What's new

It's a shameless pillage by plundering Indians - Neduntivu is perishing

DarkSeid

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jul 21, 2014
Messages
480
Reaction score
0
Country
Sri Lanka
Location
Sri Lanka
image-slider-2.jpg

Fishermen of Neduntivu, or Delft Island, have the option of either seeking alternative livelihoods or prepare for a 'tooth and nail' showdown with Indian fishermen to keep them out of Sri Lankan waters. This is the only solution to the dramatic collapse in their income from fishing in their own waters which has been the norm for over 25 years since Indian fishermen began violating Lankan maritime borders to plunder the rich catches of fish belonging to Lanka's fishermen.
The encroaching began when nearly 30 years ago northern fishermen were banned from fishing in those waters because of the maritime threat from the LTTE 'sea tigers'. Indian fishermen began encroaching stealthily and that practice of over 25 years has now become an illegally established norm that deprives northern fishermen of their livelihood, with over 1340 families on Nandaitivu island alone being deprived of their legitimate fishing grounds and livelihoods.


india-sri-lanka-sea-borders-map.jpg

Fisherman Fernando's family, like hundreds of others, are seated on the shores of Nanditivu by on a bright morning. Time was when the entire stretch of beach here was abuzz with hectic bidding going on for huge catches of fish at the beach auctions. But today, the family looks with vacant eyes at the little waves lapping over their feet, the sea as calm as the economic death on the shores. Nothing moves here now because the marauding Indian fishermen have brought death to Lanka's northern shores. The trucks which lurched away from the beach laden with fish for the markets don't call here anymore. It's a scene out of Neville Chute's "On the Beach" epic in which nuclear fallout has snatched all of life from the coastal settlements. Anxiety has its cold grip on Fernando even as he dismally pushes his boat out with the team to set out for whatever still goes a-begging in the seas, where a fatal clash with scores of invading Indian fishermen can flare out before they drop nets.

Anxiety and doubt gnaw at the guts.The four men on the little fishing vessel share pensive, unsettling thoughts: will there, or won't there be fish today. Will there be a clash? What does the day hold? On shore, the womenfolk have stopped pretending a calmness they long ceased to feel. No catch or a very small catch leaves them hungry far too often these days while unconcerned officials hold talks with Indian fishermen on what essentially directly has to do with empty stomachs of the kids and womenfolk of Neduntivu. They simply cannot understand why the Indian fishermen are dealt with in a manner that sees the legitimate rights of the folk of Neduntivu offered on a platter to those invasive hordes of Indian fishermen. Literally thousands of Indian trawlers continue sweeping away all the wealth of the sea that belongs to Sri Lanka. Life is not so desperate or hopeless even in "On The Beach" where the option was there to flee from the fallout or die in the attempt. Neduntivu's desperation lends them no hope because in this industry , ironically, Neduntivu's fisher families cannot relocate elsewhere on Lanka's coastline that's home to other fisher families. But Indian fishermen are allowed by the thousands to invade and take away massive hauls of fish which belong to them.

And the authorities talk, talk and talk.
The terrorist war is over. The army is pulling out. The Indian Peace keeping Force is long gone. Yet Neduntivu's thousands of fisher families face starvation and a depth of mental agony that no one has the right to impose on them. The yoke remains tightly knotted around their necks.
Neduntivu - the long island, just 46 square km, is the biggest island abutting Lanka's shores. It offers nothing else besides meager palmyrah toddy, a sweetmeat made of palmyrah honey and the boiled palmyrah root that's a poor food supplement. Officials at talks deciding on their fate return home or to hotels to unwind in luxurious comfort and ease. Neduntivu's children, women and desperate men scorch in the noonday heat to freeze out in the biting cold of the night winds.


image-slider-1.jpg

History of the fishemen
Time was when they could look out at subtle colour differences in the ocean and predict their catch for the day. The Indian boats and trawlers obliterate all that today and seem intent on continuing indefinitely.
Sturdily built, Fernando at 64 is a sixth generation fishermen living here with his family. His forefathers were from Myliddy who discovered this island surrounded by fish and settled there for good. "It was during king Vedi Arasan that my forefathers came here to fish." Of 13 siblings only four remain today. But that's a taboo subject saturated with painful memories and one you cannot broach with Fernando.

Like many others, he lives by the sea, on his wife's dowry land, braving all weather conditions, their lives and livelihood on the cusp of an ocean sinkhole created by the Indians and couldn't-care-less negotiating officials. "During king Vedi Arasan's rule,circa 1002, people on Neduntivu island were farmers but when my forefathers discovered that it was a fishing paradise they decided to plant their homesteads there and develop the fishing industry. It's this rich heritage that thousands of such pioneers lived and died for that is being mysteriously bartered away to the Indians, no matter how many of Neduntivu's people suffer and die in the process. "They were rich and shared their wealth with the community, and that includes me" muses Fernando with bitterness. I was rich enough to feed anyone until the Indian trawlers came to hit us below the belt, he adds.

Fernando recalls: "I remember when M. G. Ramachandran (MGR)was the Tamil Nadu chief minister in the 1960s. Those were the heydays of our lives. There was no trouble, our catches were abundant and life was worth living. I think it would have been the same for the people of South India. But trouble began brewing after his death across the Palk Straits." That would mean that the old timers see a coming together of problems beginning in the 1960's, unrelated to the ban on fishing during the war, and the incursions by the Indians after the ban.

After MGR's death, South Indian fishermen have been fishing all over the sea. "It's at that time that the trouble began and grew to its current proportions. In those days they came in small boats up to Kachchativu when it belonged to India. Then their incursions came deeper into Kaaithurai, north of Neduntivu.
He said those were the days in which a rich catch grossed over 20, 000 kgs and fishermen earned upto Rs 200, 000 on a good day. "Shark, tuna, crabs, prawns and squid..the catches were in abundance".
Fernando continues, "Even fishermen from the East came to Neduntivu in big numbers. But the Indians leave us nothing today but for some Salayas and other small species which have no market."

Fernando's son Ramesh is a management graduate but has no stable job. Working for a cooperative store for a pittance of only Rs 7000 a month, he said he would be quitting his job soon because he too cannot depend on the sea anymore.
"My father's income was around Rs. 100 000 in the 80s but with the war and political fallout we are besieged by poverty and left with no future. We struggled to live another day during the war, but the worst blow has been the loss of our livelihood today. We cannot go elsewhere to make a living. These crucial facts must be driven into the Indians. This island has only 1340 families with 12 schools and two post offices. Where can we go if we cannot work and live on our own island anymore?" Ramesh questioned.
There will only be some hope for us if and when this plunder by the Indian fishing trawlers is stopped."
Other fishermen don't share his desperate hope. "It never will unless our government or our northern provincial council stops playing politics and does something to end it" they intone in one voice.

Fernando deplores the fact that the government does not seem to realize that "Our wealth is the country's wealth." He adds that "we can easily reap huge revenue via fish exports if the government does what it must.There's no need for any dialogue with India because as Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe said it, if the Indians violate Sri Lanka's maritime boundaries, shoot them. It may be painful to hear such remarks but why must they come here in the first place? Why tolerate this abuse anymore?What rationale does the government have for allowing this to continue?
He also suggested that plentiful fish produce can boost tourism by serving tourists with the best of Neduntivu's seafood.
"We have no alternatives and cannot afford to do anything due to lack of financial assistance and that is sad," Fernando's son Ramesh laments.

A fisherman's life remains unchanged through centuries. They are fated to forever live by the sea and brave the weather all the time. Fernando says his latest catch produced only five crabs in his net. That was just enough for our family. The net was bedded two days ago, he pointed out

There are other areas of concern for the fishermen. They are deprived of a proper mechanism to sending their meager catches to the Jaffna main market on time due to boat travel. "We have missed the peak sale hours by the time we reach there."
Boat travel
Neduntivu has three boats running between Jaffna and Neduntivu of which two are Navy operated passenger boats which make two trips a day. The other private boat carries goods for traders but occasionally some boats break down leaving people with no alternative. Neduntivu folk usually limit their travel to the mainland by boat to once a week. Fernando prefers more cargo boats being made available to the islanders.

The fishermen also have a huge cooler room that is more or less abandoned these days because of poor catches. Ramesh adds that the cooler is never switched on now due to lack of funds to maintain it.
The island has three Justices of Peace (JP) who are fishermen too who are well respected by the people. The JPs also often double as policemen when occasion demands it.

