What's new

India rejects China's contention on signing NPT, says France was included in NSG without signing it

dadeechi

BANNED
Joined
Sep 12, 2015
Messages
4,281
Reaction score
-8
Country
India
Location
United States
India rejects China's contention on signing NPT, says France was included in NSG without signing it

Last Updated: Friday, May 20, 2016 - 22:50


490827-vikash-swaroop-on-china.jpg




New Delhi: India on Friday rejected China's contention that it must sign the NPT to get membership of the Nuclear Suppliers Group, saying France was included in the elite group without signing the Non-Proliferation Treaty.

2387

"I think there is some confusion here. Even the NPT allows civil nuclear cooperation with non-NPT countries. If there is a connection, it is between the NSG and IAEA safeguards and with export controls," External Affairs Ministry Spokesperson Vikas Swarup said.

He was asked about a Chinese official linking China's support to India's bid for NSG to the country signing the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) .

"NSG members have to respect safeguards and export controls, nuclear supplies have to be in accordance with the NSG Guidelines. The NSG is an ad hoc export control regime and France, which was not an NPT member for some time, was a member of the NSG since it respected NSG's objectives," said Swarup.

China has opposed India's bid to get NSG membership on the ground that it was yet to sign the NPT. Its Foreign Ministry spokesman Lu Kang had said all the multilateral non-proliferation export control regime including the NSG have regarded NPT as an important standard for the expansion of the NSG.

"Apart from India, lot of other countries expressed their willingness to join. Then it raised the question to the international community - shall the non-NPT members also become part of the NSG?" he said, adding "China's position is not directed against any specific country but applies to all the non-NPT members".

Liu Zhenmin, China's Vice-Minister of Foreign Affairs, later denied that his country was blocking India's bid for a membership in elite NSG and said it will "work" with the members of the 48-nation grouping as well as India to find a solution.

"Members of the Nuclear Suppliers Group should be party to NPT. So, I think China will also work with others including Indian colleagues together to find a solution," he had said.

President Pranab Mukherjee is likely to raise the issue during his visit to Beijing next week.

PTI

First Published: Friday, May 20, 2016 - 22:35
http://zeenews.india.com/news/india...cluded-in-nsg-without-signing-it_1887549.html
 
. . .
Thats the last try of pakistanis to stop indian entry in NSG and they know its futile and it means only 1 thing india is getting in NSG very soon :cheers::cheers:

China is engaged in the bargain for its entry into MTCR for allowing India into NSG.
 
.
New Delhi: India on Friday rejected China's contention that it must sign the NPT to get membership of the Nuclear Suppliers Group, saying France was included in the elite group without signing the Non-Proliferation Treaty.


Well because France is one of the recognised veto and nuclear powers with full expertise on everything...unlike india which still needs co-operation from France and USA to build its nuclear infrastructure..secondly...France is not India
 
.
Well because France is one of the recognised veto and nuclear powers with full expertise on everything...unlike india which still needs co-operation from France and USA to build its nuclear infrastructure..secondly...France is not India

We all know that. What is it with your opposition with India ?
 
.
France was one of the victorious powers at the end of WW2 so I guess they are an exception.
 
.
France was one of the victorious powers at the end of WW2 so I guess they are an exception.

:rofl::rofl::rofl:

Yup,victorious...a country which surrendered in front of Nazi Germany and remained under its control till 1944.
 
. .
:rofl::rofl::rofl:

Yup,victorious...a country which surrendered in front of Nazi Germany and remained under its control till 1944.
Well the "allies" (France included) did win the war so France can claim victory in the larger picture.
 
.
Well because France is one of the recognised veto and nuclear powers with full expertise on everything...unlike india which still needs co-operation from France and USA to build its nuclear infrastructure..secondly...France is not India

Does not matter. It is not about France per se but about having a "Precedent"

Well the "allies" (France included) did win the war so France can claim victory in the larger picture.

How does allies winning a war related to NSG? That would have been relevant for UNSC.

NSG was created as a reaction to India's nuclear test on 18-May-1974.

It has come a full circle now that the founders of NSG are strongly pushing for India's membership in NSG.
 
.
Does not matter. It is not about France per se but about having a "Precedent"



How does allies winning a war related to NSG? That would have been relevant for UNSC.

NSG was created as a reaction to India's nuclear test on 18-May-1974.

It has come a full circle now that the founders of NSG are strongly pushing for India's membership in NSG.
Well not all countries are equal. Some are more equal than others.:D
 
. .
Well Indians take pride that multiple organizations were created to oppose it's rise. That itself is a testament of it's importance.:D
Would't that include China and the rest of the third world as well.o_O
 
.
Every tom, dick and harry on this thread is conveniently avoiding the exact point which MEA made.

China said, an exception cannot be made for India, which meant it will set a precedent for other non NPT countries.

India is saying, that an exception has already been made for France and thus there is a precedent. Thus, come up with a better reason or allow us entry in to NSG.

Pretty simple and straightforward.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom