CriticalThought
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2016
- Messages
- 7,094
- Reaction score
- 13
- Country
- Location
So I came across this simulation which seems to give a very, very low rating to Pl-12 and a low rating to PL-15 when they are used at around max range, while showing AMRAAM to be vastly superior because of pilot tactics and training as well as technological superiority
NOTE: I shared another simulation by this guy in the 'Azm thread.
In the video under discussion in this post, amongst other things, he is saying that PL-15, although having a superior range, will arrive on target at max range with very little energy left and can be easily evaded by sharp maneuvering towards the ground. Compare this with what I posted here:
I believe the youtube video only gives partial information. You dive down to force the missile to follow, and then gain altitude to force the missile left with little energy to fight against gravity.
Interestingly, these limitations should apply to AMRAAM as well. I believe the video is hiding even more information. That 'superior tactic' of 'experienced USAF pilots', might just be the use of two AMRAAMS against a single target, with one aiming for high altitude and the other aiming for low altitude at the target. Now, the pilot has virtually no escape route left.
@SQ8 I wish to bring this to the notice of PAF bosses.
NOTE: I shared another simulation by this guy in the 'Azm thread.
In the video under discussion in this post, amongst other things, he is saying that PL-15, although having a superior range, will arrive on target at max range with very little energy left and can be easily evaded by sharp maneuvering towards the ground. Compare this with what I posted here:
JF-17 Block-3 -- Updates, News & Discussion
What % of each block is built from composite materials? Since its conception, did CAC/PAC targeted a set % of the plane to be built from composite materials? Sorry, not the right place, the project was never conceived as a high and fast and far flyer.
defence.pk
I believe the youtube video only gives partial information. You dive down to force the missile to follow, and then gain altitude to force the missile left with little energy to fight against gravity.
Interestingly, these limitations should apply to AMRAAM as well. I believe the video is hiding even more information. That 'superior tactic' of 'experienced USAF pilots', might just be the use of two AMRAAMS against a single target, with one aiming for high altitude and the other aiming for low altitude at the target. Now, the pilot has virtually no escape route left.
@SQ8 I wish to bring this to the notice of PAF bosses.