Israel: "Iran Can Build 1 Bomb"

[Pasban]

May be Iran shouldn't have nuclear and missile program which is Israel specific.

How are we to say it does and how are we to say that Israel does not?

 

[MYSTIC]

China, India and Pakistan all have nuclear weapons... and they all have a stake in disputed Kashmir. We have fought wars against each other. Why did India develop nuclear weapons? In their own words, because of China.

Cannot compare the two situation. Where there any tensions between India and China to scale of Israel and Iran when India started its nuclear program. It had tasted bitter defeat at the hands of China in 62' which led to the creation of the nuclear program. Don't forget that India and Pakistan's nuclear program led to sanctions on our countries.

Personally I see more threat to Israel from militants rather than states, and even then, Gaza/Syria/Lebanon/PA are all bigger threats to Israel than Iran is.

But Iran wants to play a much bigger role.

Has it even been proven that Iran have a nuclear weapons programme?

They have bought the technology from their neighbor and have the raw materials. So the correct question is will/ should they? My answer is they should not.

 

[MYSTIC]

How are we to say it does and how are we to say that Israel does not?

It is your President who is giving hate speeches left, right and center. Can Iran be a responsible nuclear state?

 

[Pasban]

It is your President who is giving hate speeches left, right and center. Can Iran be a responsible nuclear state?

If you wish, I can quote speeches to you from Israel's leadership. Also do quote for me at least some of the recent 'hate' speeches. I fail to understand your double standards in viewing one as being more responsible than the other though. Iran for one hasn't invaded another state in modern times. Israel has in this regard been more aggressive and expansionist. Israel's occupation and military adventures in southern Lebanon brought about the birth of Hezbollah. Can a state so willing to flex it's military muscle be a responsible nuclear state? Also, the state that refers to itself as being the most responsible nuclear power is the one which has used it's ability twice on civilian populations.

 

[humanfirst]

I think iran have the right to develop nukes.They must be idiots if they use nukes on a country with 200+ nukes but having nukes will make sure that no one will dare to attack them.
@t rex
Haven't muslims invaded and occupied 1000x more land than jews ever did?Doesn't muslims believe that one day islam will conquer the entire world?Jews were original inhabitants of jerusalem,their holy land much before advent of islam.And they believe they have the right to own that little piece of land.I believe the demand of latter is more reasonable than former.

 

[Ghostwhowalks]

One question to all the Pakistani members....it seems every news agency from the west- Fox, CNN, BBC, Reuters are biased, zionist mouthpieces....so what according to you guys is an unbiased news agency/service? it would help to know so that in future people could try to post links from there only, thereby not consuming unnecessary bandwith of this forum

 

[jha]

This is all talk..How could he possibly know that Iran has Uranium for exactly one bomb...?This is him just being paranoid..

 

[Ahmad]

Israel havin Nuclear wepons doesn't blabber abt wiping anybody oof the face of earth nor it has ever said to use this on any other nation

So nuclear wepons in the hand of israel is very diffrent story as compared to that with Iran

Israel is already wiping an entire nation from the face of the earth, very systematically and with the help of civilized world!!! If you turn a blind eye then that is not the others problem. Iran might or might not say to wipe israel, just empty words, but israel is actually doing what iran is saying.

 

[Ahmad]

It is your President who is giving hate speeches left, right and center. Can Iran be a responsible nuclear state?

responsible nuke state? what is that mate? the only responsible state is the one which doesnt have it!! if you have nukes, then you will use it if you see the needs, simple as that. didnt america flatten japan with nukes and killed hundreds of thousands of civilians in a matter of mintues? israel dont need to use nukes, cuz it is already a capable military power, but in case if they see the need, they will surely use it.

 

[Ahmad]

Word of advice try putting national interest before religon

do you give the same advice to the zioinists who come from different countries but have the same goal?

 

[MYSTIC]

responsible nuke state? what is that mate? the only responsible state is the one which doesnt have it!! if you have nukes, then you will use it if you see the needs, simple as that. didnt america flatten japan and killed hundreds of thousands of civilians in a matter of mintues? israel dont need to use nukes, cuz it is already a capable military power, but in case if they see the need, they will surely use it.

No. My country has a 'no first use' policy for nuclear war heads. That means it will not use its nuclear weapons unless it is used by the opponents. A responsible nuclear state is one which does not give away its technology to other.

Israel needs nukes because no one country can be stopped from being a very strong conventional military power. Israel is surrounded by enemies on all sides. Nuclear deterrence is required for Israel's own existence. Why does Iran need nuclear weapons?

 

[Pasban]

No. My country has a 'no first use' policy for nuclear war heads. That means it will not use its nuclear weapons unless it is used by the opponents. A responsible nuclear state is one which does not give away its technology to other.

Israel needs nukes because no one country can be stopped from being a very strong conventional military power. Israel is surrounded by enemies on all sides. Nuclear deterrence is required for Israel's own existence. Why does Iran need nuclear weapons?

Iran, if she intends to equip herself with these, would then need them for the very same reason Israel does by your own above logic. Let's also include the fact that Iran has been threatened with nuclear weapons (see link).

Consortiumnews.com

 

[Ahmad]

No. My country has a 'no first use' policy for nuclear war heads. That means it will not use its nuclear weapons unless it is used by the opponents. A responsible nuclear state is one which does not give away its technology to other.

Israel needs nukes because no one country can be stopped from being a very strong conventional military power. Israel is surrounded by enemies on all sides. Nuclear deterrence is required for Israel's own existence. Why does Iran need nuclear weapons?

you are very concerned about the existence of israel, what can you say about the existence of palestine which is taken away from them everyday?

 

[MYSTIC]

you are very concerned about the existence of israel, what can you say about the existence of palestine which is taken away from them everyday?

No I am concerned about co-existence of both the groups. So should you.

 

[Ahmad]

No I am concerned about co-existence of both the groups. So should you.

abolutely i am. but it is israel which is wiping out palestine from the face of the earth.