What's new

Indian impasse over nuclear deal

t-birds

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Sep 27, 2007
Messages
323
Reaction score
0
Indian impasse over nuclear deal
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/media/images/44776000/jpg/_44776421_nukedealcpmprtestap226.jpg
The Communists have opposed the deal

India's governing coalition and its communist allies have failed to break the deadlock over a delayed civilian nuclear co-operation deal with the US.

Leaders discussed the impasse in Delhi and said they would meet again, although no date has been set.

The talks came amid reports that the Congress-led coalition could go ahead with the deal and risk early elections.

India is under pressure from Washington to sign the deal before the US presidential elections in November.

"[The talks] will be held in due course," said Foreign Minister Pranab Mukherjee - representing the Congress party - after his meeting with Communist Party of India (Marxist, CPI-M) representative Sitaram Yechury.

Under the terms of the controversial deal, India would get access to US civilian nuclear technology and fuel.

In return, Delhi would open its civilian nuclear facilities to inspection - but its nuclear weapons sites would remain off-limits.

Objections from the Indian government's communist allies have delayed the signing. The left-wing parties argue that it would give the US undue influence over India's foreign and nuclear policy.

The communists, who have 59 members in parliament, say they will withdraw support for the government if it goes ahead with the deal.

Hopeful

This would lead to early polls - general elections are due to be held by next May.

Allies of the Congress-led coalition have said early elections would go against them at a time of double-digit inflation fuelled by rising oil and food prices.

Reports before Wednesday's meeting said that the Congress Party was backing Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, who is widely believed to be the architect of the deal.

NUCLEAR POWER IN INDIA
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/media/images/44776000/jpg/_44776426_indianuclearstation226ind.jpg

India has 14 reactors in commercial operation and nine under construction
Nuclear power supplies about 3% of India's electricity
By 2050, nuclear power is expected to provide 25% of the country's electricity
India has limited coal and uranium reserves
Its huge thorium reserves - about 25% of the world's total - are expected to fuel its nuclear power programme long-term
Source: Uranium Information Center


But some senior Congress party members appear to have misgivings about it.

"I can't understand why the deal cannot be renegotiated at a later stage, maybe one year down the line," former junior foreign minister and party member Salman Khursheed told The Indian Express newspaper.

US President George W Bush finalised the nuclear agreement with Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh in July 2005.

It overturned three decades of US policy by allowing the sale of nuclear technology and fuel to India.

With President Bush's second and final term in office drawing to a close and presidential elections set for November, the Bush administration is growing increasingly keen to wrap up the deal.

Many analysts and some within the Bush administration believe a failure to conclude the agreement could create a setback for the current momentum in US-India relations.

Any deal would also eventually need to be approved by the UN's nuclear watchdog, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), as well as by the 45-nation Nuclear Suppliers Group, which regulates global civilian nuclear trade.

The IAEA's board of governors and the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) must approve India-specific exemptions before the deal is sent back to the US Congress for its final seal of approval.
 
.
I've to say one thing, our PM and Mrs. Gandhi both are fully aware of the implications of not signing this deal. My hunch is they'll go ahead with it and risk early elections as the Left will pull out.
 
.
I've to say one thing, our PM and Mrs. Gandhi both are fully aware of the implications of not signing this deal. My hunch is they'll go ahead with it and risk early elections as the Left will pull out.

Seems unlikely...with inflation hitting 11 percent, no government will want to contest elections now.

The only option left is to wait it out till the last possible moment, delaying elections as far as possible.
 
.
Seems unlikely...with inflation hitting 11 percent, no government will want to contest elections now.

The only option left is to wait it out till the last possible moment, delaying elections as far as possible.

Its not politics anymore... its personal... MMS would go to any length to get this deal passed. The Congress and Gandhis will toe his line.

I'm wondering what the BJP will do; they are giving mixed signals.
 
.
Its not politics anymore... its personal... MMS would go to any length to get this deal passed. The Congress and Gandhis will toes his line.

I'm wondering what the BJP will do; they are giving mixed signals.

I feel like Government will sign the deal. in case of show of power SP will support UPA and with some independents the government will be afloat. BJP and Left will vote against the government. Most of the parties dont want general elections early, this is the only hope.
 
.
I've to say one thing, our PM and Mrs. Gandhi both are fully aware of the implications of not signing this deal. My hunch is they'll go ahead with it and risk early elections as the Left will pull out.

I also have the same feeling as this is a strategic decision and will help congress in years to come. Taking earlier decision will help congress as I feel Commies will support them silently as they also do not want Elections other wise they would have withdrwan support long back.
 
.
The Communists have held the country to ransom for too long.

The charade must stop.

It is to watch as to who blinks first.

Inflation also is a factor which is worrying the UPA on the issue of holding early election.
 
.
Indian coalition partners fail to bridge gap on N-deal

NEW DELHI, June 25: The Indian government and its communist allies on Wednesday failed to settle an impasse over a landmark nuclear deal with the United States, but decided to continue talks.

Faced with a choice of breaking with the communists and heading to early elections or abandoning the deal, the government chose to stall for more time.

“The committee completed its discussions on all aspects of the Indo-US civil nuclear cooperation agreement. The next meeting of the committee, to be convened in due course, will finalise its findings,” said Indian Foreign Minister Pranab Mukherjee, reading from a terse statement after the meeting.

He declined to answer questions.

Mukherjee represented the governing Congress party at the hour-long talks with leaders of the communist parties and heads of several smaller members of the ruling coalition.

The nuclear deal would reverse three decades of American policy by allowing the shipment of atomic fuel and technology to India, which has not signed international non-proliferation accords and has tested nuclear weapons.

India, in exchange, would open its civilian reactors to international inspections.

The deal has faced stiff opposition from India’s communist parties, which don’t want to see New Delhi drawn closer to Washington.

The communists, who prop up the government from the outside, have threatened to withdraw their support if the current administration presses on with the nuclear pact, a move that could topple the government and lead to early elections.

For India to move ahead with the deal it needs to sign a separate deal with the UN’s International Atomic Energy Agency that’s needed before the US Congress can approve the pact.

There was no change of heart from the communists after the talks.

“We will not allow this government to go for the IAEA board approval,” said Debabrata Biswas, a senior communist official who attended the meeting.

With no concessions from the communists, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh would be forced to either move forward without their support — a risky political move — or abandon the much touted nuclear agreement.—AP

Indian coalition partners fail to bridge gap on N-deal -DAWN - Top Stories; June 26, 2008
 
.
Back
Top Bottom