Indian Political Corner | All Updates & Discussions.
- Thread starter Hyde
- Start date
jamahir
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2014
- Messages
- 28,132
- Reaction score
- 1
- Country
- Location
Bihar results prove no Opposition leader can match PM Modi
Sanjay Jha
·Former National Spokesperson, Indian National Congress party
Wed 18 November 2020, 4:55 PM IST·5-min read
After all the brouhaha over a likely stunning upset of the BJP-JDU alliance in the exit polls, November 10, 2020 felt like a hangover after a tipsy night before.
It must not have been easy being Tejashwi Yadav. Practically all exit polls gave the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD)-Congress-Left parties Mahagathbandhan (MGB), the Grand Alliance, a clear majority, with two of them with a penchant for blockbuster predictions even going so far as to suggest two-thirds majority for the MGB.
A victory was on the cards: what remained suspenseful was only the magnitude of the triumph.
The Grand Alliance and the Congress was not short of talking points. In a normal universe, any political party at the helm would have got obliterated. Bihar’s migrants had suffered enormously following the abrupt lockdown announcement in March 2020.
Millions were devastated by the brutal punch in empty stomachs. Television screens were full of tragic stories of families walking hundreds of miles, desolate and despondent, on deserted highways.
Those who survived the coronavirus pandemic, could not escape the scorching summer heat and tired limbs. It was a humanitarian catastrophe that captured global headlines.
It revealed the mammoth administrative failure of the Modi government making them appear disinterested, if not altogether, disinclined to alleviate migrants’ miseries. From a perception standpoint, the cataclysmic failure would have long-term repercussions on the Bharatiya Janata Party, was the general consensus.
People do not forget their tormentors in a hurry. By the time the government arranged for special trains to transport migrants home from Delhi, Punjab, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Karnataka, etc. back home to Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand, Odisha and Bengal, the damage was done.
That this was an emotive electoral issue in Bihar was hardly surprising. In fact, Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar was seen as a villain of the piece who did precious little to arrange transport, unlike his UP counterpart, Yogi Adityanath.
There are 30 million migrants who traverse the country, leaving home and hearth looking for jobs that can help them to get a decent livelihood. If an average size of a family is 4, there are 120 million citizens of the state who would be extremely piqued at the way they were treated.
Thus, there would be caste-neutral and religion agnostic voting. For the MGB, this was a moment to seize, to fight for the oppressed. But tried as hard as they did they clearly could not communicate their empathy to the suffering multitude.
They could not demonstrate their panacea for the whopping size of unemployed youth either, albeit Bihar’s jobless throngs were at least momentarily captivated by Yadav’s talismanic pronouncement of 10 lakh government jobs on day one.
In the end, Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s trademark hyperbole held sway; the double-engine of growth versus the double-dynastic successors who brought in jungle raj fifteen years ago.
That the people of Bihar forgot their current wretched predicament when reminded of a period of terrible mal-governance about 16,000 days earlier, is a poor reflection on the MGB’s counter-attack political strategy.
They appeared like sacrificial lambs, bereft of smart defensive tactics, awaiting electoral slaughter. Bihar’s numbers on NCRB these days are far from flattering (for instance, Bihar is number one in communal or religious violence in India, based on available statistics).
The Congress gave a rather dilettantish argument that had Asaduddin Owaisi’s AIMIM political party not contested at the behest of their alleged guardian BJP, the minority vote consolidation would have led to strengthening of the ‘secular forces’ in Seemanchal.
Frankly, that appeared to be a tenuous defense of its abject performance. Owaisi is an inspiring orator, fiery and passionate, and when need be conveniently inflammatory who reciprocates the hardliner tribalism that is espoused by Hindutva apostles. Owaisi ended up winning a crucial five seats and making a grand foray into the state assembly.
That the Grand Old Party was now hanging precariously by the coat-tails of an ascending 31-year-old Tejashwi exhibited its emaciated electoral base. It had settled for 70 seats, and ended up winning 19 of them.
Ultimately, its meagre tally would reduce the MGB to below the half-way mark of 122 seats. The silver lining is that they had almost equal vote-share (NDA got 37.26% against UPA’s 37.23%), but in a first–past-the-post system, it is the winner who takes all.
Thus, there is another five years in the wilderness for MGB, while Nitish Kumar gets an enviable fourth term in a row, which is quite extraordinary.
That PM Modi can say anything he likes and the public buys into it is a manifestation of two elements; the PM has very high credibility despite mammoth governance gaffes, and that the Opposition (particularly the Congress) has no one to match Modi’s towering preponderance over Indian politics.
It is a lopsided, uneven battle. The Congress, after thirty years of political badgering, still manages to win only 19 seats which makes the national party increasingly irrelevant in one of the most crucial states on the roadmap to Delhi. That should worry 24, Akbar Road.
The BJP now parades Modi as their showboat at the hustings fully convinced that he can change the direction of the winds. And Modi is changing north-eastern hurricanes into south-western tailwinds.
And to his credit he does that more often than not.
As for the Congress it utters the right platitudes of protecting the Idea of India, and it sounds good and no one can disagree with its great-hearted intention. But it needs to quickly realise that winning elections is a desideratum to do that.
---
Jamahir's comment : Sanjay Jha correctly speaks of the unfortunate history of this year and the political and socio-economic tragedies and shortcomings of India.
Sanjay Jha
·Former National Spokesperson, Indian National Congress party
Wed 18 November 2020, 4:55 PM IST·5-min read
After all the brouhaha over a likely stunning upset of the BJP-JDU alliance in the exit polls, November 10, 2020 felt like a hangover after a tipsy night before.
It must not have been easy being Tejashwi Yadav. Practically all exit polls gave the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD)-Congress-Left parties Mahagathbandhan (MGB), the Grand Alliance, a clear majority, with two of them with a penchant for blockbuster predictions even going so far as to suggest two-thirds majority for the MGB.
A victory was on the cards: what remained suspenseful was only the magnitude of the triumph.
The Grand Alliance and the Congress was not short of talking points. In a normal universe, any political party at the helm would have got obliterated. Bihar’s migrants had suffered enormously following the abrupt lockdown announcement in March 2020.
Millions were devastated by the brutal punch in empty stomachs. Television screens were full of tragic stories of families walking hundreds of miles, desolate and despondent, on deserted highways.
Those who survived the coronavirus pandemic, could not escape the scorching summer heat and tired limbs. It was a humanitarian catastrophe that captured global headlines.
It revealed the mammoth administrative failure of the Modi government making them appear disinterested, if not altogether, disinclined to alleviate migrants’ miseries. From a perception standpoint, the cataclysmic failure would have long-term repercussions on the Bharatiya Janata Party, was the general consensus.
People do not forget their tormentors in a hurry. By the time the government arranged for special trains to transport migrants home from Delhi, Punjab, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Karnataka, etc. back home to Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Jharkhand, Odisha and Bengal, the damage was done.
That this was an emotive electoral issue in Bihar was hardly surprising. In fact, Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar was seen as a villain of the piece who did precious little to arrange transport, unlike his UP counterpart, Yogi Adityanath.
There are 30 million migrants who traverse the country, leaving home and hearth looking for jobs that can help them to get a decent livelihood. If an average size of a family is 4, there are 120 million citizens of the state who would be extremely piqued at the way they were treated.
Thus, there would be caste-neutral and religion agnostic voting. For the MGB, this was a moment to seize, to fight for the oppressed. But tried as hard as they did they clearly could not communicate their empathy to the suffering multitude.
They could not demonstrate their panacea for the whopping size of unemployed youth either, albeit Bihar’s jobless throngs were at least momentarily captivated by Yadav’s talismanic pronouncement of 10 lakh government jobs on day one.
In the end, Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s trademark hyperbole held sway; the double-engine of growth versus the double-dynastic successors who brought in jungle raj fifteen years ago.
That the people of Bihar forgot their current wretched predicament when reminded of a period of terrible mal-governance about 16,000 days earlier, is a poor reflection on the MGB’s counter-attack political strategy.
They appeared like sacrificial lambs, bereft of smart defensive tactics, awaiting electoral slaughter. Bihar’s numbers on NCRB these days are far from flattering (for instance, Bihar is number one in communal or religious violence in India, based on available statistics).
The Congress gave a rather dilettantish argument that had Asaduddin Owaisi’s AIMIM political party not contested at the behest of their alleged guardian BJP, the minority vote consolidation would have led to strengthening of the ‘secular forces’ in Seemanchal.
Frankly, that appeared to be a tenuous defense of its abject performance. Owaisi is an inspiring orator, fiery and passionate, and when need be conveniently inflammatory who reciprocates the hardliner tribalism that is espoused by Hindutva apostles. Owaisi ended up winning a crucial five seats and making a grand foray into the state assembly.
That the Grand Old Party was now hanging precariously by the coat-tails of an ascending 31-year-old Tejashwi exhibited its emaciated electoral base. It had settled for 70 seats, and ended up winning 19 of them.
Ultimately, its meagre tally would reduce the MGB to below the half-way mark of 122 seats. The silver lining is that they had almost equal vote-share (NDA got 37.26% against UPA’s 37.23%), but in a first–past-the-post system, it is the winner who takes all.
Thus, there is another five years in the wilderness for MGB, while Nitish Kumar gets an enviable fourth term in a row, which is quite extraordinary.
That PM Modi can say anything he likes and the public buys into it is a manifestation of two elements; the PM has very high credibility despite mammoth governance gaffes, and that the Opposition (particularly the Congress) has no one to match Modi’s towering preponderance over Indian politics.
It is a lopsided, uneven battle. The Congress, after thirty years of political badgering, still manages to win only 19 seats which makes the national party increasingly irrelevant in one of the most crucial states on the roadmap to Delhi. That should worry 24, Akbar Road.
The BJP now parades Modi as their showboat at the hustings fully convinced that he can change the direction of the winds. And Modi is changing north-eastern hurricanes into south-western tailwinds.
And to his credit he does that more often than not.
As for the Congress it utters the right platitudes of protecting the Idea of India, and it sounds good and no one can disagree with its great-hearted intention. But it needs to quickly realise that winning elections is a desideratum to do that.
---
Jamahir's comment : Sanjay Jha correctly speaks of the unfortunate history of this year and the political and socio-economic tragedies and shortcomings of India.
ps3linux
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Mar 4, 2019
- Messages
- 913
- Reaction score
- 34
- Country
- Location
Extremism in any society is like cancer, it spreads and spreads till it consumes the being, every society has a tipping point when it has to decide whether it wants to continue down the path to self destruction or come out of it. Personally I do not like discrimination among people on any parameter that people set. Many people seek pleasure that India is on a path to self destruction but I for one feel saddened the moderate India, the secular India is going south and that is not good for geo politics considering we are dealing with a nuclear state here, problems/threats faced by the world after the downfall of Nuclear USSR stull haunt many.
Add to this in my opinion the farmers are protesting that the law should be repealed, I see majority of them still carrying the "Taranga" of course would be some who would use the occasion for their own purposes may be "Khalistan" but the coverage I have seen majority of the farmers still carry the Tri Colour, but when people start labelling the farmers as Anti State or terrorist for that matter it becomes a major concern for the unity of India in the long term and such people become majority then future of India will become??? whatever...
INS_Vikrant
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Nov 2, 2015
- Messages
- 1,730
- Reaction score
- -7
- Country
- Location
Modi must have really earned a good karma in his past life, that he is blessed with such idiot and incompetent political opponents today. People like Tharoor and other stupid Congress leaders will ensure that Modi would keep on winning elections no matter how much he screws up.
jamahir
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2014
- Messages
- 28,132
- Reaction score
- 1
- Country
- Location
Congress may get young leaders Jignesh Mevani Kanhaiya Kumar, to join
The two young leaders may get plum positions in the party that is gearing up for multiple state polls in 2022
Sabrangindia 20 Sep 2021
Image: The Hindu
The news has all been attributed to ‘sources’, but the buzz is loud and clear that Gujarat MLA Jignesh Mevani, and former student leader Kanhaiya Kumar of the CPI, will soon join the Congress. Speculations had been doing the rounds about Kanhaiya Kumar’s possible move to the Congress for a while, however, Jignesh Mevani’s name has only recently cropped up. It has been reported that Kumar who contested the 2019 Lok Sabha election from Begusarai, Bihar (where he lost to the BJP strongman Giriraj Singh) had already met Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra. The two young leaders may get plum position in the party, and NDTV reported that Mevani, a Dalit leader elected to the Gujarat Assembly Vadgam constituency as an independent “could be made Working President of the party's Gujarat unit.” He has ‘appreciated’ the Congress in this recent tweet:
According to the report, Kanhaiya Kumar and Jignesh Mevani “will join the Congress - likely during an event on October 2”, adding that “hey were scheduled to join on September 28 - on the birth anniversary of Bhagat Singh.” Mevani move to the Congress, ahead of Gujarat elections next year, is being compared to the appointment of a Dalit CM in Punjab. The Dalit voters are emerging as a political force the party can no longer ignore. The two are also popular young leaders and the party it appears has recognised the need to bring youth to the forefront of its leadership, which till now has been helmed by ‘elders’. All eyes are set on state elections in 2022 and the Lok Sabha election in 2024.
---
Jamahir's comment : Disappointed to see Kanhaiya leaving the Communist Party of India especially in context of the symbolism of Shaheed Bhagat Sing's birth anniversary who was a Socialist or Communist. Though what I would really like see is Kanhaiya being the PM candidate for 2024 general election.
The two young leaders may get plum positions in the party that is gearing up for multiple state polls in 2022
Sabrangindia 20 Sep 2021
Image: The Hindu
The news has all been attributed to ‘sources’, but the buzz is loud and clear that Gujarat MLA Jignesh Mevani, and former student leader Kanhaiya Kumar of the CPI, will soon join the Congress. Speculations had been doing the rounds about Kanhaiya Kumar’s possible move to the Congress for a while, however, Jignesh Mevani’s name has only recently cropped up. It has been reported that Kumar who contested the 2019 Lok Sabha election from Begusarai, Bihar (where he lost to the BJP strongman Giriraj Singh) had already met Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra. The two young leaders may get plum position in the party, and NDTV reported that Mevani, a Dalit leader elected to the Gujarat Assembly Vadgam constituency as an independent “could be made Working President of the party's Gujarat unit.” He has ‘appreciated’ the Congress in this recent tweet:
According to the report, Kanhaiya Kumar and Jignesh Mevani “will join the Congress - likely during an event on October 2”, adding that “hey were scheduled to join on September 28 - on the birth anniversary of Bhagat Singh.” Mevani move to the Congress, ahead of Gujarat elections next year, is being compared to the appointment of a Dalit CM in Punjab. The Dalit voters are emerging as a political force the party can no longer ignore. The two are also popular young leaders and the party it appears has recognised the need to bring youth to the forefront of its leadership, which till now has been helmed by ‘elders’. All eyes are set on state elections in 2022 and the Lok Sabha election in 2024.
---
Jamahir's comment : Disappointed to see Kanhaiya leaving the Communist Party of India especially in context of the symbolism of Shaheed Bhagat Sing's birth anniversary who was a Socialist or Communist. Though what I would really like see is Kanhaiya being the PM candidate for 2024 general election.
jamahir
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2014
- Messages
- 28,132
- Reaction score
- 1
- Country
- Location
I should explain the context of the first two tweets. Some days ago that serial Hindutvadi idiocy speaker from Bangalore, Tejaswi Surya, raised a stink about a limited fashion show for the Hindu Deepawali festival and done by the ethnic Indian clothing company FabIndia. The event's name was Jashn-e-Riwaaz ( obviously anything Urdu automatically hated by the Hindutvadis ) and the female models wearing clothes that supposedly were not Hindu enough and supposedly were "Abrahamic" and supposedly did not mesh enough with the festival :
The below quoted tweets are from 2012 when the Congress party was in power and the Hindutvadis and their supporters were condemning the Congress for the rise in petrol prices, but now that petrol prices have risen again who is in power ?
---
@Goenitz @STREANH @Drizzt
@Chhatrapati @INDIAPOSITIVE others
The below quoted tweets are from 2012 when the Congress party was in power and the Hindutvadis and their supporters were condemning the Congress for the rise in petrol prices, but now that petrol prices have risen again who is in power ?
---
@Goenitz @STREANH @Drizzt
@Chhatrapati @INDIAPOSITIVE others
Last edited:
INS_Vikrant
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Nov 2, 2015
- Messages
- 1,730
- Reaction score
- -7
- Country
- Location
The real surprise today was Goa, every survey showed it a hung assembly. Irony is all anti BJP parties like Congress, AAP and TMC ended up helping it indirectly by splitting anti incumbency votes among them lol.
INS_Vikrant
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Nov 2, 2015
- Messages
- 1,730
- Reaction score
- -7
- Country
- Location
India being mentioned by both govt and now even by opposition in ongoing Pakistan political drama, mentioning in 1996 when Vajpayeeji lost NCM by just 1 vote. His memorable speech that day.
Similar threads
