Indian Cryogenic Engine GSLV D3 Failed

[Myth_buster_1]

nuclear tech was first developed by US so are u saying u copied them and have never made anything on your own .....what a shame

Dig that

WOOW. what a great punch line come back.

The US helped us and you to make the bomb. DIG THAT!
I am not going to debate on this matter any further as it will derail this thread. However i will be happy to debate about this matter on another thread which i will open in the morning.

India: Nuclear Helpers

The Risk Report
Volume 1 Number 2 (March 1995) Page 8

Western companies have supplied India's controversial nuclear program for more than three decades. All of India's plutonium-making reactors and heavy water production plants are based on foreign designs.

Canada
Supplied the Cirus reactor, which produced plutonium for India's 1974 nuclear weapon test
Supplied India's first two power reactors at Rajasthan, which India copied to build unsafeguarded reactors

China
Sold at least 130 tons of heavy water to a German broker who smuggled the material to India for use in unsafeguarded nuclear reactors

France
Helped build the unsafeguarded Baroda and Tuticorin heavy water plants
Helped build the unsafeguarded Fast Breeder Test Reactor (FBTR) at Kalpakkam; trained Indian engineers in France and sent French engineers to work in India

Germany
Supplied unsafeguarded Nangal and Talcher heavy water plants; sold teleperm process control system to Hazira heavy water plant
German firm was fined $800,000 by the U.S. for illegally re-exporting U.S.-origin beryllium
German broker arranged illicit sales of more than 200 tons of heavy water to India
Supplied natural lithium useful in making tritium to boost nuclear bombs
Sold zircalloy pipes which are used as reactor fuel cladding

Norway
More than 26 tons of Norwegian heavy water was diverted to India through Romania and Switzerland

Soviet Union/Russia
Secretly sold at least 80 tons of heavy water to run unsafeguarded reactors

Sweden
Supplied specialized steel tube plates for heavy water reactors
Sold flash X-ray devices, which can be used for nuclear weapon development

Switzerland
Helped build the unsafeguarded Baroda and Tuticorin heavy water plants

United Kingdom
Supplied turbine generator designs used at several unsafeguarded reactors
Repaired damaged heavy water equipment at Madras reactor

United States
Supplied heavy water for Cirus reactor that made plutonium for India's first nuclear bomb

 

[ARCHON]

WOOW. what a great punch line come back.

The US helped us and you to make the bomb. DIG THAT!
I am not going to debate on this matter any further as it will derail this thread. However i will be happy to debate about this matter on another thread which i will open in the morning.

Pakistan: Nuclear Helpers

Belgium

Supplied New Labs plutonium extraction plant
Canada

Supplied Kanupp power reactor including fuel and spare parts until 1976
China

Supplied a tested bomb design and high-enriched uranium fuel
Supplied special magnets to help gas centrifuges enrich uranium
Building a power reactor and training technicians at Chashma despite de facto international nuclear supply embargo
Helping to build a secret plutonium producing reactor at Khusab
Supplied tritium that could help increase bomb yields
France

Designed Chashma plutonium extraction plant
Contracted to renovate controls at Kanupp
Germany

Supplied nuclear fuel fabrication equipment and technology, including high-powered welding and drilling lasers
Supplied factory to make uranium hexafluoride used at Kahuta enrichment plant
Sold electronic components to control gas centrifuges
Exported "preforms" for gas centrifuge scoops for Kahuta enrichment plant
Supplied natural lithium, useful in making tritium for boosted nuclear weapons
Set up tritium gas purification plant and provided a small amount of tritium for testing
Supplied information for design and construction of secret research reactor
Netherlands

Source of centrifuge design, materials and manufacturing equipment secretly procured by Dr. A.Q. Khan
Norway

Sold computers and software useful in nuclear weapon design
Sweden

Supplied flash X-ray machines, useful in nuclear weapon development
Switzerland

Supplied components for centrifuge enrichment plant
Supplied high vacuum valves and gasification and solidification units
United States