JP Prasgasm Mariampillai is deeply disturbed by the Indian trawlers coming in thousands every week. "It's pathetic that India does not stop the trawlers while Sri Lanka has banned us from using it.
"In Gurunagar, Jaffna, there are more than 400 big fishing trawlers anchored because of the ban. There will come a time when we will also havwe to stop listen to what anyone says and simply exercise our right to fish in our won waters" he warned.
He predicted that there could be worse clashes which will mar Indo-Lanka ties unless the authorities stopped playing games with this crisis and got down to an immediate and sustainable solution to it.

Mariampillai says it's the Indian fishermen who need talking to because the Lankan fishermen are the aggrieved party.
"President Maithripala should bring us some relief immediately and restore our former livelihoods to us. This is why we voted for him. According to him the EPDP has been concerned but the people obviously have wanted a change," he opined.
He sees a compromise solution in which the Indian trawlers are either entirely prohibited from entering Lankan waters or are compelled to not impede Lankan fishermen fishing in their own waters. Sri Lankans have not violated any law of the sea or of nature because we honour the wealth of the sea and that we should not destroy it, he explained.

Their trawlers which come as close as a few kilometers to the Neduntivu shores drop large trawling nets which destroy our smaller nets and it's not easy keep buying fishing nets every other day.
Mariampillai added that having faced life and death situations during the war, they are still not free from trauma."You can brave the war but not hunger and poverty," he said.

Navy officials have on occasion helped us chase away the intruders."On several occasions, we have even assaulted Indian fishermen who have got caught to us. Navy officials have chased them away but that has also been turned into a political issue. But whether they chase them or not these officials are being unduly accused of doing so"
Due to South Indian fishermen encroachment these islanders lose approximately Rs 120, 000 daily.
Bernard, the English educated school teacher chipped into the conversation saying that the 80s and 90s were the golden years of the fishing industry.

Having seen his sons serve in the army, Bernard is now a translator and helps people who need anything to be written in English.
Bernard's only worry is that his people continue suffering and are deprived of their livelihood.
"There were times when we used to bring 1000 to 2000 kg of fish to the shore. Now a fishing boat brings in a mere 30 kg catch and that too not on a daily basis. "We're lucky if we can get an aggregate catch of 2000 kilograms from 50 boats these days" he explained.

Neduntivu fishermen are doomed to idling on the shore while over 1000 or more Indian trawlers spend the whole day within sight using the large prohibited nets to farm all the fish and crustaceans that they can, leaving us nothing after they have left. "No other government will tolerate this wantonly destructive trespass into its maritime precincts."
Fernando added, saying that Sri Lanka could truly benefit through the excellent prawn harvests now reaped by the Indians. The People of Neduntivu are mostly Tamil Christians. The warm friendly people are blessed with two of nature's best offerings : the white sandy beaches and abundant coral gardens immediately offshore abutting the island.

Efforts have been made by all players in the fishing industry to work together with their Indian counterparts to solve the issue facing the fishermen of both sides. "Any dialogue should conclude in our favour because we don't have to share our seas with anyone.
Fernando said the Indian fishermen were never a problem before and if they were not in the picture as before, the Neduntivu fishermen would have made an adequate income that would have enabled them to build houses for themselves.

Ceylon Today | It's a shameless pillage by plundering Indians - Neduntivu is perishing
By Sulochana Ramiah Mohan

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TN Fishermen May get 83-day Access -The New Indian Express
Sorry, we aren't willing to share our seas with anyone.
 
.
Now i'm not sure how reliable this idiot Ajith Perera is but this is the latest on the Indian claims of agreeing to a 83 access for it's poachers

The Island

Acting Foreign Minister Ajith P. Perera yesterday denied Indian media reports that Sri Lanka had agreed to allow Indian fishing vessels to enter the Sri Lankan waters 83 days per year for the next three years.


Minister Perera stressed that the government hadn’t changed its position on the contentious issue of poaching. The minister was responding to foreign media reports that Sri Lanka had agreed to share its waters with the Indian fishing fleet.


Premier Ranil Wickremesinghe had recently explained Sri Lanka’s position as regards the Tamil Nadu fishing fleet poaching on northern waters at the expense of local fishermen, Minister Perera said. Premier Wickremesinghe didn’t mince his words when he reiterated Sri Lanka’s right to discourage poachers, the minister said.


