Indian Army tortures Kashmir village in freezing winter night

[fd24]

I like Abishek already state feel the primary grief and concern is for the Kashmiri people. Most people on here that are putting flaming and abusive posts have never visited the place nor have an interest in the place. To them its just strategical and a place never to be allowed to rest.

Kashimir - my solution

The Judgment of Solomon refers to a story from the Hebrew Bible in which King Solomon of Israel ruled between two women (in our case Pakistan and India) both claiming to be the mother of a child (in our case the child is Kashmir). It has become a metaphor referring to a wise judge who uses a stratagem to determine the truth, tricking the parties into revealing their true feelings. Specifically, the judge pretends that he will destroy the subject matter of a dispute, rather than allowing either disputing party to win at the expense of the other.

If you love the land and the people then let them decide - whatever they decide - accept and lets walk away and let them live in peace. Does it not make sense rather than to allow unnecessary hardship and more deaths. If you love Kashmir then let it live and let it go....

 

[AbhimanyuShrivastav]

I like Abishek already state feel the primary grief and concern is for the Kashmiri people. Most people on here that are putting flaming and abusive posts have never visited the place nor have an interest in the place. To them its just strategical and a place never to be allowed to rest.

Kashimir - my solution

The Judgment of Solomon refers to a story from the Hebrew Bible in which King Solomon of Israel ruled between two women (in our case Pakistan and India) both claiming to be the mother of a child (in our case the child is Kashmir). It has become a metaphor referring to a wise judge who uses a stratagem to determine the truth, tricking the parties into revealing their true feelings. Specifically, the judge pretends that he will destroy the subject matter of a dispute, rather than allowing either disputing party to win at the expense of the other.

If you love the land and the people then let them decide - whatever they decide - accept and lets walk away and let them live in peace. Does it not make sense rather than to allow unnecessary hardship and more deaths. If you love Kashmir then let it live and let it go....

I dont think any one is forcing any Kashmiri to live in India if he/she does not want to.. The question though is that does Paksitan love Kashmiris enough to accept them without the land of Kashmir. Or is the concern for Kashmiris just a farce to hide Pakistan's true intentions of land grab ? I guess we all know the answer to that. So you can safely can away the fake sentimental appeals

 

[Jade]

I like Abishek already state feel the primary grief and concern is for the Kashmiri people. Most people on here that are putting flaming and abusive posts have never visited the place nor have an interest in the place. To them its just strategical and a place never to be allowed to rest.

Kashimir - my solution

The Judgment of Solomon refers to a story from the Hebrew Bible in which King Solomon of Israel ruled between two women (in our case Pakistan and India) both claiming to be the mother of a child (in our case the child is Kashmir). It has become a metaphor referring to a wise judge who uses a stratagem to determine the truth, tricking the parties into revealing their true feelings. Specifically, the judge pretends that he will destroy the subject matter of a dispute, rather than allowing either disputing party to win at the expense of the other.

If you love the land and the people then let them decide - whatever they decide - accept and lets walk away and let them live in peace. Does it not make sense rather than to allow unnecessary hardship and more deaths. If you love Kashmir then let it live and let it go....

You don't understand Kashmir. That is why such a non implementable and simplified 'solution'

 

[skyknight]

why don't you free Tibet ?

Tibet was freed from serfdom by PLA 60 years ago.
For Dalai Lama and the serf owners, new Tibet is jail，while for the serfs new Tibet is the heaven.
The lamas belong to Dalai lama faction do not represent the common Tibetan people.
Most Tibetan people have a far better life than most Indians, and the gap becomes bigger and bigger.

 

[skyknight]

[video]http://politics.people.com.cn/mediafile/201107/01/F201107011359021664930033.jpg[/video]

 

[buddyboyyash]

Tibet was freed from serfdom by PLA 60 years ago.
For Dalai Lama and the serf owners, new Tibet is jail，while for the serfs new Tibet is the heaven.
The lamas belong to Dalai lama faction do not represent the common Tibetan people.
Most Tibetan people have a far better life than most Indians, and the gap becomes bigger and bigger.

does that justify inhuman treatment of lamas??....

its funny how if we say we saved kashmir from pakistan and how the pics of saving stranded people etc etc...its all false propaganda....also wen we say they are paid stone pelters....its all false right??...

wen u say u are working for tibet etc etc...post a few pics of monks....yaaaaa...tibet is a wonderful place and chinese army is most innocent of all...obviously monks live in tibet...not everyday army goes on killing for fun....

same with india

wat u r doing something known as DOUBLE STANDARDS....which kills constructive debate!!!!

 

[fd24]

I dont think any one is forcing any Kashmiri to live in India if he/she does not want to.. The question though is that does Paksitan love Kashmiris enough to accept them without the land of Kashmir. Or is the concern for Kashmiris just a farce to hide Pakistan's true intentions of land grab ? I guess we all know the answer to that. So you can safely can away the fake sentimental appeals

I think you have also answered my question. You would rather the baby be cut in half - fair enough thats your opinion. What i believe is there is deep rooted anxiety and sensitivity regarding this issue and is at the core of most of our qualms. What i suggested was just MY solution. If anyone has a definitive way of resolving the issue feel free to post. However please post and its about time we thought of the people that are actually belonging to the land and what their views are. We can all object and protest and voice concern - we are not the ones that are living with the everyday people. btw - i have no fake sentimental appeals - just genuine

 

[buddyboyyash]

shud i start posting pics of how beautiful and peaceful kashmir is??...i have visited it and its really heaven on earth...but noooooooooo

it will all be propaganda and m just trying to fool people...

 

[Abhishek_]

A few photo ops by the Chinese Army "rescuing" people isn't going to change the ground reality. You're not fooling anybody here, we know the truth and the tibetan people know the truth hence they seek their liberation.

well said
reminds of the thread about forcing tibetans to celebrate new year, or else

 

[skyknight]

 

[skyknight]

shud i start posting pics of how beautiful and peaceful kashmir is??...i have visited it and its really heaven on earth...but noooooooooo

it will all be propaganda and m just trying to fool people...

Go post，
I show the development in Tibet，and also you can do the same thing.
Go post what happened in Kashmir in Sikkim

 

[Subramanian]

I think you have also answered my question. You would rather the baby be cut in half - fair enough thats your opinion. What i believe is there is deep rooted anxiety and sensitivity regarding this issue and is at the core of most of our qualms. What i suggested was just MY solution. If anyone has a definitive way of resolving the issue feel free to post. However please post and its about time we thought of the people that are actually belonging to the land and what their views are. We can all object and protest and voice concern - we are not the ones that are living with the everyday people. btw - i have no fake sentimental appeals - just genuine

the issue is pretty much solved as of now.Nobody is interested in it and if pakistan is,they have to initiate the dialogue.

 

[buddyboyyash]

beautiful kashmir - Google Search

m too busy studying....so heres a lil shortcut....

 

[Abingdonboy]

Okay, okay. We all know mistakes have been made n the Indian side in regards to Kashmir for which actions have been/ar being taken. However it is a bit rich for Chinese members to sit there and claim moral superiority when we all know what is going on in China and how brutal minorities are treated the only difference is this is done behind closed doors, monks don't set themselves alight for nothing. And it is even worse for Pakistanis to claim to be on the side of the Kashmiris when it has been as a direct result of their govt stoking the fires in Kashmir that so much bloodshed (on both sides) has been caused.

The GoI/IA should be lauded for, despite the best efforts by her neighbour, Kashmir is now relatively quiet, safe and prosperous- having the best tourist year in recent times in 2011.

 

[skyknight]

beautiful kashmir - Google Search

m too busy studying....so heres a lil shortcut....

Show us the true smile of Kashmir and Sikkim people， show us how the India gov. work for local people, show how the local people love
India? can you?