Iran offer mediation between Pakistan and India to resolve Kashmir dispute

[AMCA]

Kashmir will not stay with India because we don't see India as a single country. It will be divided into smaller pieced due to so many freedom struggles.

You ended up in two the last time you attempted it. Neither do we see you as a single country.

 

[Samurai_assassin]

Kindly do read why it's not allowed and it's definitely not due to Indian security personnel.

Saw video footage of Shias arrested and detained by Indian security personnel and stopped from their procession.

You ended up in two the last time you attempted it. Neither do we see you as a single country.

Of course you don't that's why you house runaway rebel leaders such as Mr Bugti whilst his clan members are a powerful force in Pakistan and are in government positions. The same people have openly spoken agaisnt Mr Bugti.

 

[The Diplomat]

Considering Shias are not allowed to take out muhharam procession in the valley Iran would be more concerned about how Kashmiri freedom fighters treat Kashmiri Shia population in the valley. I believe it's one of the reason why Iran is offering to mediate to begin with.

Please do provide credible sources because all I see is a group of people (Sunni and Shia) demeaning freedom and justice for the UNLAWFUL killings and murders of innocent Kashmiri men, women and children. You guys are worse than Israel when it comes to torture...

 

[ranjeet]

Please do provide credible sources because all I see is a group of people (Sunni and Shia) demeaning freedom and justice for the UNLAWFUL killings and murders of innocent Kashmiri men, women and children. You guys are worse than Israel when it comes to torture...

Are Kashmiri Shias The Next Pandits?
http://www.tehelka.com/2013/11/are-kashmiri-shias-the-next-pandits/

 

[The Diplomat]

Are Kashmiri Shias The Next Pandits?
http://www.tehelka.com/2013/11/are-kashmiri-shias-the-next-pandits/

Do you understand the word "Credible"?
I'm not accepting any Indian sources they will be biased towards India. Find some International source.

 

[Meengla]

Well for a fair resolution we need a neutral player to help mediate and also be very concerned about human rights. But I don't think Iran possess a stature above India or Pakistan and thus it may not be able to play any effective role. It has to be a country with significant influence on both countries. I doubt Iran has any.

Yes, Iran, with all due respect, doesn't have the stature for this.

The Middle East Quartet comes to mind: UN, USA, Russia, and EU. So some entity like that: The Kashmir Quartet!?

The key will be the phased withdrawal of troops from both sides in such a way that the other side doesn't take advantage of any vacuum. To prevent that, the Kashmir Quartet guarantees and monitors the de-escalation.

I believe Kashmir is eminently resolvable unlike the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

 

[ranjeet]

Do you understand the word "Credible"?
I'm not accepting any Indian sources they will be biased towards India. Find some International source.

Kashmir Shias: Socio-political dilemmas

The revival of sectarian based politics in Pakistan during mid eighties and dramatic resurgence of anti-Shia forces there reinforced the fears of the community. The fears actually worsened after the outbreak of the armed uprising in Kashmir in the late eighties with some militant groups, actively supported by the Pakistani state and perceived by the community to be influenced by anti-Shia hate propaganda that was tearing Pakistan of their dreams apart, at the fore front.
This perhaps can explain the reluctance of the community to actively throw in their lot with the separatist movement. This was unlike in the past when the community was in the vanguard of the pro-Pakistan movement in Kashmir.

It was because of this fear that during the past two decades Kashmir, particularly Srinagar, saw emergence of Shia enclaves, now increasingly taking the shape of ghettos.

Zadibal, Bagwanpur, Shalimar and Bemina, the Shia dominated areas of the city absorbed a heavy influx of community members from smaller pockets of downtown Srinagar like Kamangarpora, Shamswari, Fateh Kadal, Chinkral Mohalla, Habba Kadal, Rainawari, Khanyar, Nowpura, Khankah-e-Sokhta, Chattabal etc where Shias alongside Sunni Muslims and Kashmiri Pandits, had been living for centuries, creating a composite setting. This relocation, which had brought them temporary security, has spawned complications of its own, with dangers of breakdown of established social order.

And with this the small Shia pockets spread out in predominantly Sunni areas of the city are gradually disappearing

http://edition.presstv.ir/detail.fa/278797.html

Is this credible enough?

 

[Ajaxpaul]

Thank you Iran. But India and pakistan has sworn to end the kashmir menace together.

 

[xyxmt]

How date Iran interferes in India's internal matters, wrath of Modi is upon you now Iran you Iranain you

 

[NirmalKrish]

Thanks Iran, but no thanks. We would rather end up in a nuclear holocost With the enemy defeated than give into 3rd party mediation.

 

[lastofthepatriots]

Thanks Iran, but no thanks. We would rather end up in a nuclear holocost With the enemy defeated than give into 3rd party mediation.

Enemy defeated?

Shakal deki avdi bondua?

 

[NirmalKrish]

If the whole world couldn't bring India on the negotiating table despite wasting 70 years after agreeing to to hold plebiscite in Kashmir, what can Iran really do about it?

India will continue to oppress the voice of Kashmiri brothers and sisters until they either shun their demand of independence from Indua or eventually see the day with their own eyes after decades of struggle

It took over 200 years to get this subcontinent back from the clinge Of British Raj, The people of Kashmir are standing firm to see that day even if it comes after another 200 years

Apparently, our Indian friends will keep blaming the irrelevent terror outfits rather than resolving the matter as they have recently found an easy way to twist the facts on ground and face saving. Patriotism, indeed is blind I don't blame our Indian members for the oppression and cruelty of their government

Please read the UN resolution on the prerequisites for a plebiscite.
http://i.cfr.org/content/publications/attachments/47.pdf

Demilitarise and get out of Kashmir for a plebiscite, you can't even do that, yet you keep going on about oppression. Have you even read the resolution in full.

Esp subsection: restoration of peace and order 1a & b. I can quote it in vertabim if you like.

 

[Indian_gorkha]

Mediation only helps when both parties are willing to solve the issue. India is not. the only way for Pakistan to solve this issue is from position of power. Period.

What power? And which position?

 

[The Diplomat]

Kashmir Shias: Socio-political dilemmas

The revival of sectarian based politics in Pakistan during mid eighties and dramatic resurgence of anti-Shia forces there reinforced the fears of the community. The fears actually worsened after the outbreak of the armed uprising in Kashmir in the late eighties with some militant groups, actively supported by the Pakistani state and perceived by the community to be influenced by anti-Shia hate propaganda that was tearing Pakistan of their dreams apart, at the fore front.
This perhaps can explain the reluctance of the community to actively throw in their lot with the separatist movement. This was unlike in the past when the community was in the vanguard of the pro-Pakistan movement in Kashmir.

It was because of this fear that during the past two decades Kashmir, particularly Srinagar, saw emergence of Shia enclaves, now increasingly taking the shape of ghettos.

Zadibal, Bagwanpur, Shalimar and Bemina, the Shia dominated areas of the city absorbed a heavy influx of community members from smaller pockets of downtown Srinagar like Kamangarpora, Shamswari, Fateh Kadal, Chinkral Mohalla, Habba Kadal, Rainawari, Khanyar, Nowpura, Khankah-e-Sokhta, Chattabal etc where Shias alongside Sunni Muslims and Kashmiri Pandits, had been living for centuries, creating a composite setting. This relocation, which had brought them temporary security, has spawned complications of its own, with dangers of breakdown of established social order.

And with this the small Shia pockets spread out in predominantly Sunni areas of the city are gradually disappearing

http://edition.presstv.ir/detail.fa/278797.html

Is this credible enough?

Not really it's a news Chanel from Iran whom are over the top with this Sunni and Shia thing

 

[imadul]

Totally ridiculous from Iran. They are too close to India, have supported secterian violence in Pakistan, opposed Pakistan tooth and nail in Afghanistan. Only time Pakistan had good releations with Iran were duing Shah Iran eras.
Iranians are too complex a nationality to deal with. They have too grand designd about their ancient lost Sassanide Empire.
They are ravial to Pakistan politically and economially. Chabahar is being developed to counter Gawadar and CPEC.
Cant be trusted to mediate.