The Navy captured 54 poachers in 10 trawlers in the northern seas over the last weekend. They were handed over to the Indian Coast Guard at Indo-Lanka maritime boundary off Kankesanthurai on March 25.


Foreign Minister Mangala Samaraweera was not available for comment. he is in China with President Maithripala Sirisena.


Navy headquarters yesterday said that the navy hadn’t been informed of an agreement with Indian fishermen to allow poaching.


The Northern Provincial Council, too, wants the government to take tangible measures to prevent Tamil Nadu from depriving the northern fishermen of their livelihood.


Prime Minister Wickremesinghe is on record as having said recently that northern fishermen expressed displeasure over the government’s failure to halt poaching.


Political sources said that the issue would definitely come up during Premier Wickremesinghe’s three-day tour of the Northern Province beginning today
 
.
Now i'm not sure how reliable this idiot Ajith Perera is but this is the latest on the Indian claims of agreeing to a 83 access for it's poachers
Politicians couldn't be trusted anymore based on their word only.
 
.
Politicians couldn't be trusted anymore based on their word only.

Well then it goes both ways mate.. The now opposition is made out of politicians as well.. Even the worse kind than the current govt
 
.
@DarkSeid .. Further confirmation of Indian media jumping the gun on this issue.. After all the Dy foreign minister is right.. SL have never accepted those terms

Peaceing Together Fisher Formula -The New Indian Express

Although leaders of Indian fishermen and the Indian Ministry of External Affairs have given a positive spin to the third round of talks between the Sri Lankan and Indian fishermen held in Chennai recently, Lankan fishermen told Express that they had only agreed to consider the demands, not accept them.

While Indian fishermen said that amicability and trust have been added after Mahinda Rajapaksa was toppled by President Maithripala Sirisena, the island nation’s fishermen representatives say that they would put these demands before their colleagues and at the high-power meeting convened by Sirisena at Colombo on April 10-11.

Following this, they would come back with a consolidated view on the various issues brought forward by their Indian counterparts at a meeting to be held in Colombo in mid-May, they say. The bright side of the Chennai meeting then, was that the Sri Lankan side did not reject the Indian side’s Seven Point Set of Proposals outright.

PEACEING.JPG


One of the major sticky points between the fishermen of both nations is the use of trawler boats by the Indian side — two proposals in the seven-point list relate to these ‘destructive’ boats that scoop the sea bed clean of marine life. According to the proposals accessed by Express, Indian fishermen have agreed to give up trawling in Palk Strait in the next three years. They had initially said they would abandon the practice in five years. However, they say this requires huge investment from Centre and State to provide alternative livelihoods for the community.


One of the most viable alternatives at present is deep sea fishing. For this, the Tamil Nadu government has subsidised the cost of deep sea vessels by 50 per cent — each one costs about 60 lakh. In addition, former Chief Minister J Jayalalithaa has asked for Rs 975 crore for three years from Prime Minister Narendra Modi for deep sea fishing.

Joint Council Plan to Ease Rough Sea in Traditional Turf




The third round of talks between Sri Lankan and Indian fishermen held in Chennai may have given hope to end the bitter fishing rights issue. Read


K Rajachandran, President, Sri Ambal Fishermen’s Cooperative, Karainagar, Jaffna, feels that three years is too long a period to allow bottom trawling even if the Indian side does not use destructive nets. “By the end of three years, Sri Lankan waters will be completely denuded of fish and other marine resources,” he says. S P Anthonymuthu, advisor, Indo-Lanka Fishermen’s Welfare Forum, concurs. There ought to be a planned phasing out, with short term and long term plans, he says. However, the Lankan fishermen agree that converting trawlers to deep sea fishing vessels is the way forward, but say the process should be expedited.

Another point on the list is that Indian boats should be allowed to fish in Palk Strait for 83 days a year for three years. While Tamil Nadu has been seeking restoration of traditional fishing rights of the State’s fishermen, including unhindered fishing in Palk Strait, Lanka’s fisherfolk see even this as too long a time and say that the traditional fishing rights claim is something to be sorted out at the government level.

However, Rajachandran says, “If banned methods of fishing are not used, we as fellow fishermen, have no objection to Indian fishermen fishing in Sri Lankan waters. But it is a matter within the jurisdiction of the government of Sri Lanka as it is responsible for the country’s security.”

