What's new

India’s health budget fourth lowest in world: Oxfam

beijingwalker

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Nov 4, 2011
Messages
65,195
Reaction score
-55
Country
China
Location
China
India’s health budget fourth lowest in world: Oxfam
Chandrima Banerjee / TNN / Oct 11, 2020, 03:45 IST

78597931.jpg

NEW DELHI: Afghanistan and India set aside the same share for health in their budgets, 4%, just above a quarter of the recommended spending and one-third of what the second poorest country in the world, Burundi, did. And that may have affected how far people were shielded from the Covid-19 outbreak, the latest ‘Commitment to Reducing Inequality Index 2020’ by international charity Oxfam says.

Globally, the report found, only 26 of the 158 countries surveyed were spending the recommended 15% of their budgets on health. “Nigeria, Bahrain and India, (the last of) which is currently experiencing the world’s fastest-growing outbreak of Covid-19, were among the world’s worst performing countries in tackling inequality going into the pandemic,” the Oxfam statement said.

The survey data show India spent less than 4% of its budget on health and ranked 155th on the health spending index. “Its health budget is the fourth lowest in the world. Just half of its population have access to even the most essential health services,” the report said.

According to the World Bank database, India was the 13th lowest (among 206 for which data was available) in terms of the percentage of total government expenditure that went to health in 2017. It puts the figure for India at 3.4%. Burundi spent 8.5% of its total government budget on health in the same year. For perspective, the average for high income countries was 18.6%, for lower middle income (the group to which India belongs) 5.1%. Japan spent 23.6% of the government budget on health.

The trend is consistent across South Asia — Pakistan spent just above 4% of its budget on health, Nepal and Bangladesh spent 5%, according to the Oxfam report. “This is particularly damaging when just half of India’s population (55%) has access to even the most essential services, and more than 70% of health spending is being met from household budgets (one of the highest levels in the world). This has left the country woefully ill-prepared to deal with the coronavirus pandemic,” the report said.

For the economic fallout of the pandemic, India was even worse prepared. “India, which has weak labour rights and a high incidence of vulnerable employment (about 75%), is eighth from the bottom,” the report said. India and Haiti are the only countries outside Africa in the bottom 10. In both Bangladesh and Pakistan, 57% of the workers are vulnerable — which takes into account wages, rights, conditions of work. In Nepal, it’s a little higher than India, at 79%.

“Most workers earn less than half of the minimum wage; 71% do not have any written job contract and 54% do not get paid leave. Only about 10% of the workforce in India is formal, with safe working conditions and social security,” the report said.

 
Last edited:
.
This is absurd way of looking at it. India's budget (including states) is over 20 times Pakistan. So per capita wise India is still spending three times more.
 
Last edited:
.
Beautiful the world largest democracy.
India has its own bragging right, it is the world biggest arms importer, splurging hundreds of billions dollars buying everything from aircraft carriers, jets to rifles and grenades.
 
Last edited:
.
This is absurd way of looking at it. India's budget (including states) is over 20 times Pakistan. So per capita wise India is still spending three times more.
If the data proves what you just wrote, then you are correct. If the relative size of the GDP pie is bigger by a greater proportion than the population pie for the two countries, then the per capita spend would be greater and it makes no sense to talk about what the %age break up is. Per capita health benchmarks, if met with a lower percentage, don’t need an extra “meta” %age benchmark as well.
 
.
This is absurd way of looking at it. India's budget (including states) is over 20 times Pakistan. So per capita wise India is still spending three times more.
ohhhhh really you failed again very badly. you are not even close to us you are close to some sub saharan countries

paksitan per capita health budget by gov 578 USD

india per capita health budget by gov 74 USD

Health expenditure per capita (current US$) in Pakistan was reported at 578 USD in 2014, according to the World Bank collection of development indicators, compiled from officially recognized sources. Pakistan - Health expenditure per capita - actual values, historical data, forecasts and projections were sourced from the World Bank on October of 2020.




Health expenditure per capita (current US$) in India was reported at 74.99 USD in 2014, according to the World Bank collection of development indicators, compiled from officially recognized sources. India - Health expenditure per capita - actual values, historical data, forecasts and projections were sourced from the World Bank on October of 2020.

 
Last edited:
.
ohhhhh really you failed again very badly. you are not even close to us you are close to some sub saharan countries

paksitan per capita health budget by gov 578 USD

india per capita health budget by gov 74 USD

Health expenditure per capita (current US$) in Pakistan was reported at 578 USD in 2014, according to the World Bank collection of development indicators, compiled from officially recognized sources. Pakistan - Health expenditure per capita - actual values, historical data, forecasts and projections were sourced from the World Bank on October of 2020.




Health expenditure per capita (current US$) in India was reported at 74.99 USD in 2014, according to the World Bank collection of development indicators, compiled from officially recognized sources. India - Health expenditure per capita - actual values, historical data, forecasts and projections were sourced from the World Bank on October of 2020.



These are some horrible lopsided stats for health budget per capita for India, thought they were slightly better than us looking at the bragging and boasting by Indians, the only thing they are good at...

79.99 USD, 2014 figure for India per capita is close to sub-saharan Africa as you mentioned...

578 USD for Pakistan looks decent here compared to India, and with KPK coming up with health card worth 7.5 lacs per family for 60% of the households has improved the stats now...


Indian braggarts knew that only a few private specialty hospitals like Medanta, Fortis, Apollo hospitals which used medical tourism to invite patients from all over the world doesn't makes the Indian healthcare good for poor masses.

It is much worst than Pakistan for sure, check the Covid-19 situation...

And these 8-10 specialty hospitals(for a population of 1.35 billion) charges a hefty sum like Pakistanis were charged about 20-32 lacs for treatment, and now nobody is going there after the hate campaign against Pak(India's staple diet), some low IQ(most of them are low IQ) Indians still brags about Pakistanis visiting India and that India is year ahead kinds of fake vibes...

Think Indians are delusional as per their lower IQ...
 
Last edited:
.
These are some horrible lopsided stats for heath budget per capita for India, thought they were slightly better than us looking at the bragging and boasting by Indians, the only thing they are good at...

79.99 USD, 2014 figure for India per capita is close to sub-saharan Africa as you mentioned...

578 USD for Pakistan looks decent here compared to India, and with KPK coming up with health card worth 7.5 lacs per family for 60% of the households has improved the stats now...


Indian braggarts knew that only a few private specialty hospitals like Medanta, Fortis, Apollo hospitals which used medical tourism to invite patients from all over the world doesn't makes the Indian healthcare good

It is much worst than Pakistan for sure, check the Covid-19 situation...

And these 8-10 specialty hospitals charges a hefty sum like Pakistanis were charged about 20-32 lacs for treatment, and now nobody is going there after the hate campaign against Pak(India's staple diet), some low IQ(most of them are low IQ) Indians still brags about Pakistanis visiting India and that India is years ahead kinds of fake vibes...

Think Indians are delusional as per their lower IQ...
asal main usko ye meme post kerni thi mujhy :lol: budget main afghanistan jitna or batoon main khud ko Holland smajhta hai

1602430224605.png
 
.
These are some horrible lopsided stats for heath budget per capita for India, thought they were slightly better than us looking at the bragging and boasting by Indians, the only thing they are good at...

79.99 USD, 2014 figure for India per capita is close to sub-saharan Africa as you mentioned...

578 USD for Pakistan looks decent here compared to India, and with KPK coming up with health card worth 7.5 lacs per family for 60% of the households has improved the stats now...


Indian braggarts knew that only a few private specialty hospitals like Medanta, Fortis, Apollo hospitals which used medical tourism to invite patients from all over the world doesn't makes the Indian healthcare good

It is much worst than Pakistan for sure, check the Covid-19 situation...

And these 8-10 specialty hospitals charges a hefty sum like Pakistanis were charged about 20-32 lacs for treatment, and now nobody is going there after the hate campaign against Pak(India's staple diet), some low IQ(most of them are low IQ) Indians still brags about Pakistanis visiting India and that India is years ahead kinds of fake vibes...

Think Indians are delusional as per their lower IQ...

Lol. Only dumb people will believe that Pakistan spends $578 on health per capita.

With population of 220 million and Pakistan spending $578 per capita requires a $127 billion as health budget. Your total budget is $35 billion. Lol.

When you guys talk about IQ and Aukaat, atleast verify the facts. Otherwise you become butt of jokes. Lol.
ohhhhh really you failed again very badly. you are not even close to us you are close to some sub saharan countries

paksitan per capita health budget by gov 578 USD

india per capita health budget by gov 74 USD

Health expenditure per capita (current US$) in Pakistan was reported at 578 USD in 2014, according to the World Bank collection of development indicators, compiled from officially recognized sources. Pakistan - Health expenditure per capita - actual values, historical data, forecasts and projections were sourced from the World Bank on October of 2020.




Health expenditure per capita (current US$) in India was reported at 74.99 USD in 2014, according to the World Bank collection of development indicators, compiled from officially recognized sources. India - Health expenditure per capita - actual values, historical data, forecasts and projections were sourced from the World Bank on October of 2020.


Imran Bhai, learn some english.

Here health expenditure is expenditure incurred per capita on health. And not Govt spending on health.

It is indeed lopsided @N.Siddiqui. Look how bad health care is in your country that people had to spend $578 on health. Like everything else there is a loot going on in healthcare in your country. No wonder they come to my country to get a new lease of life.
 
Last edited:
.
Lol. Only dumb people will believe that Pakistan spends $578 on health per capita.

With population of 220 million and Pakistan spending $578 per capita requires a $127 billion as health budget. Your total budget is $35 billion. Lol.

When you guys talk about IQ and Aukaat, atleast verify the facts. Otherwise you become butt of jokes. Lol.


Imran Bhai, learn some english.

Here health expenditure is expenditure incurred per capita on health. And not Govt spending on health.

It is indeed lopsided @N.Siddiqui. Look how bad health care is in your country that people had to spend $578 on health.

Khush hone dete thodi der aur, woh meme dekh kar ab woh khud ro lega thoda.

Now here is some data from world bank.

Its 44 dollars for pakistan. :p:
screenshot-data.worldbank.org-2020.10.11-21_30_45.png

screenshot-data.worldbank.org-2020.10.11-21_30_23.png
screenshot-data.worldbank.org-2020.10.11-21_30_45.png
 
.
With population of 220 million and Pakistan spending $578 per capita requires a $127 billion as health budget. Your total budget is $35 billion. Lol.

This is not government of Pakistan expenditure but by individual expenses on health care...so it is much close to believable as considering the others stats we well, like about 45-50% of household income in Pakistan is spent on food.

And that health budget makes it about 30-35% of the budget overall...could be measured in purchasing power parity that makes it still believable.

Govt. spending is negligible on healthcare and education.

In Karachi for instance about 75-80 % of the children goes to private schools, don't have the figure for universities and colleges...

And private hospitals in Karachi and other urban areas caters to most of the population.

And that figure quoted was not a Pak govt. healthcare budget figure...

Pakistan is all run by private sector be it health, education, housing...others.
 
.
Globally, the report found, only 26 of the 158 countries surveyed were spending the recommended 15% of their budgets on health. “Nigeria, Bahrain and India, (the last of) which is currently experiencing the world’s fastest-growing outbreak of Covid-19, were among the world’s worst performing countries in tackling inequality going into the pandemic,” the Oxfam statement said.

The survey data show India spent less than 4% of its budget on health and ranked 155th on the health spending index. “Its health budget is the fourth lowest in the world. Just half of its population have access to even the most essential health services,” the report said.

If India spent huge sums on health care and had people who lived as long and were as fit and healthy as those in the UK and USA would India and Indians be better off?

China has VERY few doctors and dentists. Does this make the Chinese unhealthy? Of course not. Chinese are a healthy people so China doesn't have to waste money on health care.

In some countries health care professionals and drug companies want jobs and sales so they need sick people. Sick people are VERY profitable for certain groups.
 
.
China has VERY few doctors and dentists. Does this make the Chinese unhealthy? Of course not. Chinese are a healthy people so China doesn't have to waste money on health care.
Who told you so? China has the world most doctors in absolute number by a massive margin, even per capita wise is also not very bad.

21168.jpeg
 
.
This is not government of Pakistan expenditure but by individual expenses on health care...so it is much close to believable as considering the others stats we well, like about 45-50% of household income in Pakistan is spent on food.

And that health budget makes it about 30-35% of the budget overall...could be measured in purchasing power parity that makes it still believable.

Govt. spending is negligible on healthcare and education.

In Karachi for instance about 75-80 % of the children goes to private schools, don't have the figure for universities and colleges...

And private hospitals in Karachi and other urban areas caters to most of the population.

And that figure quoted was not a Pak govt. healthcare budget figure...

Pakistan is all run by private sector be it health, education, housing...others.

Read Imran's comment to which you replied and read the OP article. In India healthcare is pretty cheap. We have the cheapest medicines in the entire world and private hospitals compete for business, so we get the best possible market rates.

So you can see the reason why India' per capita expenditure on health is so low.

Talking about health cards. My state extends free healthcare to all earning less than 500000 (1.25 million Pkr) in all hospitals of the state including private. It covers some 2059 treatments (or any treatment upto 400000), all free of cost that includes medicines. And if you are operated, they'll pay you 350 rs a day for loosing work when in recovery for up to a maximum of 45 days. Recently one of my staff had her thyroid operation done free of cost. She stayed in hospital for 10 days. Only expense they charged her was the food in cafeteria.
 
Last edited:
.
.
The reason why China can so quickly wiped out the coronavirus is because China sent doctors and nurses from all over China to Wuhan, so strictly speaking there was no China outbreak, only Wuhan outbreak, and China mobilised her medical personnels and resources to wipe it out in 2 months.
We always disagree but I enjoy your comments. :D

Index Mundi (their source is also the OECD) has China at 1.79 in 2015 rank 84. 2.0 would put China at 75.


Use more recent stats, not old ones, China is on par with S.Korea and France, not much behind US either.

21168.jpeg
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom