Jinnah had a dream, and we failed him

[DRaisinHerald]

This was the rough plan. As you see, at least mainly 3 different countries for Muslims, but only "Pakistan" had any chances of coming into being, having any decent leadership if anything.

 

[American Pakistani]

You're obviously not aware of the hue and cry raised by Mr. Jinnah over Junagadh and Hyderabad.

I suggest you do some research.

It is obvious, suppose if gajarat opted for india & Pakistan had occupied it, your nehra & Gandhi would have been crying all over.

 

[Sugarcane]

if you remain in denial then i can't argue with you.
why did you let junagarh ceded with you since it did not match with your alphabetical theory which you are ranting here? why did you let Bangal to be part of pakistan if it wasn't matching with your alphabetical theory?
truth is- that 2 nation theory is the biggest blunder. don't remain in denial about it. pakistan which jinah dreamt of does not exist from 71.

Indians & Pakistanis can't agree even on PDF clearly shows that we are two different nations with different mindsets.

Situation was same in past that's why Jinah left congress and joined Muslim League

 

[Gautam]

You need to read out history before posting like dumb, in the real plan it was decided about 3 Muslim countries after British exit, one was Pakistan consisting(Punjab, Afghania(NWFP), Kashmir, Sindh, BalochisTAN), 2nd was Bangalistan (Assam & East Bengal) 3rd was Osmanistan (Hyderabad Deccan). The polititions from Bangladesh rejected that plan & force to make E Bengal part of Pakistan.

go read history sir. Jinah
wanted Calcutta- which is a proof he wanted Bangal.

Wrong, it was Junagadh & Hyderabad's rulers who decided to become part of Pakistan just like Bangladesh's rulers. india's state sponsered terrorism & naked aggression end up in occupying those areas.

yeah but those 2 didn't match with your "alphabetical theory" that you guys always rant.

Read my post kid, instead of trolling.

i did uncle. but it was not making any sense.

 

[Bachchu Yadav]

Indians & Pakistanis can't agree even on PDF clearly shows that we are two different nations with different mindsets.

Situation was same in past that's why Jinah left congress and joined Muslim League

You are putting horse before cart .
First Pakistan was created then came PDF and then came trollers like us.

Who is creater of this map ? Saint Zaid hamid ?

 

[Sugarcane]

You are putting horse before cart .
First Pakistan was created then came PDF and then came trollers like us.



Who is creater of this map ? Saint Zaid hamid ?

Have you red below part

Situation was same in past that's why Jinah left congress and joined Muslim League

 

[American Pakistani]

go read history sir. Jinnah
wanted Calcutta- which is a proof he wanted Bangal.

Jinnah wanted Calcutta to be a part of Bengal that is Banglistan & not Pakistan.

yeah but those 2 didn't match with your "alphabetical theory" that you guys always rant.

again Osmanistan was decided to be a 3rd country not a part of Pakistan whereas Junagadh was to be part of Sindh.

i did uncle. but it was not making any sense.

Because whatever is fixed in kid's memory, he think, is correct.

 

[DRaisinHerald]

Jinah
wanted Calcutta- which is a proof he wanted Bangal.

After Bengal opted to join our federation, with Dacca, Jinnah showed interest in Kolkata. He said that Kolkata is the main capital on Bengal, so if Bengal is gonna join us, we'd rather also have Kolkata. Simple. He didn't express any interests into it before this.

You guys are trying way to hard to prove Pakistan's existence wrong to satisfy your own fantasies

 

[American Pakistani]

Who is creater of this map ? Saint Zaid hamid ?

This was original plan back in 1930's & early 1940's.

After Bengal opted to join our federation, with Dacca, Jinnah showed interest in Kolkata. He said that Kolkata is the main capital on Bengal, so if Bengal is gonna join us, we'd rather also have Kolkata. Simple. He didn't express any interests into it before this.

You guys are trying way to hard to prove Pakistan's existence wrong to satisfy your own fantasies

Not to forget Calcutta holds majority of Muslims.

 

[DRaisinHerald]

Who is creater of this map ? Saint Zaid hamid ?

Created by Choudhry Rahmat Ali (I think) but based on writings from Allama Iqbal. It's a rough map showing all the Muslim Majority areas with 3 main countries which could be formed part of it. Notice how each and every single one is separate; it's not Pakistan's map, but a map for (mainly) 3 different countries

 

[Bachchu Yadav]

Have you red below part

RED ?

http://www.english-test.net/forum/ftopic3104.html

It would help you.

 

[Sugarcane]

RED ?

What is the difference between "read" and "red"?

It would help you.

You guessed it right, same thing chilli is dancing in a$$ of indians like you since 1947

 

[IndiaIsrael]

Thread starter is discussing very Important point, see despite of huge population, variety of culture, poverty, problem of natural disasters. growth of Indian economy is high and sustained (2nd fastest), as nation pakistan can also do that, one day pakistan will also do the same, but It needs determination, and will power for example. Terrorism is problem for India we know pakistani terrorist attacked India, pakistan must eradicate such things from its land because at the end terrorism harm image of pakistan too. Internationally no one wants to Play cricket in Pakistan Reason for that is terrorism. Pakistani youth got potential but Madarsas ruin everything. Existing things are not working properly pakistani youth needs world class scientific education and total policy change..

 

[Gautam]

After Bengal opted to join our federation, with Dacca, Jinnah showed interest in Kolkata. He said that Kolkata is the main capital on Bengal, so if Bengal is gonna join us, we'd rather also have Kolkata. Simple. He didn't express any interests into it before this.

that's what i'm sayin. he wanted this and he wanted that. it does not approve your alphabetical theory. right?
now since we are on the same page- it is evident that the pakistan he wanted does not exist. thus his dream is broken long back in 71.

 

[Gautam]

Jinnah wanted Calcutta to be a part of Bengal that is Banglistan & not Pakistan.

he could have said no to Bangal. but he didn't. meaning he wanted Bangal which got separated from you because of your Punjabi leaders hypocrisy which broke his dream of pakistan he imagined.

again Osmanistan was decided to be a 3rd country not a part of Pakistan whereas Junagadh was to be part of Sindh.

you mean he wanted 3-4 countries out of India? then where did the "2" nation theory go?
it should have been some "3-4
nation theory"- no?

Because whatever is fixed in kid's memory, he think, is correct.

could have said the same thing about you. but i'm not frustrated.