Japan: Myanmar did not commit genocide against Rohingya

[Dalit]

Surprise surprise. Another Indian ally speaks up.

 

[Michael Corleone]

@bluesky @Michael Corleone @DalalErMaNodi


If USA tries to enter Myanmar, it will be another North Korea.

Not surprised. Japan sees itself as the victim of the war and not the perpetrator

 

[namefield_empty]

India also has nothing to offer to Myanmar

Your assertion is redundant, as India and Myanmar ties are based on mutual cooperation as equitable partners, both the stakeholders are bound together by shared civilizational ties. It will lead to the prosperity in our immediate region, and transform Myanmar into the country it so very much ought to be. India-Myanmar ties today are stronger that it's even been.

Quite a contrast from the master-client relation between China, and countries like Pakistan and Myanmar.

 

[Song Hong]

Myanmese once thought democracy and US is panacea to their problems.

Millions even went on streets to invite US to invade Myanmar.

Myanmese hated China for many everything. They hated China for supporting warlords, Kachin, Karen, Shan, Wa...etc

They hated China for investing in Myanmar.

They hated China for destroying environment, even though China investment made Myanmese rich.

They despise China.

Before 2011, 90% of Myanmese were very stupid. Only Tatmadaw was clever.

Myanmese should say thank you to China for being so kind. But many Myanmese are simply too ungrateful. Really bad character.

Your remarks is racist.

There so many BD members who have been successfully brainwashed by Google / Murican narrative. ~ Rohingya was created and master minded by Murican CIA
to overthrow the MYANMAR government, or at minimum
sabotage the MYANMAR & CHN economic cooperation.

===

@Song Hong

OP, ... Thousand Thanks for digging this Japanese / Rohingya news.

India also has nothing to offer to Myanmar tbh. China at least helps Myanmar to mdernize it's army. On the other hand India does not let its neighbour and allies to become militarily stronger because it would reduce the influence of India over its allies.

India and China both are bad neighbours.

 

[Suika]

There's a lot of history and context going here.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rohingya_conflict
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arakan_Rohingya_Salvation_Army

"Genocide" is a very heavy word. Human right violations for sure. But terrorists insurgency is broading the bad behavior from Myanmar goverment. Rohingya probably would live more peacefully if there was no long history of insurgency.

 

[bluesky]

If USA tries to enter Myanmar, it will be another North Korea.

I think the USA will take heed of what you said about your country and will not try to ENTER MM. But, why do you think MM is a superpower that can annihilate the USA and also why do you think the USA should enter that poor country?

 

[Song Hong]

Myanmar is not North Korea. Myanmar is worse than Yugoslavia, full of ethnic and religion contradiction. The moment US army landed, 70% of the people (minorities + Barmese race traitors and CIA Barmese such as Suu Kyi) will spread their legs, welcoming invaders to destroy their land.

The patriotic Tatmadaw can only cry.

US is preparing to invade Myanmar. Western MSM in lockstep accusing Myanmar of genocide, ala Sadam Hussein WMD, and Assad chemical weapon.

The reason US is not invading is because China is protecting Myanmar.

The extremists in PDF and elsewhere can forget about doing a Kosovo style for Rohingya. Not going to happen when China is there.

I think the USA will take heed of what you said about your country and will not try to ENTER MM. But, why do you think MM is a superpower that can annihilate the USA and also why do you think the USA should enter that poor country?

 

[Indos]

There's a lot of history and context going here.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rohingya_conflict
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arakan_Rohingya_Salvation_Army

"Genocide" is a very heavy word. Human right violations for sure. But terrorists insurgency is broading the bad behavior from Myanmar goverment. Rohingya probably would live more peacefully if there was no long history of insurgency.

Papuan also have long history of insurgency but it doesnt make Papuan people get oppressed by Indonesian military and cannot get citizenship like what happening with Rohingya. When 1 million people leave their home country to live in a crowded camp in Bangladesh, there must be something bad happening. Hence, it is not correct to bring low level insurgency there to legitimize what Myanmar gov/military did there.

 

[Song Hong]

Indonesian state is politically far more stable than Myanmese state, and Chinese is not waging insurgency in Indonesia now.

Myanmar has given Chinese citizenship.

There is still a forgotten group of tens of thousands of Indonesian descendents of Chinese who don't have citizenship and are basically stateless in 2010.


https://www.scmp.com/article/713128/home-where-heart-indonesias-stateless-community

Papuan also have long history of insurgency but it doesnt make Papuan people get oppressed by Indonesian military and cannot get citizenship like what happening with Rohingya. When 1 million people leave their home country to live in a crowded camp in Bangladesh, there must be something bad happening. Hence, it is not correct to bring low level insurgency there to legitimize what Myanmar gov/military did there.

 

[Buddhistforlife]

I think the USA will take heed of what you said about your country and will not try to ENTER MM. But, why do you think MM is a superpower that can annihilate the USA and also why do you think the USA should enter that poor country?

Geopolitics is not about being poor or rich. Myanmar has good reserves of natural resources, it is also a gateway to the SEA also to the South China sea and many other factors. Why do you think India, China, Russia, Japan and others supports Myanmar on the Rohingya crisis? It is because many countries are ripping strategic benefits out of Myanmar.

USA is well aware of it. They want to implement democracy in Myanmar through Aung San Suu Kyi. Also the Rohingya crisis may lead to USA take action against Myanmar.

I think the USA will take heed of what you said about your country and will not try to ENTER MM. But, why do you think MM is a superpower that can annihilate the USA and also why do you think the USA should enter that poor country?

What @Song Hong said is quite right.

Like Saddam Hussein's wmd, USA accused Myanmar of having chemical weapons. So what does this indicate?

 

[Song Hong]

Geopolitical if Myanmar breaks apart as per planners of USA, Kachin State, Wa State, Kokang, Karen will join China.

Not a bad deal for China.

Shan may consider Thailand or China.

Rohingya may join Bangladesh or go independent.

Rakhine will go independence.

Chin state may join Barma.

Fortunately China is too good to Barmar, forever helping Barmar race to control the Myanmar state.

China tell all Myanmar minority to stay with Myanmar state and forget about independence.

Geopolitics is not about being poor or rich. Myanmar has good reserves of natural resources, it is also a gateway to the SEA also to the South China sea and many other factors. Why do you think India, China, Russia, Japan and others supports Myanmar on the Rohingya crisis? It is because many countries are ripping strategic benefits out of Myanmar.

USA is well aware of it. They want to implement democracy in Myanmar through Aung San Suu Kyi. Also the Rohingya crisis may lead to USA take action against Myanmar.

 

[zhxy]

The reason US is not invading is because China is protecting Myanmar.

China does not protect Myanmar. It is not like the time of the Korean War. China does not want to conflict directly with the US and it does not put all the eggs in one basket. If Myanmar is an independent nation, very good. But if it's a puppet nation of the United States, it's not bad news because China doesn't care.

 

[Buddhistforlife]

Geopolitical if Myanmar breaks apart as per planners of USA, Kachin State, Wa State, Kokang, Karen will join China.

Not a bad deal for China.

Shan may consider Thailand or China.

Rohingya may join Bangladesh or go independent.

Rakhine will go independence.

Chin state may join Barma.

Fortunately China is too good to Barmar, forever helping Barmar race to control the Myanmar state.

China tell all Myanmar minority to stay with Myanmar state and forget about independence.

Nothing of such sort will happen.

The Burmese army is not foolish enough. They know the situation of their country.

 

[lonelyman]

Papuan also have long history of insurgency but it doesnt make Papuan people get oppressed by Indonesian military and cannot get citizenship like what happening with Rohingya. When 1 million people leave their home country to live in a crowded camp in Bangladesh, there must be something bad happening. Hence, it is not correct to bring low level insurgency there to legitimize what Myanmar gov/military did there.

Get off ur high horse, Indonesia is the last one to talk about human eights such things when u systematically commit genocide

 

[Buddhistforlife]

Geopolitical if Myanmar breaks apart as per planners of USA, Kachin State, Wa State, Kokang, Karen will join China.

Not a bad deal for China.

Shan may consider Thailand or China.

Rohingya may join Bangladesh or go independent.

Rakhine will go independence.

Chin state may join Barma.

Fortunately China is too good to Barmar, forever helping Barmar race to control the Myanmar state.

China tell all Myanmar minority to stay with Myanmar state and forget about independence.

Myanmar does not need USA. Israel is Myanmar's close friend. Why do you need USA when you have Israel as your friend?