India should avoid ICBM Race

[faithfulguy]

No ways India should avoid ICBM race. As fast as possible we should have our own ICBM, like other super powers

There are 5 countries in the world that has ICBMs but only 1 superpower

So have an ICBM doesn't make one country a superpower. Even North Korea and Iran can soon make ICBMs, does that make these countries super powers.

 

[faithfulguy]

With SLBMs on Nuke sub (Arihant SSBN?) India already has virtual ICBM capability. We dont need to make enemies out of our friends by developing land based ICBMs.
Our top priority should be on tactical missiles and BMD systems. We should be capable of withstanding the nuke blackmail from our irresponsible neighbors.
Our strategic missiles are quite adequate at present.

SLBM also has different ranges. Trident I is actually not a ICBM ranged SLBM. I do agree that India needs tactical missiles more and also BMD. The biggest enemy facing India is actually the terrorist that Pakistan is fight right now. You never know when the terrorist is going to acquire a nuclear missle and fire at Bombay. A BMD would be perfect for such a scenario as the terrorist generally steal a missile and they are generally short ranged missile.

 

[BJlaowai]

SLBM also has different ranges. Trident I is actually not a ICBM ranged SLBM. I do agree that India needs tactical missiles more and also BMD. The biggest enemy facing India is actually the terrorist that Pakistan is fight right now. You never know when the terrorist is going to acquire a nuclear missle and fire at Bombay. A BMD would be perfect for such a scenario as the terrorist generally steal a missile and they are generally short ranged missile.

I never said Intercontinental range SLBM on nuke sub. Even an Intermediate range (2000~4000Kms) range SLBM on nuke sub (SSBN)) will give the same effect as land based ICBM. If need be, the SSBN like Arihant with K-15 missiles, hiding in north Atlantic will cover large parts of north-America and Europe.

 

[Abu Zolfiqar]

A think tank from a nation vows to eat grass (read: ready to live in extreme poverty) to defeat India should weigh his word before preaching some thing against its own deeds and ideology. More powers brings more responsibilities. I am not talking about this thread ICBM etc but your think tank responsibilities.

Regards

your concerns have been noted...


thank you.

 

[Roby]

how about feeding your 350-400 million poor first...1/3 of the worlds poorest people are in india

India is poor

 

[KS]

A think tank from a nation vows to eat grass (read: ready to live in extreme poverty) to defeat India should weigh his word before preaching some thing against its own deeds and ideology. More powers brings more responsibilities. I am not talking about this thread ICBM etc but your think tank responsibilities.

Regards

right on his face...!!!!

 

[ARCHON]

how about feeding your 350-400 million poor first...1/3 of the worlds poorest people are in india

Poverty can be calculated on the base of No of Mobile Users in India.
India has 650 million of Mobile users in the world 2nd highest after China. Out of every 100 Indian 65 are using Mobile phone.Even a beggar in the street is holding Mobile Phone in India.

 

[democracyspeaks]

u guys don't have anything more than getting emotional over advice that was given to you

take it or leave it....


(you'll probably leave it, meaning you'll pretend like india is some rich developed country when almost half your country is in abject poverty)



good strategy

This has nothing to do with the topic. but if you insist on trolling what can we do.

By the way only Poor pakistan thinks that India is poor, I guess the world sees India as an Economic Super Power after China, I guess the world opinion is wrong everytime and again the pakistanis are right as usual

Getting back to the topic definitely we need ICBMS and belive me there will be no sanctions against India. World needs India more than we need them. Each and every country wants to do business with India no matter which sector it is.

Regarding ICBMS apart from mainland we need to put these ICBMs on Andaman and other Indian Islands.

 

[Indian_Idol]

we should develop a ICBM and we cant take a chance... i think it should be like our nuclear program no first use or used until provoked to do so... since we Indians dont have any imperialistic policy, our ICBM program is not going to harm anybody...

 

[ek_indian]

If someone give me "yield vs range" chart I would bee able to say someting.

Currently Agni three has 3500+ km of range with 2490 kg warhead. If someone let us know what is the actual warhead size in Indian inventory, perhaps we would be able to see more clearly.

 

[Indian_Idol]

how about feeding your 350-400 million poor first...1/3 of the worlds poorest people are in india

answering a troll becomes a troll so sorry for trolling...

in the entire forum i could see only this thing as a failure of GOI as per our Pak and Chinese friends, soon we will rectify it. and I'm very glad that in all other sectors we have been good.. our poverty will come to the least single digit in a decade or earlier.. so big thanks for you guys for such a loving concern & care of our poor people...

 

[below_freezing]

Poverty can be calculated on the base of No of Mobile Users in India.
India has 650 million of Mobile users in the world 2nd highest after China. Out of every 100 Indian 65 are using Mobile phone.Even a beggar in the street is holding Mobile Phone in India.

this only means one thing: those beggars are idiots because they bought a phone but not enough food to live to use it.

the only attack indian ICBMs would pull of is an economic attack on india's poor. If it tried it on anyone else, it would be a very foolish move.

 

[ARCHON]

this only means one thing: those beggars are idiots because they bought a phone but not enough food to live to use it.

the only attack indian ICBMs would pull of is an economic attack on india's poor. If it tried it on anyone else, it would be a very foolish move.

They use it to order pizza...

 

[Prometheus]

how about feeding your 350-400 million poor first...1/3 of the worlds poorest people are in india

 

[Luftwaffe]

faithfulguy...the term super power is obsolete its is a word to give sense of pride nothing more..you mean to say a super power that is given credit by China to survive the economic depression? if this is the case than i am sorry to inform you there is not a single super power on the earth if since any nation is pron to this economic depression.
Just as there is no agreement over the definition of terrorism majority won't agree on definition of superpower = America move on when nukes falls on a nation calling themselves super power nothing is left just powerless and revenge..


For few indians...Is icbm important or feeding these really deserving people..