Pakistan did not fare any better- in fact it turned out to be infinitely worse. Created as the result of a minority’s demand, it soon discarded Jinnah’s repeated invocations for what can only be described as a secular state and slipped into majoritarianism far worse than what Jinnah had apprehended in United India.
We created this state to get rid of the idolatry of secularism and ethnic nationalism. The author is a secular/liberal bigot, serving agenda of his western kafir masters.
In 1956 we became an Islamic Republic, the world’s first of its kind, and then in 1973 we added Islam as the state religion.
And we are proud of this fact. We dont need a secular state. The seculars who want to live in a secular state can shift back to secular Bharat Maata.
The offices of the President and Prime Minister were closed to Non-Muslims. In essence Non-Muslims were relegated to second class status and after General Zia ulHaq took over, they effectively became third class citizens at best.
The author is forgetting that we get rid of Hindu's because we didnt wanted to be ruled by a Non Muslim. That was the reason behind partition and that huge loss of life. But, a liberal cant understand this because he has effectively rejected Islam and it's basic teachings and adopted a narrative of Kufaar.
One particular group, the one even our Prime Minister is too scared to name, was systematically disenfranchised and for all practical purposes is stateless.
Qadiyanis were disenfranchised because they are enemies of Rasool Allah (P.B.U.H) and His Deen. This state is created for Rasool Allah P.B.U.H and His deen, His enemies will surely be sidelined in every way possible.
So it is extraordinary that the President of Pakistan, the great dentist Arif Alvi, can give an interview to a Canadian news outlet and suggest without any sense of irony that secularity of India is being burnt.
He is an idiot. We shouldnt be worried about secularity of anyone.
For His Excellency it is submitted that Pakistan seems to have begun to burn its own secularity in March 1949 with the Objectives’ Resolution. By the 1980s, Pakistan spread those ashes in the Indus river and for all practical purposes became a full blown theocracy.
As expected, liberals are full of hate against Islam and it's ideals. Secondly, they are worst lairs and distorter. This liberal idiot doesnt even understand the meaning of theocracy and it's historic relevance. Basically, they have read books of their kafir masters and started applying the same terminologies to Islamic state without studying and understanding Islamic system.
There is no theocracy or priesthood in Islam or Islamic state. It is a purely western concept which is utterly irrelevant to Islam. There is no pope, no priesthood in Islam. We Muslims are followers of Quran and Sunnah and unlike Christianity we are not bound to follow any Pope, Imam, Molvi or priest in beliefs. Our beliefs are directly derived from Quran and Sunnah and unlike Roman Catholics and Qadiyanis, no Molvi can declare that "I am the representative of God on earth, follow me'.
These liberals are ignorant of highest order, who cant understand basic facts.
How then can President Alvi and Prime Minister Khan complain about the demise of Indian secularism?
They shouldn't claim that. Moreover, we always believed that this is the fight of two religions, two ideologies, two different way of livings. Now, it is proving right in the face of emerging Hindutva nationalism.
How can Islamic Republic which forecloses the right of Non-Muslim Pakistanis from becoming President or Prime Minister complain about India’s treatment of its minorities? How can you complain about Hindutva when you are yourself an Islamic Republic which denotes an exclusivist ideology that presupposes only Muslims have the right to govern Pakistan?
We should realize the fact that these liberals are traitors and are serving under the guidance of their kafir masters. They are our real internal enemies, due to their hatred of Islam. They have soft corners for Qadiyanis and they will do everything in their power to destroy Islamic republic of Pakistan. We should also keep in mind that there will be no Pakistan after the destruction of Islamic republic of Pakistan
The only interpretation of his explanation possible is that in his view it is okay for Pakistan to be an Islamic Republic but not for India to be Hindu Republic because Islam is obviously better than Hinduism.
Of course it is better. The one who believes otherwise can only be a Kafir or Murtad.
At least Maulana Maududi and other Ulema were fairer than Prime Minister Khan, when they conceded to Munir-Kayani Commission in the 1950s that they wanted an Islamic State even if India became a Hindu state based on laws of Manu and Muslims were mistreated in India.
They were right. We will not accept anything other than an Islamic state.
That is a consistent vision – we will persecute our minorities and you may persecute your minorities
These liberals are not attacking Islamic republic of Pakistan but Islam itself. They believe that Islam allows minorities to be persecuted. We should understand their real agenda.
Yet I think one of the reasons India, still secular and democratic on paper, can get away with it is because Pakistan is rightly viewed by the world as a bankrupt theocracy. For the Muslim only President and the Muslim only Prime Minister of Pakistan to cry foul about the ideology of Hindu supremacy in India is nothing less than rank hypocrisy. Only a modern, secular democratic Pakistan based on Jinnah’s 11 August speech can fight for Kashmir and win it.
These idiots only see the one side of picture, which is favourable to their idolatry of secularism. Pakistan will not and can not become a secular republic. This is like signing a death warrant for Pakistan and they wanted to do that. Inshallah, they and their masters will be humiliated by God.
That obviously is not going to happen at least in our lifetimes and therefore we can pretty much kiss Kashmir goodbye. No world tribunal will ever take our complaints on the matter seriously. The best outcome in this scenario would be for the Indian Supreme Court to strike down Modi government’s action of 5 August.
Again, the mentality of secularist to link all problems they have to religion.
Things will then go back to as they were and Pakistan can go back to persecuting Non-Muslims in Pakistan without too big a burden on its conscience.
By non Muslims he means his qadiyani brothers.
Meanwhile India can slowly slide into the same majoritarian trap that we did decades ago. The world is never going to be a better place for the people who were unfortunate enough to be born in this subcontinent. Tragic but this is unfortunately the world we live in.
Thank God, we are not living in a Secular Pakistan.
In the end i would like to quote the great Iqbal so that liberals can burn some more.
"Islam is more than a creed, it is also a community, a nation"
"Nationalism is a subtle form of idolatry, a defecation of material object"
"It is the eternal mission of Muslims to protest against idolatry in all its forms"
@Khafee @war&peace @Wa Muhammada @Pan-Islamic-Pakistan
