Is India Better-off With Partition?

[A.R.]

Muhammad Aslam Khan Khattak was also one of the greatest Pakhtun leader. He was the President of Pakistan Movement in U.K with Dr. Abdur Rahim as Vice President and Chaudhry Rehmat Ali as Secretary. This Organisation gave the world the name "PAKISTAN".

All the 4 provinces of Pakistan and Bengal decided in a referendum to be part of Pakistan in 1947. The people of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa dont share anything with bharatis, nothing at all. The majority chose Pakistan over india in 1947 and thats why they're a province of Pakistan. You are south indian what do you know what the people of Pakistan wanted or not, one man's opinion does not count as millions of people who voted in the referendum to join Pakistan.

By the way, Pakhtuns all over the world are very proud of the fact that they defeated the Soviet Union (the former superpower). If Pakistan was part of india, india would've never helped U.S. but allowed Soviets to control Afghanistan, and even allow the Soviets to use the soil of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to easily control Afghanistan. And it is a known fact that people of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and other parts of Pakistan were involved in the jihad against the Soviets in Afghanistan.

And no thanks we dont even want a EU style union with bharat. No union at all. Accept Pakistan as a sovereign independent nation, thats all.

you should know what is going on world politics... Do you know why EU nations felt a need to form a union.... They were the worst fighters.. and england and france did fight a famous hundred years of war.. still they are in one union....
?
?
they want to dominate the world once again... and there size are very small to fullfill there ambitions... so they gets united.. to check the power of USA and China.... and still they each are sovereign independent nation...

china and japan along with other SE asian nations also conducted meeting to have a union and common currency like EU...

India do not want to lag behind these powers... if we fail to bring all south asian countries on the same stage... I have faith on my leaders they will find some alternate......

...India might have a collaboration with South Africa, Brazil and other friendly developing nations to have a common currency....

 

[kugga]

But if partiotion had not occured there wont have any Muslim State.... That's the best we have achieved through partition.... People call Pakistan a Muslim state...... and we feel really proud when some one call us a muslim...... Muslims of india are not enjoying this feeling.....

Our Identity in the world is as a Muslim State and that's the biggest achievement.........

Hats off to MA Jinnah..

 

[Omar1984]

you should know what is going on world politics... Do you know why EU nations felt a need to form a union.... They were the worst fighters.. and england and france did fight a famous hundred years of war.. still they are in one union....
?
?
they want to dominate the world once again... and there size are very small to fullfill there ambitions... so they gets united.. to check the power of USA and China.... and still they each are sovereign independent nation...

china and japan along with other SE asian nations also conducted meeting to have a union and common currency like EU...

India do not want to lag behind these powers... if we fail to bring all south asian countries on the same stage... I have faith on my leaders they will find some alternate......

...India might have a collaboration with South Africa, Brazil and other friendly developing nations to have a common currency....

Europe united because they have such a small population in their countries and they all share the same ideology, they are the same people, the same religion, the same beliefs, the same race, the same everything except languages. Turkey is not included in EU even though Turkey is part of Europe. Why is that? Maybe because Turkey has a Majority Muslim population

-European Union

Area
- Total 4,324,782 km2
1,669,807 sq mi
- Water (&#37 3.08
Population
- 2010 estimate 501,259,840
- Density 115.9/km2
300.2/sq mi

Even when such a large continent is united, they still dont even make half of india's total population.

Keep your india to yourself. No one wants a EU style union or any kind of union with india. your country is itself more than twice the population of whole of Europe united.

 

[A.R.]

Europe united because they have such a small population in their countries and they all share the same ideology, they are the same people, the same religion, the same beliefs, the same race, the same everything except languages. Turkey is not included in EU even though Turkey is part of Europe. Why is that? Maybe because Turkey has a Majority Muslim population

-European Union

Area
- Total 4,324,782 km2
1,669,807 sq mi
- Water (&#37 3.08
Population
- 2010 estimate 501,259,840
- Density 115.9/km2
300.2/sq mi

Even when such a large continent is united, they still dont even make half of india's total population.

Keep your india to yourself. No one wants a EU style union or any kind of union with india. your country is itself more than twice as populated as whole of Europe united.

who's going to unite with pakistan... it will only bring mor poverty.. fundamantalism... unstability... etc...

I did said the collaboration of other friendly develoving stable nations... such as South Africa, Brazil, some latin countries...

and thats too for economy... not at the cost of sovereignty.....

truly India do not needs you ..... you are already a biggest headache Of India...

 

[harish]

Europe united because they have such a small population in their countries and they all share the same ideology, they are the same people, the same religion, the same beliefs, the same race, the same everything except languages. Turkey is not included in EU even though Turkey is part of Europe. Why is that? Maybe because Turkey has a Majority Muslim population

I am sorry to say sir but your argument displays two marked fallacies. (1) Your complete ignorance about the socio-religious-anthropological dynamics of the European people and their history (which incidentally post-date ours by a few thousand years of civilization); and (2) Your self-inflicted Islam/Non-Islam centric polarisation on the European caucus. Please read up on European history, their anthropology and genetic drift, and their religious foment down the ages, not to mention broad generalisations like 'same ideology', 'same beliefs', and 'same everything', before professing to lump the entire continent under the comfortable umbrella of 'same people.' Dont get me wrong. I am not a reunification fan either. Far from it. But to an unbiased eye, all the reasons you quote for the EU being a reality, actually make a far stronger case for a unified subcontinent being a reality. And on the issue of same religion bonds, Europe spilled a lot of Christian blood down the ages and two great wars before the EU became a reality. On the other hand, Hindus and Muslims lived together as one people for a thousand years till as recently as 6 decades ago. And still do on the successful side of the divide when you get right down to it. Think about it my friend.

 

[amoverlord]

what kind of discussion is this?????
no use of discussing WHAT IF.....
what we can do is to make india developed,powerful n prosperous to an extent that others will be desperate to be a part of it........

and to indian members-----no use of arguing with this so called elite member.....i haven\'t seen anybody more blockheaded....

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Bull crap thread.
I wish mods dispose this thread which is nothong but a big wet dream of inf. indians.

 

[Justin Joseph]

Bull crap thread.
I wish mods dispose this thread which is nothong but a big wet dream of inf. indians.

Yes, it is crap thread.

And also does not have to do with India defense.

But it's Pakistani member who have started wet dreams like 1000 year ruled like crap.

This thread should be deleted or closed.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Yes, it is crap thread.

And also does not have to do with India defense.

But it's Pakistani member who have started wet dreams like 1000 year ruled like crap.

This thread should be deleted or closed.

Reality cant be changed or refuted just by calling crap.
Decendents of mughals live in Pakistan as well as pushtuns,jatts and rajputs so technically these people ruled u more then just 1000 years.
You Dig>?

 

[Chill Bihari]

Reality cant be changed or refuted just by calling crap.
Decendents of mughals live in Pakistan as well as pushtuns,jatts and rajputs so technically these people ruled u more then just 1000 years.
You Dig>?

Well what u r saying is just figments of ur dull imagination which u brew again and again to veil ur frustration at being in shambles and watching Ur mother India , of whom u r all estranged and wayward children marching ahead towards prosperity and peace.
Btw what stopped ur 1000 year rule on India, Shivaji made u impotent.
Too happy to be lackeys of China,stoneheaded neighbours of ours.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Well what u r saying is just figments of ur dull imagination which u brew again and again to veil ur frustration at being in shambles and watching Ur mother India , of whom u r all estranged and wayward children marching ahead towards prosperity and peace.
Btw what stopped ur 1000 year rule on India, Shivaji made u impotent.
Too happy to be lackeys of China,stoneheaded neighbours of ours.

Lol my imagination?
Werent u under muslim rule for 1000 years?
Were rajputs ur masters?
Didnt pushtuns invade india?
If we go at ur retarded theory where did we come from?Saudi arabia?
Sivaji made whom impotent?
In tht case indians were a bunch of impotents for a 1000 years???
And after independence u became lackeys of the communit russians??
And our saffron buniya minded neighbours?
About us being lackeys of the chinese?
Dumo when we befriended the chinese they were called addicts and world made fun of them?and now when they have become a regional power,Some @ssh..les are now shitting there pants.
Shamefull sad little man.

 

[ramu]

Pakistan Nationalist, Muslims is not equal to Pakistan.

1000 years of Muslim rule on undivided India :/: Pakistan ruled India for 1000 years.

So let us not get too excited here.




http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Large_States_in_Pre-Colonial_India.gif

 

[Chill Bihari]

Lol my imagination?
Werent u under muslim rule for 1000 years?
Were rajputs ur masters?
Didnt pushtuns invade india?
If we go at ur retarded theory where did we come from?Saudi arabia?
Sivaji made whom impotent?
In tht case indians were a bunch of impotents for a 1000 years???
And after independence u became lackeys of the communit russians??
And our saffron buniya minded neighbours?
About us being lackeys of the chinese?
Dumo when we befriended the chinese they were called addicts and world made fun of them?and now when they have become a regional power,Some @ssh..les are now shitting there pants.
Shamefull sad little man.

Dont know what u have learned in ur madarsas, So cant argue with ur sources of information.U have been dissected once and with India's support wait till Afghanistan stands on its own and get ready to part with Balochistan as well.We know how capable u are in ruling ur own Islamic nation,so get out of ur mullahs propaganda of ruling India.Rather living in illusional history of 1000 years work for ur country which does'nt even have next years imports reserves.

 

[Kabir Panthi]

Firangi jee, that is an unfair. I am sure there must be budding APJ Abdul Kalams in Hyderabad and Aligarh also. Furthermore, there are bigots in all religions.

There may be some justified concerns about certain theological belief systems ... but most people just want to be good human beings.

Furthermore, logic is always more powerful than blind belief.

Many are unaware about the problematic aspects of their religions, or even if they are aware, choose to ignore those aspects. Some may even use their own logic and consciously disavow those problematic aspects.

The concept of Brainwashed Muslims is a myth.. Its a choice they make for themselves.. Go figure what is being taught to thousands of young brains in the madarasaas of Hyderabads and Aligarhs in India..

 

[CONNAN]

IS THIS REALLY NECESSARY NOW