Supplied Pakistan's first research reactor and fuel which Pakistan used for secret experiments in tritium production

will be waiting for you

 

[Windjammer]

The only country that isnt in the news these days for any failures is pakistan simply because they arent trying in any feild .......just because they will doom back to stone age fighting the monster that they created (Taliban)

It dosent hurt us that the mission failed because we are people who have rose from the ashes of failures to pinnacle of success

That doesn't seem to be the case with your set up since they feel jittery with even 18 F-16s. When the crunch came, we left you bewildered with our nuclear and missile technology, as they say, never give up till the fight is done so a trifle early on your exposure.

 

[scrumpy]

This is a setback. Not the end of the Indian space program. Sooner rather than later Isro will put a satellite up using the GSLV. They have done this before and I am sure they will do it again.

 

[BelligerentPacifist]

Space programmes are very complex and fraught with difficulties. Launches fail and cash goes down the pot. This will adds to failure management strategies and design improvements for ISRO.

After all, this is only the first ahem ahem indigenous engine India has reportedly fielded.

 

[Windjammer]

This is a setback. Not the end of the Indian space program. Sooner rather than later Isro will put a satellite up using the GSLV. They have done this before and I am sure they will do it again.

That's all very well scrumpy, i am sure sooner or later they will achieve in their objective, but here you have half a dozen Indian members debating with a solitary Pakistani member, there must be a question of morality, albeit they are merely trying to salvage their pride but hey, empty pots make a lot of noise..... as the saying goes.

 

[ARCHON]

That's all very well scrumpy, i am sure sooner or later they will achieve in their objective, but here you have half a dozen Indian members debating with a solitary Pakistani member, there must be a question of morality, albeit they are merely trying to salvage their pride but hey, empty pots make a lot of noise..... as the saying goes.

Its proven that this is a full pot.

Empty pots make lots of noise ... as the saying goes.

 

[xman]

Russia agreed in 1993 and the deal was most probably singed later that year or next year in 1994.

The first engine was shipped to india in 1998 and eventually 7 were bought.
In those 12 years since india got the engine as well as the technology know how the engine is still very complicated to study learn and produce. The kavir engine india wants to make for LCA is not even ready yet and the work is being done for the past many years and still some sources say the engine may not be ready for the next 5-10 years.

you have f-16 but i Bet you cannot even build your own glider.

 

[imran iqbal]

Patents Filed by ISRO

ISRO

ISRO has also obtained 105 patents to protect the intellectual proprietary further rights and 209 patent applications are in various stages of processing. ISRO has executed over 270 consultancy projects in high technology areas to provide support to various industries.

Simultaneously, ISRO has been investing in developing a patent portfolio, which now consists of 270 patents, 24copyrights and 10 trademarks. Even in this area, while ISRO's objective has been to safeguard the technologies developed in ISRO Centres, simultaneously, the approach has been to enable maximal commercial exploitation of such resources through appropriate technology transfers or licensing schemes.

 

[AgNoStiC MuSliM]

Closed to let people cool off.

 

[Ghareeb_Da_Baal]

 

[Creder]

gayi bhains pani main........better luck next time Isro

katta ve nal lay gayi

 

[faithfulguy]

There is nothig to be dissapointed guys...this failure has now made this sure that India will definitely launch it cause this has now become a matter of prestige for the ISRO. Infact we dont even have to wait fora year now.

Even God would have rested after 29 continuous successful launches..we should be taking it as a first step toward sucess...

So prior to this launch, it was not a matter of prestige for the ISRO? Just curious about how it now has become a matter of prestige and wasn't prior to this latest launch?

 

[luffy]

one must learn to respect scientist whichever country they belong to...

 

[Novice09]

Great comment from a person whose country is number one is space technology

Defeat is not the worst of failures. Not to have tried is the true failure.

Develop success from failures. Discouragement and failure are two of the surest stepping stones to success.