India the fascist ?

[WAR-rior]

Those people who see Indian politics with reference to european examples need restructuring their knowledge and beliefs. Simple question. How many riots do you see in Gujarat in past 10 years? Also Dictatorship in India is not possible unlike Pakistan.

On Topic: I only see this Congressies at work. They have a strong lobby in America.

 

[Indischer]

Who said Hitler was a dictator Sir? - He was 'elected' into office as an ambassador of hope and glory, He targeted the Jews in his speeches and had a reputation of a Prophet of hate.

Not, to forget that everything Hitler did in Germany was 'Perfectly legal'.

He may have been elected to Office, but what he did after that to secure and consolidate his power can only be termed as a Dictatorship. I am absolutely confident that Mr Modi can't pull off such moves even in his wildest dreams here. Indian electoral politics withstood an Indira Gandhi. Narendra Modi is a cake by those standards.

Exactly.

Not only that but Hitler was elected because the German people felt that the country was going in the wrong direction and needed a hardliner.

What they got was a fascist.

The parallels between how Hitler came to power and Modi coming to power are eerily similar.

Tell me, which WorldWar has India lost? Is there hyperinflation in India? Has India been genuinely humiliated and harshly treated by any of her neighbours?

The circumstances are not the same and neither are the demands. It's the rampant corruption and mismanagement of the Congress-led UPA Govt that has in a way forced the people to look forward to a better administrator. That Modi was able to subvert his party leadership and project himself as a reform & growth-oriented leader only indicates how shallow the BJP has become of late.

 

[Chronos]

Where are 14 points for protection of the minorities in pakistan??? any ways this is a modi bashing thread, thus I dont want to derail it, btw please dont forget the Direct action day where Jiannah famously quoted "Go to the Congress and ask them their plans. When they take you into their confidence I will take you into mine. Why do you expect me alone to sit with folded hands? I also am going to make trouble." and the trouble costed pretty well "4,000 people lost their lives and 100,000 residents in the city of Calcutta were left homeless."

Comparing Modi to hitler is going to far IMO. And it makes the guy who levels those criticism look ridiculous.

Guess what is going to happen when Modi comes to power? Nothing

 

[Ajatashatru]

That maybe what you believe. Jinnah was not even a little bit of a fascist
Nor did he kill people, nor encouraged them by saying 'let people vent their frustration'.

Jinnah's demand did lead to massacring of millions and the largest migrations in human history. The partition of India due to people like Jinnah also caused irreparable damage to the reputation of Islam and Muslims in India. People started seeing Muslims as intolerant people not capable of living in harmony with other faiths.

 

[Alpha1]

Jinnah's demand did lead to massacring of millions and the largest migrations in human history.

It was not only Jinnah's demand but the choice of the Muslims. Period

 

[Ajatashatru]

It was not only Jinnah's demand but the choice of the Muslims. Period

That's why one-third of Muslims stayed behind. It was only the choice of intolerant Muslims. The tolerant ones stayed behind.

 

[Arya Desa]

Good. We need a Hitler to remove pollution from India.

 

[Contrarian]

Exactly another leader with religious agenda's and alleged role in communal violence was M.A. Jinnah.... indeed people have short memories...

Where are 14 points for protection of the minorities in pakistan??? any ways this is a modi bashing thread, thus I dont want to derail it, btw please dont forget the Direct action day where Jiannah famously quoted "Go to the Congress and ask them their plans. When they take you into their confidence I will take you into mine. Why do you expect me alone to sit with folded hands? I also am going to make trouble." and the trouble costed pretty well "4,000 people lost their lives and 100,000 residents in the city of Calcutta were left homeless."

A political party nominates a leader with communal ties- "India is Facist"

Communal riots retaliation of kar sevak burnt Alive - "India hates muslim"

India buys a used a/c carrier - "India is region Hegemon"

and suggesting communal role of M.A. Jinnah is subversive?

Quoted to emphasize.

When Jinnah does it , its Kosher, when someone else does it it becomes fascist.

 

[Manvantaratruti]

When Jinnah does it , its Kosher, when someone else does it it becomes fascist.

I hope you are not comparing a genuine mass leader like Modi to a snobby british stooge like Jinnah. I would rather have him being compared to Hitler

 

[Trichy]

I don't understand it in Politics, If a Muslim or Christian speak about their religion in open or in mass gathering they are called SECULAR ones, if the same a Hindu did, its called COMMUNAL.. WTF it is..?

Just a simple question, if a Hindu Group Killed/Burned a group or people back from Huj/Vatican in Pakistan/USA/Italy/Saudi Arabia/Bangladesh after that that Hindu community is left in that country?

in India Hindus are so tolerable to other religions that's why in the name of minority most people used to convert and spread the hate among them-self in India..

Simple Question to the Barkers, if the Train with Pilgrims did not burnt alive, is there any way to happen 2002 riots? Muslims started the Riots so they must me responsible for that.

 

[Manvantaratruti]

I don't understand it in Politics, If a Muslim or Christian speak about their religion in open or in mass gathering they are called SECULAR ones, if the same a Hindu did, its called COMMUNAL.. WTF it is..?

Just a simple question, if a Hindu Group Killed/Burned a group or people back from Huj/Vatican in Pakistan/USA/Italy/Saudi Arabia/Bangladesh after that that Hindu community is left in that country?

in India Hindus are so tolerable to other religions that's why in the name of minority most people used to convert and spread the hate among them-self in India..

Simple Question to the Barkers, if the Train with Pilgrims did not burnt alive, is there any way to happen 2002 riots? Muslims started the Riots so they must me responsible for that.

This is called 'secularism'.

Hindus should never used the word 'Hindu' or the word 'Muslim' or 'christian'. These words are Taboo.

If you use this word in any discussion or in any post you loose your certificate of secularism. You become 'Facist' or 'RSS' or 'saffron terrorist' or 'Internet Hindu'.

Only muslims and christians are allowed to use the word 'muslim' and 'christians' respectively.

A Hindu is also not allowed to ask the religion of anyone. If you do so, you are communal. You will loose your certificate of secularism.

There are a few more rules..... but if you get the general rule you are on your way to masters in secularism.