India’s Chabahar gambit

[Shamain]

And your point is based on that some excerpts from speech that proves zilch. I though I would get to learn something, thank you for proving me wrong. Peace

Bro check the whole speech
Remarks by President Ashraf Ghani in the Indian Council of World Affairs - Office of the President

And read this ,excerpt,

"We are the battle front. We, today in Afghanistan, are fighting on behalf of every one of our neighbors from India to Russia. This fundamental challenge asks the state system to respond coherently together organically. ,

 

[I.R.A]

Here are some quotes from Ghani in Delhi:

"Delhi, you can begin with having breakfast in Delhi, lunch in Peshawar and dinner in Kabul. I hope that what is immensely possible, can become actually achievable. And the day, when I will drive after retirement from Kabul to Delhi, I look forward to dedicating my life to creating this possibility of cooperation."

And you think it is convenient for Islamabad to forget what Delhi and Kabul did in and to Peshawar. Easy to dream no taxes, fck other's place first and then go ask for access. Nice strategy you got there will surely work if we have Mir Jaffars and Mir Sadiqs in our ranks.

 

[Shamain]

Do you what a Dredger is?

It is ship which excavates underwater and disposes off the sand at different location.
Any port in the world can be dredged to handle a ship of any draught..you just need the will and resources.

How ,much dredging uwill do?

 

[nForce]

India already has 3 border trading posts with China. And Western Delhi-Mumbai Freight corridor and Eastern Corridor already cover all 3 trading posts (almost to the last mile).

There is always an opportunity to do more. The Western part of India is heavily industrialized and the states of Gujarat and Maharasthra have good ports as well. I am quite sure, if there is an easy link available, we can always find something of common interest that can be traded.

And you think it is convenient for Islamabad to forget what Delhi and Kabul did in and to Peshawar. Easy to dream no taxes, fck other's place first and then go ask for access. Nice strategy you got there will surely work if we have Mir Jaffars and Mir Sadiqs in our ranks.

You need to explain the same to the traders.
In any case, if Gwadar port becomes fully functional, India will immensely benefit from it. India's trade with China will increase further.

 

[NIA]

How ,much dredging uwill do?

We have a dredging company owned by government of india. ..
Dredging Corporation of India - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Dredging Corporation of India Limited, or DCI, is a Miniratna Indian public sector unit engaged in the business ofdredging. DCI does dredging mainly for Indian seaports, though occasionally it dredges at foreign seaports in countries such as Taiwan and Dubai. It is mainly involved in maintenance dredging; almost all the maintenance dredging in Indian seaports is carried out by DCI. DCI is also involved in capital dredging, beach nourishment, and land reclamation. The main seaports in which DCI does business areHaldiaKandlaCochin and Ennore.

 

[Shamain]

i asked how much dredging u will do?

 

[Hellfire]

and how exactly Afghanistan gonna provide security to Indian workers working on that corridor and how exactly Iranian gonna prevent attacks by Balochi insurgents at their part of the land ? Last I heard that Balochi insurgents are more active and deadly at Irani side of the land than Pakistan. Funny to see Indian totally ignoring the security in Afghanistan and Irani side while so much concerned about Pakistan lol.

And last I heard, it was the RAW which was running the Baluchis? Or even Pakistan forgets what it says? LOL

 

[NIA]

i asked how much dredging u will do?

Dredging will be going on until we get sufficient depth..every sea ports in world needs dredging. .

 

[Shamain]

Dredging will be going on until we get sufficient depth..every sea ports in world needs dredging. .

That dredging to remove silt and sediment deposits is one thing.it happens all the time.
I am talking about depth increasing one, for post panamax 43 ft drafts.
Not all coastal beds allow deep dredging.
Anyways,leave it. Noone can answer it. except for the iranian gov.

 

[Nilesh Singh]

Lol, is at all that irks you? Okay!

Beautiful words and absolutely justified but don't refute what author of the article has said! The last paragraph indirectly comments on the normalization of the relations between three countries, under current states of affairs I highly doubt a native of Delhi can have his/her lunch in Peshawar. He's looking forward to dedicate his life to create such possibility of cooperation. Read this part bit carefully - In order for money to work and to become an agent of transformation, it has to become capital. And thereby, again, comes the immense experience of the region. India’s creativity in terms of financial instrument, in terms of the range of funds, and the enormous power of the Indian diaspora to transform money into wealth is one of the key issues.

You have access to to these transcripts of his emotional speech but do you have access to Mr. Ghani's statement at Asia summit that don't make us a proxy war battlefield? He repeated exact statement in his interview to NDTV a few days before his departure to Delhi, watch it. Also do you know before his visit to India he visited Pakistan and China? And in China his speeches were quite similar to ones he made in India, urged Chinese investors to invest in mining sector. China is the biggest investor in Afghanistan maybe it's new and informative to you. The coordination between ANA and PA has reached to new heights, ANA unlike in past has arrested and killed many Pakistan wanted insurgents in Afghanistan. ISI chief had covertly visited Afghanistan two days ago for reasons nobody knows and it was not his first visit. Pakistan PM and COAS are going on a official visit to Afghanistan today. President Ghani is focusing on trade route through Pakistan more than Chahbahar port.

A speech alone is not ample to understand levels of developments.

Afghanistan won't be able to export even half a kg of its minerals to India in 100 years let alone 15 years if, God forbids, civil war resurfaces in its full swing.

Please don't post unnecessary words of wisdom to prove your superiority over author.

MODS sir it seems you talk with complete biased towards Pakistan , you say situation in Afghanistan will become bad and if Taliban comes back Afghanistan will not be able to export anything to India or the world, so are you implying Pakistan will again meddle in Afghanistan affair through Taliban if it does not get what it wants. Now on second point about Afganistan being used as Proxy war battlefield, conveniently you have assume accusation is towards India, how can you be so sure .India hand might be dirty but Pakistan is in deep knee mud fest in Afghanistan affair, basically your generals have destroyed Afghanistan in 3 decade long civil war, and now you are portraying Pakistan as a saint and victim nation, with your argument it seems you are trying desperately to convince yourself then others.

 

[IBRIS]

Lmao what exactly is India gonna be trading to Afghansitan that we are so in disadvantage?? Burqas?

You could of gotten the transit cash but you'd rather prefer to eat grass instead. Sorry we don't manufacture salwars for men, give that task to china. I'm sure they won't mind.

 

[ashok321]

Doesn't matter, approach and berthing drafts can be deepened.

First of all above statement is flawed.

But once again, if Gwadar berth can be deepened, why not Chabahar port?

 

[ares]

How ,much dredging uwill do?

The entire port does not need to be dredged, only a narrow channel for entry and exit into the harbour and vessels berth next to the jetty need to be dredged.

It is a routine job, happens in every port around the world.

 

[Shamain]

The
It is a routine job, happens in every port around the world.

Did u not read my prev post, didnt i write that

 

[Tiger Genie]

And you think it is convenient for Islamabad to forget what Delhi and Kabul did in and to Peshawar. Easy to dream no taxes, fck other's place first and then go ask for access. Nice strategy you got there will surely work if we have Mir Jaffars and Mir Sadiqs in our ranks.

elaborate what you mean by 'what Delhi and Kabul did in Peshawar'. But if you are going to build upon insane conspiracy nuts, never mind