard of "media-mujahideen" sympathic to the Taliban and Al-Qaeda, coupled with the stunning refusal of the Pakistan Army and the Pakistan Muslim League-N to condemn and resist the Taliban onslaught, compelled Mr. Zardari to turn to Parliament for cover. Only the MQM that rules Karachi, and a clutch of liberal journalists and papers (including this one, of course) has had the consistent courage and imagination to stand up and resist the Swat deal.

Thankfully, however, the tide is beginning to turn. it began after the TV channels plucked up the courage to show the outragous flogging of a young swati girl in public by the Taliban. subsequently, the TNSM and the TTP have alienated all of Pakistan by their recent outbursts against the constitution, Supreme Court, women, democracy and the rule of law. Worse, they have repudiated the core elements of the "Swat deal" (to lay down their arms and not to use force to seize other territories) and the Nizam-e-Adl (to accept the Qazi appointed by the NWFP government, to allow the right to appeal by the yardstick of the constitution, etc) even before the ink on it was dry. The TTPs armed seizure of Buner district and encroachments into Dir, coupled with continuing attacks on security forces in Hangu and elsewhere, have exposed its aims.

Meanwhile, three disquieting questions arise. First, why havnt the articulate spokesman and cheerleaders of the lawyers movement protested the sidelining of the lawyers of Swat and the trampling of the law and constitution by the TTP?

Indeed, where is the Chief Justice. Mr, Iftikhar Mohammed Chaudhry, whose suo motu actions in defense of law and liberty have given him a legendary status but who is now silent in the face of the Taliban threat to the very law and constitutionl that he has vowed to defend and uphold?

Second, why does the Pakistan Army support the Swat deal? Indeed, why did it stand by while the Taliban liquidated civilian officials and landlords allied to the ANP during their peaceful conquest of Swat and then Buner but swung into action unilaterally with helicopter gunships and jets when its own soldiers were attacked by the Taliban in violation of the same deal?

Third, why is Mr. Nawaz Sharif's attitude to the TTP and TNSM so equivocal? He supported the Swat deal and urged the Zardari government to desist from military action "against its own people". Now he has the gall to tell a foreign newspaper that Taliban are a menace and must be resisted "if they try to export their brand of Shariah to other parts of the country". He has not once said the same thing on Pakistani television. In fact, he thrives on ambiguity, wooing the international community while pandering to the anti-American sympathy for the Taliban at home?:enjoy:
 
.
VIEW: Consequences of Swat —Shaukat Qadir

Buner fell to the Taliban within hours, though local residents attempted to organise what resistance they could. The fact that the people resisted indicates their real aspirations, but they only succeeded in becoming fair game for the Taliban. Those who survived were promptly executed

On Monday, April 13, 2009, Asif Ali Zardari, our president, finally signed the Nizam-e Adl Regulation, handing Swat over to the Taliban and thus leaving an indelible mark on our history. President Zardari has found his legacy. If General Zia-ul Haq’s legacy was the initiation of religious extremism in Pakistan and Musharraf’s its flowering into the terrorism that we are plagued with today, Zardari will go down in history as the one who succumbed to terrorist threats. Though that ignominy is not his alone and has to be shared by the parliament that approved the Nizam-e Adl, legitimised the Taliban’s activities and handed over a part of our country to them.

Responding to a question, Sufi Muhammad, who brokered the deal, categorically stated that none of the previous acts of the Taliban could be tried under the Islamic laws being imposed in Swat. In one sentence, the Taliban have been granted amnesty for the murder, rape, pillage and other crimes they have committed against the people of Swat. Sufi Muhammad also called upon the Taliban to lay down their arms. Fazlullah, his son-in-law, responded by telling him that arms will be laid down only after the Nizam-e Adl is implemented.

Since then, the Sufi has adopted the sharia route to garner support. Addressing a massive rally in Malakand, he declared all other courts ‘un-Islamic’ and issued a deadline for the commencement of lower qazi courts and senior qazi courts. Fazlullah responded by informing us that the peace deal was brokered with the TNSM and was not binding on his followers.

Meanwhile, Fazlullah is attempting to increase his support base by encouraging a revolt by the peasants of Swat against the families with large land holdings — most of whom have fled the area — and has distributed the land among the peasants. The expected infighting and power struggle between the two has begun.

Fazlullah also continues to terrorise the hapless people of Swat, who dare not oppose him. He has also not discontinued suicide bombings; the recent attack on a police post in Charsadda was carried out by a Swati. A less well-known fact is that Fazlulah has received massive support in terms of weapons and equipment and has a very large number of Tajiks among his followers.

Since Swat shares no borders with Afghanistan, where did these people and weapons come from?

According to sources, there was a massive build-up of Tajik presence in Bajaur, and they were equipped with sophisticated weapons. However, they chose not to offer pitched battle to the Pakistan Army when it wanted to clear the agency. Some of these Tajiks trickled into Swat, where they, rightly, expected a stronger base.

Why the army and the ISI were unaware of the build up in Bajaur, including artillery pieces, until it had grown to mammoth proportions is an unanswered mystery.

These are people who govern only by force and do not enjoy the people’s support. Is there anyone who thinks that Fazlullah would win the people’s support were there a fair, free and impartial election in Swat? There are some who might answer in the affirmative and, under the prevalent environment, they might be correct. However, the current environment is not conducive to a free and fair election.

The people of Swat are totally disillusioned with the military and the political government after two thwarted efforts by the army to win Swat back from these terrorists.

The first, under Musharraf in 2007, was totally inexplicable, at a point when the army was poised at the mouth of the Peochar Valley, where remnants of Fazlullah’s army were hiding. After this, all the well publicised plans of having a permanent army presence with cantonments in Swat were shelved.

The second effort was undertaken this year by the provincial government of the NWFP when it struck the infamous ‘peace deal’ with Sufi Muhammad.

Consequently, the Swati people’s current view is that they are doomed and have no option but to succumb to the Taliban. Therefore, were an election held now, they might vote in Fazlullah’s favour, but only in the interest of personal survival.

Buner fell to the Taliban within hours, though local residents attempted to organise what resistance they could. The fact that the people resisted indicates their real aspirations, but they only succeeded in becoming fair game for the Taliban. Those who survived were promptly executed. If an election is held in Buner tomorrow, Fazlullah will win. But will that represent the aspirations of the people or their fear?

Has anybody looked at the map to locate Buner? Haripur lies to its south-east, Mansehra to its east, Mardan to its west, and the GIK Institute south-west — all of them within a day’s march. Islamabad is a mere hundred and fifty miles away. If the Taliban expand towards either Mansehra or Haripur, they will control the Karakoram Highway, which links us with China.

The Taliban also attempted to take Dir, but have been only partially successful so far and are in possession of Malakand. They have taken over operations of three major emerald mines in Swat, and have auctioned all expensive items in the government facilities located in the territories under their control — calling them ‘bounty’.

The signing of the Nizam-e Adl will be President Zardari’s legacy for Pakistan. The hapless citizens await its consequences.

This article is a modified version of one originally written for the daily National. The author is a retired brigadier. He is also former vice president and founder of the Islamabad Policy Research Institute (IPRI)

Daily Times - Leading News Resource of Pakistan
 
.
amazing 74 forum members have viewed these op-eds and not a single comment!!! talk about our ambivilent attitude towards what is happening to Pakistan and us!
 
.
Well the thread has now gone sort of old we have had a major operation in Dir and we have also removed Taliban from Buner atleast the Swati Taliban cowards didn't even stay to fight give them a little power and watch how they break the rules to shreds we now need to win the propaganda war that is the important step and by the way one of the terrorist leaders has even announced an avengence against the people of Buner causing thousands of them to flock the area.

P.S. I once responded to one of your threads before has nay made nay difference
 
.
oh well no worries FATMAN sir.... atleast you keep doing the good work of posting duniya suun hii leegi.....and besides these SWINE FLU of PAKISTAN a.k.a TALIBAN will soon be dealt with now that muslims TABLEEQI JAMAT...and locals have finally realised that taliban are not what they claim to be!!!!

but having said that QAZI courts should be put in place ASAP....
 
.
Well the thread has now gone sort of old we have had a major operation in Dir and we have also removed Taliban from Buner atleast the Swati Taliban cowards didn't even stay to fight give them a little power and watch how they break the rules to shreds we now need to win the propaganda war that is the important step and by the way one of the terrorist leaders has even announced an avengence against the people of Buner causing thousands of them to flock the area.

P.S. I once responded to one of your threads before has nay made nay difference

in this country, things change so fast on the ground, you dont know whats old or whats new! this is not old news friend, this is happening right now - our country is on fire!:flame:and until or unless we dont "band together" we wont be able to beat this menace!:enjoy:

I see you live in the UK, and happy to note that you are worried about what's going on!
 
.
oh well no worries FATMAN sir.... atleast you keep doing the good work of posting duniya suun hii leegi.....and besides these SWINE FLU of PAKISTAN a.k.a TALIBAN will soon be dealt with now that muslims TABLEEQI JAMAT...and locals have finally realised that taliban are not what they claim to be!!!!

but having said that QAZI courts should be put in place ASAP....[/QUOTE]

yes indeed no worries dunya sun he laygi:coffee:hope its not too late!
 
.
in this country, things change so fast on the ground, you dont know whats old or whats new! this is not old news friend, this is happening right now - our country is on fire!:flame:and until or unless we dont "band together" we wont be able to beat this menace!:enjoy:

I see you live in the UK, and happy to note that you are worried about what's going on!

You are probably right with regards to the timings but having said that I feel the war won't be over untill we win the propaganda war we need to show videos of the Taliban that say they will avenge the people of Buner and also the Dir operation we need to show the exectutoins baseless without any evidence specially the English speakers need to be slaughtered, that is the only way we can win.

I don't live in the UK I am only here to study and maybe work for the 2 years toget a bit of experience then I have promised myself to come back to Pakistan.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom