What's new

India wants Bangladesh land for Agartala airport expansion

Homo Sapiens

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
9,641
Reaction score
-1
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
http://www.newagebd.net/article/80277/india-wants-bangladesh-land-for-expansion

India wants Bangladesh land for Agartala airport expansion
Muktadir Rashid | Published: 00:02, Aug 01,2019 | Updated: 11:00, Aug 01,2019



80277_199.jpg



India has proposed to expand its Agartala airport into the Bangladesh territory in
Brahmanbaria for an upgrade to international standards, Bangladesh officials said.


The home minister, Asaduzzaman Khan, told New Age on Monday that the government was yet to make any decision on the issue.

India, which already has obtained transit and transshipment facilities, has made the proposal at several meetings in the past one year.

The foreign ministry held a meeting in October with other relevant ministries and intelligence agencies to examine whether or how Bangladesh could share its land with India for the expansion of Agartala Airport in Tripura which was renamed as Maharaja Bir Bikram Airport on August 7, 2018.

None of the officials disclosed the amount of land that India has sought but a defence ministry official said that the existing Agartala airport and its runway were located less than a kilometre off the border at Chanpur of Akhaura.

A defence ministry official posted to Hazrat Shahjalal International Airport in Dhaka said that aircraft from Kolkata and Guwahati needed to use the Bangladesh airspace during take-off and landing at Agartala airport.

India first made the proposal at a bilateral meeting in July 2018 when India’s the then home minister Rajnath Singh, now the defence minister, visited Bangladesh.

‘As we were approached on the issue at the meeting, we asked them to make a formal proposal,’ the civil aviation and tourism secretary, Mohibul Haque, said.

Two senior officials who attended the meeting at the foreign ministry in October 2018 said that a military official detailed security issues of the sharing of the Bangladesh territory with India.

‘We also discussed how the airport would be managed and whether the bordering land would be leased out and what might be the process if the government wanted to share the land with India,’ one official said.

Another official who attended the meeting drew a map and showed if the Agartala airport was extended, India would install lights inside the Bangladesh territory and would fence it for airport security.


The foreign secretary, Shahidul Haque, said, ‘No decision has yet been made. A number of ministries are related to the issue and the ministries are coordinating themselves on the issue.’

He said that all who attended the meeting in October 2018 received the Indian proposal positively. ‘Everyone thinks that part of our land will be well connected.’

At the meeting, he also argued that Geneva International Airport falls partly in Switzerland and partly in France, he added.

Established in 1920, the Geneva airport lies in the Swiss territory while its northern boundary runs along the border and the airport can be accessed from both Switzerland and France.


Freight operations are also accessible from both the countries, making Geneva a European Union freight hub although Switzerland is not a member of the European Union.

The airport, which is the property of the state of Geneva, is an autonomous public institution.

In 2018, more than 17 million passengers used the airport connected to 148 destinations by 57 airlines. There are a number of such airports in Europe and the US-Canada borders.

Whether allowing the land would affect national security, the foreign secretary said that people related to security issues would decide the matter. ‘I have seen it in a broader perspective and also in terms of business and mobility.’

He argued that there were cross-border airports in different countries. ‘Many countries use the same airport.’

Dhaka University international relations teacher Imtiaz Ahmed said that Europe and South Asia were not similar in terms of, among others, border management, immigration system or currency policy.

He said that there are questions as to whether the airport would be managed by both the countries or it would be a joint venture.

‘If it is a joint venture, then we can consider,’ said Imtiaz, ‘otherwise, it is not logical.’


The home minister, Asaduzzaman Khan, said, ‘We do not give land to anyone this way… No decision has yet been made.’

Former civil aviation minister Rashed Khan Menon, also the Workers Party of Bangladesh president, was surprised at the proposal. ‘How can an airport be expanded into my country? The government will face stiff resistance on the issue. This is not logical considering political, economic and aviation affairs,’ he said.

‘We should expand our airports, not other’s. Our people should not go to Kolkata via Agartala. I want to go to Kolkata from here. I want seven sister states of India to use Sylhet airport to reach other states in India,’ Menon said.

The Indo-Asian News Service reported from Agartala on June 24 that after Guwahati and Imphal, Agartala airport was set to become the third international airport in India’s north-east by 2019 or early 2020.

The report quoted Tripura’s the then transport and tourism minister Pranajit Singha Roy as saying that the Airport Authority of India planned to upgrade Agartala airport to international standards by 2019 or early 2020.

The Indian airport authorities took up a project involving Rs 438 crore (about Tk 538 crore) to upgrade Agartala airport to international standards while the Indian government has already provided the authorities with 72 acres of land for the construction of the terminal building, runway and other necessary infrastructure, the report said.

Once the project is completed, Pranajit told the news agency, flights would run between Agartala and Dhaka as well as other Bangladeshi cities such as Chattogram and Sylhet.

Tripura’s the then king Bir Bikram Kishore Manikya Bahadur built the airport in 1942 where three airliners now run on an average 14 flights on the Agartala–Kolkata, Agartala–Guwahati and Agartala–Delhi routes.

More about:
 
.
We need to firmly reject such proposal. Agartala airport runway touched border fencing. this is not good. If they are willing to expand, they need to choose another location away from border area.

Former civil aviation minister Rashed Khan Menon, also the Workers Party of Bangladesh president, was surprised at the proposal. ‘How can an airport be expanded into my country? The government will face stiff resistance on the issue. This is not logical considering political, economic and aviation affairs,’ he said.

‘We should expand our airports, not other’s. Our people should not go to Kolkata via Agartala. I want to go to Kolkata from here. I want seven sister states of India to use Sylhet airport to reach other states in India,’ Menon said.
He is right, giving India transit and trans-shipment is not our interest. Our interest best serves, if we can make north east India and Eastern India dependent on our products, facilities. This transit, trans-shipment is a stupid and self damaging things Awami League is doing. Rashed Khan Menon may be communist, but he maintain more patriotism than many Awami League leaders.
 
Last edited:
.
We need to firmly reject such proposal. Agartala airport runway touched border fencing. this is not good. If they are willing to expand, they need to choose another location away from border area.


He is right, giving India transit and trans-shipment is not our interest. Our interest best serves, if we can make north east India and Eastern India dependent on our products, facilities. This transit, trans-shipment is a stupid and self damaging things Awami League is doing. Rashed Khan Menon may be communist, but he maintain more patriotism than many Awami League leaders.

I have new respect for this Menon guy, communist though he is.

His head is screwed on right at least.

We are expanding Dhaka International Airport third terminal to double passenger handling capacity in the interim and there are plans to build a huge airport outside Dhaka at least having ten times the traffic capacity of Agartala. Dhaka has INTERNATIONAL connectivity to more destinations than all their regional airports combined since the sixties and which is true even more today. These Indian guys are nuts.

There is no significant traffic demand at Agartala/Chowkir-tola Airport and it never will have it. Even if they spend millions on it.
 
. .
They should relocate the airport. Or they should pay us transit fees & use Cumilla Airport instead.

Cumilla Airport needs to be renovated and put to use as a secondary emergency diversion airport just in case there are crashes etc. at Dhaka. But ideally nowadays, it takes only a couple (or three) hours at best to get to Dhaka from Cumilla/Agartala (40 miles or 64 KM). So I don't know if Cumilla is still needed as an airport.
 
.
Why would they construct an airport just 1 kilometer away from the border in the first place? Airports are important strategic assets, why would they put one in the line of fire to become the first causality in the case of a conflict?

Besides, this literally gotta be a first where a country is expecting another country to give them land just because their air port expansion designs some how ended up including the territory of this second country.
 
.
Why would they construct an airport just 1 kilometer away from the border in the first place? Airports are important strategic assets, why would they put one in the line of fire to become the first causality in the case of a conflict?

Besides, this literally gotta be a first where a country is expecting another country to give them land just because their air port expansion designs some how ended up including the territory of this second country.
Because we don't see a conflict with Bangladesh in the near future or ever.

In the future when we have open borders with Bangladesh it will make sense. And no, there are countries who have airports or things like that shared between countries this is nothing new.
 
. .
Because we don't see a conflict with Bangladesh in the near future or ever.

In the future when we have open borders with Bangladesh it will make sense. And no, there are countries who have airports or things like that shared between countries this is nothing new.

Except you used to trade shots on the border with them just a few years back.
And while the current government might be sitting in india's lap, how long do you expect that to last?

So predicting and assuming "always" in the case of borders and neighbors is a bit too much of optimism isn't it?
 
.
Except you used to trade shots on the border with them just a few years back.
And while the current government might be sitting in india's lap, how long do you expect that to last?

So predicting and assuming "always" in the case of borders and neighbors is a bit too much of optimism isn't it?
Not with their army, just smugglers and for good reason, they do carry arms with them. Their government is not sitting in anyones lap. It's just we like to needle those loonies in PDF a bit. But their governments have largely been neutral to India at times side with India. Why a Pakistani expect India to fight with every other neighbors? We have very warm relationship with almost all our neighbors except Pakistan.

Not really, we worked the same with Nepal, or Bhutan at different levels. With time it will be implemented with friendly countries like Myanmar, BD. This airport is a special and unique case.
 
.
Except you used to trade shots on the border with them just a few years back.
And while the current government might be sitting in india's lap, how long do you expect that to last?

So predicting and assuming "always" in the case of borders and neighbors is a bit too much of optimism isn't it?

Well it is our design, our proposal rather request. Ultimately it's upto the government of Bangladesh to make the final call. I bet GOI will be willing to pay a good amount or even swap land elsewhere along Indo-Bangla border. So how come it became an issue for a third party ?? :azn:
 
.
Why would they construct an airport just 1 kilometer away from the border in the first place? Airports are important strategic assets, why would they put one in the line of fire to become the first causality in the case of a conflict?

Besides, this literally gotta be a first where a country is expecting another country to give them land just because their air port expansion designs some how ended up including the territory of this second country.
It was built during ww2 & used by USAF 4 Combat Cargo Group as a base. Radcliffe manipulated the border there just so the airport falls inside Tripura. The runway is just few meters from the Zero line.
 
.
Bullshit idea from GOI...Why can not they upgrade another airport in NE if Tripura do not have any land.
 
.
Dhaka has INTERNATIONAL connectivity to more destinations than all their regional airports combined since the sixties and which is true even more today.
Are u seriously comparing a regional airport, that too in the north east with you international airport in capital city of your country?
 
.
‘We should expand our airports, not other’s. Our people should not go to Kolkata via Agartala. I want to go to Kolkata from here. I want seven sister states of India to use Sylhet airport to reach other states in India,’ Menon said.
Well said. At least, he learned something about airports when he was aviation minister.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom