the question must be why not finance this movie and finance the junks like Ekhrajiha and the ones that come after it that portrayed our soldiers as greedy retard thieves and criminals ?
ask you do you deny the story behind "A Separation" is a theme you can frequently can be seen n our society .
Do you remember this movie
can you tell me why this movie attracted so much of viewers that they selected it as the best movie
can you tell me why this become the best selling movie of the year ?
now tell me if you want to evaluate the movie as you evaluate how you evaluate Farhadi movies what was the results?
خوب بگذار من در این مورد اونچه که بهرام بیضایی در مورد دو فیلم خودش توی سینمای ایران گفته را پست کنم.
http://www.tajrobehmag.com/article/1074/
Do you knew how many movie is made that criticize Vietnam or Iraq war do you knew ow many movie make mockery of American political systems , how many attack American financial and banking systems .
and all of them are made y Americans.
also you claim we won't produce 10s of movie against each movie that criticize Iran society that praise it as the best in the world.
there couldn't be any bigger lie about Ekhrajiha, and it shows how biased your view point is.
Ekhrajiha is a comedy, it's natural to put an idiot character in a comedy movie, it's based on true story, about a gang and his members who volunteer for the war because of their private cause, this movie shows the evolve of their character, and how in the end they sacrifice their life for their country.
Yet director shows the reality of our war and soldiers in the background. we see an army colonel who has lost his leg in the war, yet to serve his country again, hides his identity and joins as an ordinary volunteer. We see volunteer who throws himself on a grenade to save his comrades.
And this is the diferrence between a patriot director and a traitor one like Farhadi.
You said Separation is a common subject between families, so I ask how many percent of those seperations is because of migration?
Director chooses the migration cause he wants to tell bright and healthy people in Iran want to migrate, Iran is an unlivable place (according to the dialog) if the husband doesn't doesn't want to leave, it's not because he doesn't want to, but because of his sick father.
we see religious families (those who don't wanna leave the coutry) as cunny, poor, misrable, and full of tension.
What do we see outside of these two families? Accident in Street, loan sharks lined up to seize the compensation money from the poor family, cold, crowded judicial system, and of course an unevitable seperation and the doomed condition of the child. Nothing positive, just darkness.
And finally the accident which a pregnant woman is hurt by the door, it's a sarcasm to Shiah beliefs about the daughter of Prophet.
So I do have enough reason when I call Farhadi as a traitor, I do mean every letter in the word traitor.
If farhadi's film became a success, it's due to the heavy propaganda both from inside and outside, it was because of a fake advertised competition between Seperation and Ekhrajiha (which same media were talking against), people were wondering if the movie was a match for the popular title "Ekhrajiha".
The funny thing about the people who slam the Ekhrajiha with the excuse of defending our soldiers is that they are the same people who insult the basijis and our soldiers in Iraq and Syria.
Apparently hypocracy has no limit in this world.