Reflecting the distrust still prominent among the Lankan fishermen, Emiliyanpillai alleges, “They keep going back on their word. For instance, certain kinds of nets are banned in India itself, but many continue to use them here.” Shooting off a warning, Anthonymuthu says that Lanka is set to amend its Constitution to dilute the powers of the Executive President, after which the President will not be able to release Indian fishermen as easily as he has been doing so far. “Therefore, Indian fishermen will be well advised not to cross the IMBL,” he says.

The proposals also aim to fully implement the ban on purse seine and minnow seine fishing nets. Green activists in TN suggest that the vessels carrying these nets shouldn’t be allowed to leave the harbour. Though fishermen have agreed to stop using them, the Lankans are still skeptical. “We will wait and see. The proof of the pudding is in the eating,” points out A Emiliyanpillai, president, Jaffna District Confederation of Fishermen’s Cooperatives.

In sum, the seven-point set of proposals put forth by the TN fishermen is the starting point for some hard-nosed negotiations. That the Lankan side agreed to consider it is in itself a indication of possible political will to look for solutions. The path to tranquility on the Palk Straits can still be choppy. We are keeping our fingers crossed.

Deep Sea Fishing A Costly Venture

Deep sea fishing is one of the viable alternatives proposed by the fisheries department to divert those involved in trawling the over-exploited sea bed. Read

7-point Proposal

Fish in traditional fishing areas in an amicable way

India: Fishermen have been enjoying traditional fishing rights for ages, but Eelam war kindled distrust between Sinhala and Tamil fishermen

Lanka: If banned methods of fishing are not used, we as fellow fishermen, have no objection to Indian fishermen fishing in Sri Lankan waters — K Rajachandran

President, Sri Ambal Fishermen’s Cooperative, Karainagar, Jaffna

Indian Fishers to abandon trawling at Palk Strait in the next three years

I: Alternative livelihood should be provided

L: In three years (of bottom trawling), our side will meet the same fate as the Indian side

— A Emiliyanpillai, President, Jaffna District Confederation of Fishermen’s Cooperatives

Plea to allow 83 days of fishing in Palk Strait

I: It is better than not having the right to fish in Palk Strait at all

l: 83 days for three years is too long a period, unless there is a planned reduction in the use of bottom trawlers

—S P Anthonymuthu, Advisor, Indo-Lanka Fishermen’s Welfare Forum

Convert trawl boats into deep sea fishing boats with Rs 975 cr Central aid

I: Good alternate source of livelihood, but need financial aid

l: That is the way out, but it should be done urgently

TN fishermen not to go up to five nautical miles from Sri Lankan coast while fishing

I: Necessary for livelihood of Sri Lankan fishermen, could reduce conflict at IMBL

l: Theoretically not acceptable

Stop use of banned purse seine and minnow seine fishing nets

I: Nets still available in market, ban has to be fully implemented

l: Welcome move, but will wait and see if claims are true

Fishermen crossing the IMBL should not be arrested

I: Will provide relief, but will Indian and Lankan governments abide by this?

l: Unreasonable demand. No country can allow foreigners to cross IMBL without permission
 
.
@Gibbs,
The point is machan, even if we agree to 83 days or not, these thieves come and steal the fish for 365 days ne. So it is as if they already have an agreement and SL government does not care.

That is the issue.....anyhow look at the pics, breathtaking
 
.
@Gibbs,
The point is machan, even if we agree to 83 days or not, these thieves come and steal the fish for 365 days ne. So it is as if they already have an agreement and SL government does not care.

That is the issue.....anyhow look at the pics, breathtaking

Bro how can you assume the govt does not care ?? They keep arresting the poachers.. PM has been categorical in our sovereignty eventually leading to massive hysteria in India.. Despite that the govt has kept the stance.. Those warnings are the catalyst for these TN thieves to come to the table.. Did it ever happen under the MR watch ? To date not a single boat of the poachers have been released.. Inspite the immense pressure from TN.. Atleast the current govt is trying to do something about it

So you reckon the Rajapaksa govt too had an agreement to let them poach ? Because the poaching never stopped under thier watch.. Nor was anything done to stem it and every time Indian govt intervened MR released those poachers under a presidential decree.. Even the drug smugglers were released by the MR govt from death row even though everything pointed towards thier guilt

As the Sri Lankan fishermen rep rightly points out after the constitutional amendments are made the president wont have the right to decree releasing international criminals at his fancy like MR did.. You reckon that will be an agreement with the Indians as well ? C'mon mate.. Thought you were more sensible that this
 
.
Bro how can you assume the govt does not care ?? They keep arresting the poachers.. PM has been categorical in our sovereignty eventually leading to massive hysteria in India.. Despite that the govt has kept the stance.. Those warnings are the catalyst for these TN thieves to come to the table.. Did it ever happen under the MR watch ? To date not a single boat of the poachers have been released.. Inspite the immense pressure from TN.. Atleast the current govt is trying to do something about it

So you reckon the Rajapaksa govt too had an agreement to let them poach ? Because the poaching never stopped under thier watch.. Nor was anything done to stem it and every time Indian govt intervened MR released those poachers under a presidential decree.. Even the drug smugglers were released by the MR govt from death row even though everything pointed towards thier guilt

As the Sri Lankan fishermen rep rightly points out after the constitutional amendments are made the president wont have the right to decree releasing international criminals at his fancy like MR did.. You reckon that will be an agreement with the Indians as well ? C'mon mate.. Thought you were more sensible that this

I think u misunderstand many of MR's tactics. MR did not take strong actions against fishermen, because he did not want to create TN- Central governments issues.

But he did not release boats and fishermen like the present gover does. As far as I know present gover is releasing the boats.

The only solution for this is punishing the culprits and empowering our fishermen but that has to be done by SL government.

If we let loose the fishermen within few days they will definitely come back.

MR used the TN fishermen as a pressure point and for tactical usage. Releasing the drug dealers was similar to that.

I am not saying MR's policy was the best, that is why we changed ne. Between this government depend a lot on India unlike MR. So we cannot expect a good policy and action from this government.

And RW's comment is not something to be proud of. He was a lose cannon. I dont think as a PM he should have made such a remark

Dont u remember RW's remarks against Australian government and how he belittled Abbot and his policy? Do you see a rational man behind RW?
 
.
I think u misunderstand many of MR's tactics. MR did not take strong actions against fishermen, because he did not want to create TN- Central governments issues.

But he did not release boats and fishermen like the present gover does. As far as I know present gover is releasing the boats.

The only solution for this is punishing the culprits and empowering our fishermen but that has to be done by SL government.

If we let loose the fishermen within few days they will definitely come back.

MR used the TN fishermen as a pressure point and for tactical usage. Releasing the drug dealers was similar to that.

I am not saying MR's policy was the best, that is why we changed ne. Between this government depend a lot on India unlike MR. So we cannot expect a good policy and action from this government.

And RW's comment is not something to be proud of. He was a lose cannon. I dont think as a PM he should have made such a remark

Dont u remember RW's remarks against Australian government and how he belittled Abbot and his policy? Do you see a rational man behind RW?

Where have the present govt released the boats ?? Not a single boat has been released.. The courts have ordered the owners to come over pay the fines and through the legal process and get them released.. Not a single boat has been released to date.. Can you source me otherwise ?

The govt policy of MR govt was to release the poachers as soon as possible while detaining thier boats.. It's not something the present govt came up with..

Sri Lanka : Sri Lanka not to release Indian fishermen\'s boats
The Sri Lankan government has recently adopted a policy of releasing the fishermen without their boats to deter their returns to Sri Lankan seas for poaching.
.. Dated 17th August 2014 under the MR govt

Fishermen release: Sri Lankan Prez Rajapaksa trumps Modi


Hard to fathom how most sensible poster like you seem to be getting caught to this wave of pessimism.. By all means be critical of the govt because there are a lot of reasons to be but for good reason not for some heresay

The Navy keep continuing arresting these poachers without any hindrance.. These are all under the new govt

Sri Lanka arrests 54 Indian fishermen - The Times of India

43 Indian Fishermen Arrested by Sri Lankan Navy

Sri Lankan Navy attacks 5 Indian fishermen in Rameswaram : India, News - India Today

Now about PR skills of RW and a few others is irrelevant here.. Although i completely agree with you on thier undiplomatic faux pas but thats another matter to be discussed
 
.
machan, it is always the srilankan navy attacking the fishermen, why no Indian navy attacking Srilankan fishermen, what if India constructs Ram sethu project and allows large ships to pass through the channel? and these fishermen are just employees, the boats are owned by big families like the Karunanidhis and AMMAS of tamilnadu, your govt should do what subramania swamy told you to do? just hold the boats and leave the fisher men you can auction them in open market and sell them or return them with heavy fine, why do you harass those poor fisher men, we know that you fear the return of the rouge tigers, but it is not wise to group everyone with them. even Indian navy has the potential to harass but we don't want to do that, the problem arises because both the countries sezs collide both the governments should solve the issue amicably, even in India two states namely Karnataka and Tamilnadu fight like adversaries for the kaveri river water but the only solution is compromise by both the parties, if not then there is no solution for the problem.
 
.
machan, it is always the srilankan navy attacking the fishermen, why no Indian navy attacking Srilankan fishermen, what if India constructs Ram sethu project and allows large ships to pass through the channel? and these fishermen are just employees, the boats are owned by big families like the Karunanidhis and AMMAS of tamilnadu, your govt should do what subramania swamy told you to do? just hold the boats and leave the fisher men you can auction them in open market and sell them or return them with heavy fine, why do you harass those poor fisher men, we know that you fear the return of the rouge tigers, but it is not wise to group everyone with them. even Indian navy has the potential to harass but we don't want to do that, the problem arises because both the countries sezs collide both the governments should solve the issue amicably, even in India two states namely Karnataka and Tamilnadu fight like adversaries for the kaveri river water but the only solution is compromise by both the parties, if not then there is no solution for the problem.

Thats exactly what they are doing.. Releasing the fishermen after few days of legal procedure but detaining the trawlers..

As far as compromises go there is no compromise on sovereignty and territorial integrity of SL.. As the article goes it's the duty of the Indian govt or the TN govt to provide these people with alternative ways of fishing in deeper waters or alternative living.. Thier livelyhood is not the concern of GOSL but the livelihood of northern Lankan fishermen are
 
Last edited:
.
Sri Lankan fishermen welcome Ranil’s ‘shooting’ remarks

Fishermen of the Jaffna peninsula in Sri Lanka’s Northern Province say they welcome Prime Minister Ranil Wickremasinghe’s remarks that Indian fishermen may be shot if they intruded into Sri Lankan waters.

Wickremasinghe had stirred controversy ahead of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s recent visit to Sri Lanka, when he had made the statement during an interview with an India TV channel.

He had said that the Sri Lankan navy would only be acting as per law when it fires at Indian fishermen entering Lankan waters and therefore they should keep away.

“If someone tries to break into my house, I can shoot. If he gets killed...Law allows me to do that,”
the PM had said.

V. Aruldas, President of the Vadamaraj Fishermen’s Association, stated that they welcome the Sri Lankan Prime Minister’s remarks.

He added that the Indian government imposed a 40-day ban on fishing to enable the sea to recoup its resources due to the overexploitation of their own sea resources by Indian fishermen using trawlers and banned fishing nets.


Speaking to Ada Derana, Mr Aruldas accused Indian fishermen of attempting to do the same thing in Sri Lankan waters by destroying the aquatic resources using illegal methods.

He warned that if an immediate solution is not provided to this issue, fishermen and their families in Northern Sri Lanka would have to resort to drinking poison to commit suicide. He guaranteed that this would start to happen within the next 2 months or so.

Mr Aruldas also accused the Sri Lankan Navy of supporting the Indian fishermen who are violating the maritime boundary line and illegally poaching in Sri Lankan territorial seas.

He also claimed that the frequent accusations of Sri Lankan navy personnel attacking Tamil Nadu fishermen and their boats are complete lies.

He also objected to allowing Indian fishermen to engage in poaching activities in Sri Lankan waters for a set period.

Media reports claim that during the third round of talks between representatives of fishermen of Tamil Nadu and Sri Lanka ended in Chennai last Tuesday, the Lankan fishermen agreed to Indian fishermen fishing in Sri Lankan water for 83 days per year.

Mr Aruldas stated that Indian fishermen are not suitable to be given such an opportunity as they would resort trawling and using banned fishing nets during that period, thereby harming aquatic resources in Sri Lankan seas.
 
.
I think u misunderstand many of MR's tactics. MR did not take strong actions against fishermen, because he did not want to create TN- Central governments issues.

But he did not release boats and fishermen like the present gover does. As far as I know present gover is releasing the boats.

The only solution for this is punishing the culprits and empowering our fishermen but that has to be done by SL government.

If we let loose the fishermen within few days they will definitely come back.

MR used the TN fishermen as a pressure point and for tactical usage. Releasing the drug dealers was similar to that.

I am not saying MR's policy was the best, that is why we changed ne. Between this government depend a lot on India unlike MR. So we cannot expect a good policy and action from this government.

And RW's comment is not something to be proud of. He was a lose cannon. I dont think as a PM he should have made such a remark

Dont u remember RW's remarks against Australian government and how he belittled Abbot and his policy? Do you see a rational man behind RW?

Well ?? Where have they changed the policy of detaining the boats ?

Indian fishermen regret SL President’s stand ::: Dailymirror.lk ::: Breaking News

Indian fishermen’s associations today expressed regret over Sri Lankan President Maithripala Sirisena’s remark that he has clearly instructed the island nation’s navy to seize boats that violate the country’s territorial waters.

Fishermen’s Association leaders N. J. Bose and N. Devadass told reporters here that these remarks were regrettable, coming at a time when the next round of their talks are to be held in Colombo to sort out the issue and that the Sri Lankan President should reconsider his stand.

The Indian fishermen claimed that they had a right to fish in these waters.

Sri Lankan Opposition group National Freedom Front had alleged that the government had given fishing rights to Indians in Sri Lankan waters as an ‘appeasement’ policy towards India.

“We have not allowed fishing in our waters for the Indians. I have given clear instructions to navy to arrest boats or trawlers that violate our water limits,” Sirisena had told a gathering of fishing industry and political representatives last night.

The two countries held fishermen-level talks in Chennai last month. (PTI) -
 
.
Thats exactly what they are doing.. Releasing the fishermen after few days of legal procedure but detaining the trawlers..

As far as compromises go there is no compromise on sovereignty and territorial integrity of SL.. As the article goes it's the duty of the Indian govt or the TN govt to provide these people with alternative ways of fishing in deeper waters or alternative living.. Thier livelyhood is not the concern of GOSL but the livelihood of northern Lankan fishermen are

Sri Lanka is not detaining any trawlers. Under Ranil and Sirisena they are releasing Indian fishermen and all trawlers.

Sri Lanka is compromising on sovereignty and the territorial integrity of the island by allowing swarms of Tamil Nadu fisherman to poach in Sri Lankan waters.

Well ?? Where have they changed the policy of detaining the boats ?

Indian fishermen regret SL President’s stand ::: Dailymirror.lk ::: Breaking News

Indian fishermen’s associations today expressed regret over Sri Lankan President Maithripala Sirisena’s remark that he has clearly instructed the island nation’s navy to seize boats that violate the country’s territorial waters.

Fishermen’s Association leaders N. J. Bose and N. Devadass told reporters here that these remarks were regrettable, coming at a time when the next round of their talks are to be held in Colombo to sort out the issue and that the Sri Lankan President should reconsider his stand.

The Indian fishermen claimed that they had a right to fish in these waters.

Sri Lankan Opposition group National Freedom Front had alleged that the government had given fishing rights to Indians in Sri Lankan waters as an ‘appeasement’ policy towards India.

“We have not allowed fishing in our waters for the Indians. I have given clear instructions to navy to arrest boats or trawlers that violate our water limits,” Sirisena had told a gathering of fishing industry and political representatives last night.

The two countries held fishermen-level talks in Chennai last month. (PTI) -

The president says one thing and does another. What is certain is that he has released all the Indian fishermen and trawlers captured to date. Indian fishermen continue to poach in Sri Lankan waters and the navy does nothing.
 
.
The Indian have banned Beef they should also ban all meat consumption. The fishes also have life and Indian should stop eating seafood especially caught illegally from neighboring countries maritime limits. The Indian fisherman are caught fishing illegally in Pakistani, Bangladeshi and Sri Lankan waters. Does only the cow has life ? What about fish ? Especially the fishes within the Sri Lankan maritime boundary ? May be Pakistanis, Bangladeshis and Sri Lanlans could also go into India and slaughter cows and bring back beef to their countries.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom