What's new

Indian parliament considers FBI-style agency

Neo

RETIRED

New Recruit

Joined
Nov 1, 2005
Messages
18
Reaction score
0

NEW DELHI, Dec 16: The Indian government on Tuesday sought parliament’s approval for a national agency to investigate major militant attacks such as last month’s assaults on Mumbai.

The proposed agency would come after decades of opposition from India’s 29 states, which have long argued such a body would allow the national government to usurp their local law enforcement powers.

Home Minister P. Chidambaram introduced the bill which, if turned into law, would establish a National Investigations Agency, styled on the US Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI).

“There have been innumerable incidents of attacks, not only in militancy and insurgency-affected areas... but also in the form of terrorist attacks and bomb blasts in various parts of the hinterland and major cities,” Chidambaram said.

New Delhi has said militants who were trained and armed in Pakistan staged the November 26 attacks, in which gunmen killed 163 people. Nine of the attackers were also killed.

Chidambaram also sought the approval of the lower house for new anti-terror legislation which would give provincial and federal police increased powers to investigate militant attacks.

The bill would allow the “speedy investigation, prosecution and trial of cases related to terrorism,” he added.

India’s existing Central Bureau of Investigations has federal powers but it needs approval from state governments before launching major probes.

The country’s security agencies, which have long been accused of in-fighting and poor intelligence gathering, came in for fierce criticism after the Mumbai attacks.—AFP
 
.
India Intelligence and Security Agencies
The King "... should divide the day as well as the night into eight parts . . . During the fifth, he should hold consultations with the council of ministers through correspondence and also keep himself informed of the secret reports brought by spies.... During the first one-eighth part of the night, he should meet the officers of the secret service.... During the seventh, he should hold consultations and send out the officers of the secret service for their operations."
The Duties of a King The Arthasastra
Kautilya - Prime Minister to Emperor Chandragupta Maurya (4th Century BCE)



Security Threat Environment
Joint Intelligence Committee (JIC)

Research and Analysis Wing [RAW]

Intelligence Bureau (IB)

Ministry of External Affairs
National Technical Facilities Organisation


Defense Ministry
Joint Cipher Bureau
Army
Directorate of Military Intelligence
Defence Security Corps
Special Frontier Force
National Security Guards (NSG)
Special Security Bureau
Air Force
Directorate of Air Intelligence
Navy
Directorate of Naval Intelligence
Coast Guard

Minister of State for Home Affairs
Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI)
Department of Internal Security
Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF)
Rapid Action Force (RAF)
Special Protection Group (SPG)
Central Industrial Security Force
Border Security Force (BSF)
Home Guards

Ministry of Finance
Economic Intelligence Council
Department of Revenue
Central Economic Intelligence Bureau

Directorate General of Revenue Intelligence (DGRI)
Directorate of Enforcement
Directorate General of Anti-Evasion
Directorate General of Income Tax Investigation
Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB)


all these why they make for securty and where all these before bombay attack no were.
new agency will like one of these no benifit fix problims better then make agency.
 
.
An additional agency will only add to the confusion already prevailing there, a display of which was evident during the recent attacks…

IMO India doesn’t need a new agency, but reduce the red tape involved in the judiciary system, and streamline the charter of duties of the existing agencies…that should take care of many issues...

Too many strings are attached with a new player, typical issues that arise: Whose Job Is It? Who is incharge? It’s my Domain!!! Who was suppose to do this ???…More red tape and hence more confusion....
 
.
An additional agency will only add to the confusion already prevailing there, a display of which was evident during the recent attacks…

IMO India doesn’t need a new agency, but reduce the red tape involved in the judiciary system, and streamline the charter of duties of the existing agencies…that should take care of many issues...

Too many strings are attached with a new player, typical issues that arise: Whose Job Is It? Who is incharge? It’s my Domain!!! Who was suppose to do this ???…More red tape and hence more confusion....

hey man, let them do what they feel is right!
 
.
India Intelligence and Security Agencies
...
all these why they make for securty and where all these before bombay attack no were.
new agency will like one of these no benifit fix problims better then make agency.

I can quote your response to argue about any of the following:
1> US 9/11 attacks
2> London Tube bombings
3> Madrid train bombings
4> Assasination of Benazir Bhutto, Pak Army Surgeon General, Ex-Gen Alavi of SSG, etc. etc.
The fact is: there is no single agency or group of agencies that can prevent a group of fanatical terrorists from carrying out their mad missions. Period.
 
.
The Indian intelligence community essentially consists of the Intelligence Bureau (IB), the Research & Analysis Wing (RAW), the Directorate-General of Security, the Directorates-General of Intelligence of the three services of the Armed Forces and the intelligence wings of the para-military forces and the State Governments.

At present, there is no system of co-ordination of their activities, allocation of budgetary resources, assignment of tasks and monitoring of their performance.

Indian intelligency system is JUST not fit for the current size of our system.
We need to urgently upgrade, it, restructure and modify it. And also strengthn it by adding NIA.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom