Indian muslim :Javed Akhtar's India & Pakistan

[53fd]

It was a blessing in disguise for Pakistan that most hindustani muslims stayed back in hindustan. They should stay there forever in their little slums in mumbai, who needs their love.

Well, as a Pakistani, I am thankful to God that I was born in Pakistan & not India. Even as a Shia Muslim, I am blessed to be born in Pakistan where I have the respect of my fellow Pakistanis & fellow Muslim brothers/sisters, & am not discriminated against because of what I believe in. Pakistan is in a temporary volatile phase right now, where everyone (not just one particular group) is suffering. Indians that bash Pakistan for these turbulent times fail to realize that India has suffered a lot more loss in lives due to internal violence & terrorism from 1994-2005 than what Pakistan has suffered from 2001-2011. Pakistan & Pakistanis have shown their resilience & strength in the past, & will continue to do so.

 

[kingkobra]

Well, as a Pakistani, I am grateful that I am born in Pakistan & not in India. Even as a Shia Muslim, I am blessed to be born in Pakistan where I have the respect of my fellow Pakistanis & fellow Muslim brothers/sisters, & am not discriminated against because of what I believe in. Pakistan is in a temporary phase right now, Indians that bash Pakistan for these turbulent times fail to realize that India has suffered a lot more loss in lives due to internal violence & terrorism from 1994-2005 than what Pakistan has suffered from 2001-2011.

still we have managed to grow and reduce our poverty...
i guess now pakistanis who blame their current economic situation on WOT can not do so because apparently India has had more terrorism and violence and death than pakistan..

 

[gulte]

Javed Akthar considers himself as aethist.

 

[Shabz Nist]

My younger cousins, & the cousins my age & older who live in Lucknow & Delhi have very positive views about Pakistan, as do my mother's siblings & parents. I've been to India 3 times myself & seen it with my own eyes. Indian Muslims do not have one single viewpoint about Pakistan.

lol.....these are your relatives and your people.

 

[53fd]

still we have managed to grow and reduce our poverty...
i guess now pakistanis who blame their current economic situation on WOT can not do so because apparently India has had more terrorism and violence and death than pakistan..

Pakistan had reduced its poverty significantly as well over the years, but it has increased in the past 2-3 years since Zardari's rule & the effects of the WOT. India had much higher poverty levels during its times of internal violence & terrorism. When Pakistan gets out of this WOT, poverty will go down, just like it went down before in the past.

---------- Post added at 12:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:08 PM ----------

lol.....these are your relatives and your people.

They are still Indian citizens, & love India. They just aren't anti-Pakistan like most Indians (that don't have any experiences with Pakistanis) are.

 

[53fd]

It is sad that the Indian administration has to build up anti-Pakistan sentiments in its Muslim population, because of a fear of them shifting their loyalties to Pakistan. There are constant accusations levied against Indian Muslims of being loyal towards Pakistan & not India.

 

[kingkobra]

Pakistan had reduced its poverty significantly as well over the years, but it has increased in the past 2-3 years since Zardari's rule & the effects of the WOT. India had much higher poverty levels during its times of internal violence & terrorism. When Pakistan gets out of this WOT, poverty will go down, just like it went down before in the past.

---------- Post added at 12:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:08 PM ----------



They are still Indian citizens, & love India. They just aren't anti-Pakistan like most Indians (that don't have any experiences with Pakistanis) are.

we have continuously reduced our poverty since last few decades...even during so called era of 1994-2005 that you have mentioned...
we reduced poverty even during 1991 economic recession which was hard for india..

 

[kingkobra]

It is sad that the Indian administration has to build up anti-Pakistan sentiments in its Muslim population, because of a fear of them shifting their loyalties to Pakistan. There are constant accusations levied against Indian Muslims of being loyal towards Pakistan & not India.

i dont remember when indian administration did that...
i dont remember APJ Abdul kalamji bashing pakistan for proving his patriotism..

 

[53fd]

we have continuously reduced our poverty since last few decades...even during so called era of 1994-2005 that you have mentioned...
we reduced poverty even during 1991 economic recession which was hard for india..

poverty in Pakistan:

 

[53fd]

i dont remember when indian administration did that...
i dont remember APJ Abdul kalamji bashing pakistan for proving his patriotism..

Anti-Pakistan sentiments are fed to Indian Muslims via the media & through the political parties; & in general, the political system of India.

 

[OrionHunter]

It was a blessing in disguise for Pakistan that most hindustani muslims stayed back in hindustan. They should stay there forever. who needs their love.

Hell's bells! Now a Muslim bashing a Muslim!! WTF is going on?? Something doesn't add up here, or am I missing something?

 

[Omar1984]

Javed Akthar considers himself as aethist.

Just like Salman Rushdie who hates Islam and Pakistan to the core.

Why are there so many athiests from INDIAN "muslim" familes and why do they hate Pakistan so much?

I wonder why.

Just as I said before, it was a blessing in disguise that most hindustani muslims stayed back in hindustan. Pakistan is for people of Punjab, Afghania (K-P/FATA), Kashmir, Sindh, and Balochistan.

 

[Shabz Nist]

Anti-Pakistan sentiments are fed to Indian Muslims via the media & through the political parties; & in general, the political system of India.

Would any sane country ever air news that would put its mortal enemy in a good light?.........No.

That being said, the image of Pakistan currently being fed to the Indian populace is one similiar to taliban ruled Afghanistan. This, i believe is a bit too much.

 

[53fd]

Would any sane country ever air news that would put its mortal enemy in a good light?.........No.

That being said, the image of Pakistan currently being fed to the Indian populace is one similiar to taliban ruled Afghanistan. This, i believe is a bit too much.

Good post.

 

[kingkobra]

Just like Salman Rushdie who hates Islam and Pakistan to the core.

Why are there so many athiests from INDIAN "muslim" familes and why do they hate Pakistan so much?

I wonder why.

Just as I said before, it was a blessing in disguise that most hindustani muslims stayed back in hindustan. Pakistan is for people of Punjab, Afghania (K-P/FATA), Kashmir, Sindh, and Balochistan.

so you claim that there are no Pakistani atheists?