What's new

India questions China’s claim of being a developing nation in the latest round of its trade policy review at the World Trade Organisation

beijingwalker

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Nov 4, 2011
Messages
65,195
Reaction score
-55
Country
China
Location
China
India questions China’s claim of being a developing nation in the latest round of its trade policy review at the World Trade Organisation
By CNBCTV18.com |Jan 05, 2022, 05:29 PM IST (Updated)
indiachinaflag1-1019x573.jpg

India has questioned China’s claim that it is a developing country in the latest round of its trade policy review at the World Trade Organisation (WTO).
India claims that China’s per capita income belongs to upper middle income country as per the definition of the World Bank, Business Standard reported.

The World Bank definition

The World Bank defines an upper middle-income country as one which has a per capita income of $4,096 to $12,695. Those with per capita income of $12,696 and above are considered high income countries. According to the Business Standard report, China’s per capita income in 2020 stood at $10,435. United States with $63,413 per capita income is considered a high income nation, while India, with a per capita income of $1928, is in the group of low middle income nations.

What are the advantages of “developing country” status?
According to the World Trade Organisation website, countries with the developing country status enjoy certain rights such as longer transition periods for implementing agreements and technical assistance.

On account of the rapid economic progress, the US has been demanding that India and China voluntarily give up the benefits offered to developing countries at the WTO. However, both the countries have opposed the move.

China’s reply
China has highlighted the lack of a proper definition by international organisations and said the concept of a developing country was relative to developed nations.

At present, members of the WTO themselves assign the “developed” or “developing” country status. Others can challenge a country’s declared status. The country declaring itself as a “developing” nation can take advantage of the provisions available to such countries.

In December, China's ambassador to the WTO Li Chenggang told Reuters in an interview that Beijing was willing to forego many of the benefits even though it would retain its "developing" country status at the global trade body.

On account of lingering poverty, China still considers itself a developing country despite the strong growth, Li Chenggang had said. However, he declined to say when the country would completely cease to consider itself a developing country.

Others have raised alarm too
India is not the only one to question China’s developing country status. The US has also criticised its developing country status and said it was unfair of Beijing to avail preferential treatment intended for poorer countries.

Brazil, Indonesia and the European Union too raised an alarm over the issue.

India had sought an explanation of China’s claim that it has shifted “from a stage of high-speed growth to a stage of high-quality development”. In reply, China said ‘high-quality development’ will include a new development concept with innovation as the first driving force.

 
.
India questions China’s claim of being a developing nation in the latest round of its trade policy review at the World Trade Organisation
By CNBCTV18.com |Jan 05, 2022, 05:29 PM IST (Updated)
indiachinaflag1-1019x573.jpg

India has questioned China’s claim that it is a developing country in the latest round of its trade policy review at the World Trade Organisation (WTO).
India claims that China’s per capita income belongs to upper middle income country as per the definition of the World Bank, Business Standard reported.

The World Bank definition

The World Bank defines an upper middle-income country as one which has a per capita income of $4,096 to $12,695. Those with per capita income of $12,696 and above are considered high income countries. According to the Business Standard report, China’s per capita income in 2020 stood at $10,435. United States with $63,413 per capita income is considered a high income nation, while India, with a per capita income of $1928, is in the group of low middle income nations.

What are the advantages of “developing country” status?
According to the World Trade Organisation website, countries with the developing country status enjoy certain rights such as longer transition periods for implementing agreements and technical assistance.

On account of the rapid economic progress, the US has been demanding that India and China voluntarily give up the benefits offered to developing countries at the WTO. However, both the countries have opposed the move.

China’s reply
China has highlighted the lack of a proper definition by international organisations and said the concept of a developing country was relative to developed nations.

At present, members of the WTO themselves assign the “developed” or “developing” country status. Others can challenge a country’s declared status. The country declaring itself as a “developing” nation can take advantage of the provisions available to such countries.

In December, China's ambassador to the WTO Li Chenggang told Reuters in an interview that Beijing was willing to forego many of the benefits even though it would retain its "developing" country status at the global trade body.

On account of lingering poverty, China still considers itself a developing country despite the strong growth, Li Chenggang had said. However, he declined to say when the country would completely cease to consider itself a developing country.

Others have raised alarm too
India is not the only one to question China’s developing country status. The US has also criticised its developing country status and said it was unfair of Beijing to avail preferential treatment intended for poorer countries.

Brazil, Indonesia and the European Union too raised an alarm over the issue.

India had sought an explanation of China’s claim that it has shifted “from a stage of high-speed growth to a stage of high-quality development”. In reply, China said ‘high-quality development’ will include a new development concept with innovation as the first driving force.


Congratulations! You are developed and much more advanced ahead of us.
 
. . . .
I dont think a "superpower" like China should fight for status of "developing".
Instead, it should ask UN/WTO/etc to create a new status called "superdeveloped" specially for China.
 
.
" The World Bank defines an upper middle-income country as one which has a per capita income of $4,096 to $12,695. Those with per capita income of $12,696 and above are considered high income countries. According to the Business Standard report, China’s per capita income in 2020 stood at $10,435. "

whats the issue with the developing status?

$10,435 is very much between $4,096 and $12,695


china overall (tier 1 coastal cities aside) is certainly not "developed", so if the WTO only has the two categories, china fits more in the developing category.
 
.
I dont think a "superpower" like China should fight for status of "developing".
Instead, it should ask UN/WTO/etc to create a new status called "superdeveloped" specially for China.

Need Modi's approval for that. After all, Mumbai is shinier than Shanghai and has Narnia in its focus to beat next. A 'game changing' tehcnology and a certain surgical strike, India beats Narnia smooth as baby wipe.
 
. .
Indian cyber warriors mock China for being a poor country but Indian state says China is a developed country. Ouch !
 
. .
Need Modi's approval for that. After all, Mumbai is shinier than Shanghai and has Narnia in its focus to beat next. A 'game changing' tehcnology and a certain surgical strike, India beats Narnia smooth as baby wipe.

You are a funny man; re-read the article again.

India is actually calling China a developed country and that's the point of discussion. China's infrastructure today is far superior to several developed nations. There are some poor people as well, but so are several million poor in countries like UK and USA as well and yet they are called developed.
Indian cyber warriors mock China for being a poor country but Indian state says China is a developed country. Ouch !

Not a single Indian mocks China for being poor. I don't know where you get the idea from, just because geopolitically we have disagreements with the Chinese. China is a far richer country than we are and those with basic geopolitical knowledge know this.
 
.
You are a funny man; re-read the article again.

India is actually calling China a developed country and that's the point of discussion. China's infrastructure today is far superior to several developed nations. There are some poor people as well, but so are several million poor in countries like UK and USA as well and yet they are called developed.


Not a single Indian mocks China for being poor. I don't know where you get the idea from, just because geopolitically we have disagreements with the Chinese. China is a far richer country than we are and those with basic geopolitical knowledge know this.

India may call Mumbai little Hollywood, for all I care.

According to all international bodies, WB, WTO etc., China falls in the category of a developing country in terms of GDP per capita.

Even South Korea asked itself to be removed from developing country category in 2020.

China will likely remain in that category until it sees fit.
 
.
India may call Mumbai little Hollywood, for all I care.

According to all international bodies, WB, WTO etc., China falls in the category of a developing country in terms of GDP per capita.

Even South Korea asked itself to be removed from developing country category in 2020.

China will likely remain in that category until it sees fit.

Ah yes of course.. the benefits of being called a developing country are multifold, isn't it? Well, let's see how this goes. For now, it works in your favor.
 
.
Ah yes of course.. the benefits of being called a developing country are multifold, isn't it? Well, let's see how this goes. For now, it works in your favor.

It probably allows one to mind one's own business more liberally.

A more interventionist country like India (albeit unsuccessfully), may yearn for such title and its understandable.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom