What's new

Iran warns India: Speed-up assistance or lose Chabahar

Edevelop

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 2, 2007
Messages
14,735
Reaction score
23
Country
Pakistan
Location
Turkey
Now out of the harsh Western sanctions, Iran has hinted to India that it could lose out on Chabahar port and the associated railway line to Zahedan if there was further delay by New Delhi in providing monetary support for them.

“A number of economic projects with Iran are required to be implemented at the earliest. The Iranian government has stressed to us at high levels the urgency to extend the necessary financial support for these projects without further delay,” India’s foreign ministry informed the linked ministries last week.

While scheduling an inter-ministerial meeting — to be chaired by Foreign Secretary — later this week, the Ministry of External Affairs told the ministries to consider expediting the lines of credit under consideration as well as altering the existing payment mechanism for crude oil imports.

“Separately, the lifting of sanctions will require modifications in the existing arrangements for payment for India’s oil imports from Iran,” it wrote. The agreement would need to be amended to allow Iranians to collect their entire payment in dollars as the existing one allows 45 per cent of the dues to be paid in rupees.

India’s urgency to arrive at a favourable response follows the planned visit of Iran’s Deputy Foreign Minister for Asia & Pacific Ebrahim Rahimpour on February 4 to hold Foreign Office Consultations with the MEA.

Just days after the US lifted the sanctions, Iranian envoy Gholamreza Ansari said that India’s Iran policy was marked by unnecessary caution and that New Delhi could not follow the policy of patient waiting any more in the changed circumstances.

“I feel private companies in India are keen to move ahead in the Chabahar port project but the government has not shown the same level of enthusiasm in the past,” he said.

Since last August, Iran has been asking for $345 million as credit for the steel/railway project and $150 million for equipment purchases for Chabahar port. However, these loans got delayed following India’s Exim Bank’s refusal to get directly involved during the tenure of western sanctions.

India, in principle, agreed to provide buyer’s credit under the National Export Insurance Account (NEIA) for the steel/rail projects but that got stalled as Finance Ministry wanted more clarity on its “strategic importance” as well as the “Indian content” to make available concessional finance to Indian firms.

On Chabahar port, the Shipping Ministry moved a Cabinet note for providing $150 million as line of credit but that got held up as India wanted that the draft contract retain a reference to India content.

New Delhi has already delayed concluding the commercial contract for the port — considered both a strategic and an economic asset — set for November 5 last year as both governments signed an MoU last May setting a deadline for signing the detailed contract within six months.

‘India’s Iran policy marked by unnecessary caution’

> India’s urgency to arrive at a favourable response follows the planned visit of Iran’s Deputy Foreign Minister for Asia & Pacific Ebrahim Rahimpour on February 4 to hold Foreign Office Consultations with
the MEA

> Just days after the US lifted the sanctions, Iranian envoy Gholamreza Ansari said that India’s Iran policy was marked by unnecessary caution and that New Delhi could not follow the policy of patient waiting any more in the changed circumstances..

> Since last August, Iran has been asking for $345 mn as credit for the steel/railway project and $150 m n for equipment purchases for Chabahar port. However, these loans got delayed following India’s Exim Bank’s refusal to get directly involved during the tenure of western sanctions


http://indianexpress.com/article/in...ed-up-assistance-or-lose-chabahar-hints-iran/
 
. . . . .
I think this is very fare expectation from Iran too...India is talking about Chabar since last 10 year and nothing is happening...The world does not really wait for our inefficiency with decision making to complete a project outside India....I will not be surprised if China takes over the project...
 
.
Iran warns INDIA :omghaha::omghaha::omghaha:

There is nothing funny here.

I think this is very fare expectation from Iran too...India is talking about Chabar since last 10 year and nothing is happening...The world does not really wait for our inefficiency with decision making to complete a project outside India....I will not be surprised if China takes over the project...

I am pretty sure China would have given a counter (better) offer to the one offered by India. India would have tough time competing with Chinese money as well as their swiftness.
 
Last edited:
. .
nonsense. $350M and $150M...these are not great sums of money for India. The Delhi babus have to get their acts together.

Iran needs the money because oil is so cheap and Rouhani has been spending all the released billions on quickly buying stuff from Europe.

Most oil dependent countries will be in these dire straits soon, if not already.
 
. .
@Daneshmand Your thoughts appreciated on this?

Well, realistically Iran will either develop it all by itself since Iran is not a poor country and is not like Iran is begging for 100 million dollars from India. Or the Chinese will come in and do it. What people don't realize is that the current government of Iran is a one agenda government and it is economy. As current Iranian foreign relation activity shows, most of attention is on East Asia and Europe. Rouhani does not have any margin for screw up or he will be wiped out in the next election next year. And as we all know economy does not run on hopes. He is doing all he can and he wants things done fast. China seems to have responded in kind.

@Daneshmand Your thoughts appreciated on this?
By the way, China is also going to build two nuclear power reactors in Chabahar, which are part of Iran's vision for development of that area as Chabahar would need more electric power when it becomes a fully operational international port.
 
.
Well, realistically Iran will either develop it all by itself since Iran is not a poor country and is not like Iran is begging for 100 million dollars from India. Or the Chinese will come in and do it. What people don't realize is that the current government of Iran is a one agenda government and it is economy. As current Iranian foreign relation activity shows, most of attention is on East Asia and Europe. Rouhani does not have any margin for screw up or he will be wiped out in the next election next year. And as we all know economy does not run on hopes. He is doing all he can and he wants things done fast. China seems to have responded in kind.

I thought so. 100 million dollars in the Iranian context is peanuts. Quick glance at Wiki tells me your tax revenues are over $60 billion. With that in mind $100 million is as I often hear Irish say "not worth the steam of my piss".

Typical Indian habit of blowing too much hot air when millions of them are still tethered to rickshaws like donkeys. Also going by Wiki (I accept that is not the most trusted source) that 25% of your imports came from China compared to just over 4% from India. China also also takes 30% of your exports compared to 11% from India. This tells me where the wind is blowing. Without doubt economy should be the focus. That's where power really flows from.

I think the Indian importance to iran was amplified by the sanction regime. Let me tell you side story. When I went to Pakistan I stayed in a very conservative rural village in the mountains. After two weeks there when I saw female fingers I would get the rush. Here in UK half naked girl walks past and not a bother. Under the crippling sanctions anything even how insignificant would have become significant. However now with opening up things are falling in proper perspective.

You see with the rise of China is going to lead multi polar world like what existed before 1990. That's got to be good for world stability and creates natural balance.

And Daneshmand stronger the Iranian economy is great for Iran but also even if half of Pakistan does not understand it is great for Pakistan in the long run.
 
Last edited:
.
Well, realistically Iran will either develop it all by itself since Iran is not a poor country and is not like Iran is begging for 100 million dollars from India. Or the Chinese will come in and do it. What people don't realize is that the current government of Iran is a one agenda government and it is economy. As current Iranian foreign relation activity shows, most of attention is on East Asia and Europe. Rouhani does not have any margin for screw up or he will be wiped out in the next election next year. And as we all know economy does not run on hopes. He is doing all he can and he wants things done fast. China seems to have responded in kind.


By the way, China is also going to build two nuclear power reactors in Chabahar, which are part of Iran's vision for development of that area as Chabahar would need more electric power when it becomes a fully operational international port.
This is off topic, but I always wondered, what is the Supreme Leader's role in Iran. Is he a micro manager, or is he only as involved as a retired emperor is, as in only involved in the direction of the country and other times, just focus on other pursuits, unless something drastic happens. Or is he just a Religious figure and a nominal political figure.

I think this is very fare expectation from Iran too...India is talking about Chabar since last 10 year and nothing is happening...The world does not really wait for our inefficiency with decision making to complete a project outside India....I will not be surprised if China takes over the project...

Doubtful, now that there is urgency, India will probably step up. In the grand scheme of things, this is minor, there are most likely billions of dollars worth of investment in infrastructure along over the next decade for Iran, one port is hardly worth fighting over.

China maybe able to roll out infrastructure at a respectable rate, but we are pretty stretched right now, not only internationally, but also domestically. The pace of modernization have only hastened within the country.
 
.
This is off topic, but I always wondered, what is the Supreme Leader's role in Iran. Is he a micro manager, or is he only as involved as a retired emperor is, as in only involved in the direction of the country and other times, just focus on other pursuits, unless something drastic happens. Or is he just a Religious figure and a nominal political figure.

.

Supreme leader's role is exactly the same as was Chairman Mao's role. He gives the general strategic direction and has the same ideological role in Iran as Chairman Mao had in China. With the difference that, Iran's supreme leader is abit constraint in his exercise of his powers because of various constitutional definitions as well as Iran's social makeup.
 
.
India is a poor country and what they have is very hard earned.

They already has access to afghanistan through other iranian ports and trade with central asia is non existing.

Pakistan is a better choice for them to access Afghanistan and further central asian states.

How about connecting lahore motorway with delhi as a part of cpec?
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom