Is it right to attack South Waziristan now?

[Mujambeel]

Is it right to attack south waziristan now?

 

[arihant]

Is it right to attack south waziristan now?

What you mean by attack ? Is south waziristan a part of waziristan and if yes, why you need to attack your own state.

 

[nightrider_saulat]

What you mean by attack ? Is south waziristan a part of waziristan and if yes, why you need to attack your own state.

he mean to say liberate it from ruthless taliban's regime

 

[nightrider_saulat]

absolutely not as winter is coming at it'speak in soiuth waziristan
and there is expected to have heavy snowfall at the start of the next month so in this harsh conditions it would be difficult for the army to mobilize such a large attack composed of 2 divisions...and plus it wuld also be difficult for air force to drop laser-guided munition under such harsh snowfall season......
in all case it is going it is to be the most bloodiest COIN sincre 2004 in FATA.....according to analysis of zaid hamid army's death toll since the end of the operations in bajaur and malakand was 100 in bajaur and 300 in malakand
it is expected to be atleast 1000 army losses if operation is going to happen in this moment.....surely militants' loss will be 7-10 times more then this.....
but after GHQ fall out we have no other choice left but to only to re-launch operation rah-e-nijat

 

[batmannow]

absolutely not as winter is coming at it'speak in soiuth waziristan
and there is expected to have heavy snowfall at the start of the next month so in this harsh conditions it would be difficult for the army to mobilize such a large attack composed of 2 divisions...and plus it wuld also be difficult for air force to drop laser-guided munition under such harsh snowfall season......
in all case it is going it is to be the most bloodiest COIN sincre 2004 in FATA.....according to analysis of zaid hamid army's death toll since the end of the operations in bajaur and malakand was 100 in bajaur and 300 in malakand
it is expected to be atleast 1000 army losses if operation is going to happen in this moment.....surely militants' loss will be 7-10 times more then this.....
but after GHQ fall out we have no other choice left but to only to re-launch operation rah-e-nijat

SURE!

BUTonly after the USA , s clearnces over KLR bill! only!!!

 

[Silverfalcon]

They should not immediately start the operation , diplomatic talks , peace deals must be done with the American funded militants over there.

Remember that we have to finish the supply line of these American funded militants.

But let's say if they decide on starting the operation they should also destroy all Indian bases which are a few kilometers away from South-Waziristan.

 

[nightrider_saulat]

SURE!

BUTonly after the USA , s clearnces over KLR bill! only!!!

if we will wait till then th clearance of K-l bill then we will again face
two or more yesterday's GHQ like attack
......so finally no more delays
launch the operation within upcoming two days
or then never again........
delays would give remaining taliban operatives in punjab to react once more again even more violently.....

 

[nightrider_saulat]

They should not immediately start the operation , diplomatic talks , peace deals must be done with the American funded militants over there.

Remember that we have to the supply line of these American funded militants.

But let's say if they decide on starting the operation they should also destroy all Indian bases which are a few kilometers away from South-Waziristan.

one reason for the success of malakand operation was that
because whole the valley was surrounded from all four sides....and no escape route was left for taliban to flew away.......
so in this manner...they were all shot dead like sitting ducks.....

but in this waziristan case you can't just blocked them from all four sides just because on the west sides there is afghanistan...and do you think that america would allow us to send our troops for complete blockedge there.....
and you know one thing about taliban that they one simple war strategy "hit ans run"
.....so they will hit you and then on the same time would ran awat back to indian consulates on durand line......
this battle isn't going ti be so simple like swat and bajaur

 

[Spring Onion]

The operation is now coming sooner than later in South Waziristan. But for sucess of such operation, US, NATO, CIA has to stop sending terrorists from Afghanistan into Pakistan.


On the other hand we will have to be very very careful.

We need to target TTP and eleminate it completly.

Its time to launch an operation against Laskhar-e-Jhangvi too. Most of fodder for suicide bombing is coming from LJ from Punjab.

 

[Zee-Gen]

In my opinion the attack on GHQ has its other significances. The Waziristan operation is due everybody knows so why terrorists attack GHQ if they know that the possible retaliation is operation Waziristan? It is like they are asking why you are not starting Waziristan operation……coalition forces have been withdrawn from Paktika province of Afghanistan. The question is why coalition forces have decided a withdrawal even if they know what Pakistan is going to do and it is important to block terrorists from both sides?. I think our enemy wants to engage our forces in Waziristan and as there are no coalition force in Paktika it might be a long operation in terms of time and there is another aspect, which is, to make this operation fruitful we have to withdraw some of our troops from our Indian border, which is not in favor of Pakistan. Swat operation is still in progress, Indian forces are at our border, refusal of KLB is possible, which will impact our economy, and our nation wants’ Waziristan operation, these are all the point on which army is thinking right now and I think this might be the cause of possible delay in Waziristan operation.

 

[pak-marine]

"attack on waziristan" this term is inappropriate and shouldnt be used as it insults our brave tribals who are before any thing are pakistanis ,they are a part of this motherland and our brothers .This war looms on Taliban and their tatoos hopefully a final blow to Al Qaida and Taliban presence in the region.

 

[pakdefender]

We need to start pounding day in and day out ANY area from where these rats are operating from. They are enemies of the state and we have to go all out against them.

 

[pakdefender]

The Air Froce today swung into action in South Waziristan Agency killing 13 terrorists

13 extremists killed in SWA operation

 

[pakdefender]

The stratergy of the armed forces to eliminate terrorists from North and South Waziristan should be to to attack them in a slow steady and sutained manner not in an all out rush.

 

[pakdefender]

When we go after the rats hiding in SWA and NWA we will also have to go after the sympathizers that have businesses and properties in the developed areas of Pakistan and people in places where they can pass on sensitive information to them about impending opreations

Bank Accounts , Properties , Houses , Businesses , Jobs we have to fight this a all fronts to deny terrorists , their financers and sypanthisers within the country any chance to inflict harm to Pakistan. Once we have dealt with the intenal collaborators we will have to hit the external ones also.

This fight is not a 'clean' fight , its going to be very dirty one and we will have to kill them off in piece meal manner.

Im very pissed off after the attack on GHQ and I , like many patriotic Pakistans, want retribution for this