Is Punjabi a mere dialect of Hindi?

[vegav]

I bet Punjabi existed before Hindi so this question dont make sense

sanskrit & prakrit were the original languages,punjabi is a recent language but definitely older than the random languages called hindi & urdu.

There was no evidence, just watch Modi speak hindi and see how he bucther pure words. Indians can't pronounce sh/s, z/j, ph/p etc properly to save their lives. Thats why Indian english accent is most horrible accent.

Modi didn't get good formal education,why dont u listen to Gulzar/Piyush Mishra talk.

The worst accent i have heard is syed tariq pirzada's american+punjabi accented english,u never know which one ll show up.

Shamain, Shamain your going to expose my weakness. You should by now know my Urdu is well "derelict" to put it mildly so your making me feel ignorent .....

@save_ghenda Everything, civilization, language, even Rig Vedic religion spread from our Indus land ( Pakistan ) east into their Ganges land ( India ).

Yet they talk as if they gave us everything ......

it was not your land then.

 

[deepak.chauhan2312]

Actually all the languages spoken in the world today are mere dialect of Sanskrit. The genus Homo have migrated out of Ganges planes and every human is originally Hindu.

sir do you think that the language have any relation with religion?As by your words you seem to have confused with religion and language.

Modi didn't get good formal education,why dont u listen to Gulzar/Piyush Mishra talk.
.

Is it true ?

 

[Indus Pakistan]

sanskrit & prakrit were the original languages,punjabi is a recent language but definitely older than the random languages called hindi & urdu.

I have asked ( searched ) and it appears "Prakrit" is not a language. All it means is "dialect" thus seams to be attempt to enforce uniformity on what was multiple differant languages. By using the word "Prakrit" allows all to be bunched togather as one. False creation of homogenous of heterogenous group.

it was not your land then.

Right, let me guess it was yours and I fell off Mars spaceship in 1947?