What's new

India needs to prove that illegal immigrants in North Eastern states are Bangladeshis'

Homo Sapiens

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
9,641
Reaction score
-1
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
http://www.newindianexpress.com/nat...-eastern-states-are-bangladeshis-1881645.html

India needs to prove that illegal immigrants in North Eastern states are Bangladeshis'
Published: 06th October 2018 01:11 AM | Last Updated: 06th October 2018 01:11 AM


Gowher Rizvi, the special advisor to Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina however distinguished between the Rohingyas and the illegal immigrants in north-east India.

KOLKATA: Gowher Rizvi, the special advisor to Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, Friday said India needed to prove that the illegal immigrants in the north-eastern states were indeed Bangladeshis.

The controversy over illegal immigrants in the north-eastern states has emerged as a major issue and some of the states have demanded a National Register of Citizens (NRC) on the lines of Assam.

"At present, they (people whose names are not there in the NRC list) are residents of India and India should prove that they are residents of Bangladesh, not India," Rizvi, also a historian, said at an interactive session at the "India Today Conclave - East" here.

On the issue of the Rohingyas, he said, "We should distinguish between the Rohingyas and the illegal immigrants in north-east India. The two cases are entirely different."

The Rohingyas, Rizvi said, were persecuted and deliberately thrown out of Myanmar as a part of ethnic cleansing, adding, "It is not acceptable."

Close to one million Rohingyas are currently living in Bangladesh.

"The immediate burden has fallen on our shoulders. Our prime minister has shown a humanitarian gesture. We are not a wealthy country. But our prime minister has stated that we will share our meals with them," Rizvi said, adding that India was immensely helping Bangladesh by providing relief materials.

"In fact, India was the first country to bring relief to Chittagong. Secondly, India has promised to build homes for the Rohingyas in Myanmar. It essentially means that the Rohingyas would have homes when they go back," he said.

Asked about the chances of Sheikh Hasina and her Awami League in the coming general election in Bangladesh, Rizvi said, "We have established democracy and have thrown the military regime out. Elections are predictable, but even with such a fantastic economic and political record, we cannot comment that we will win."

On West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, he said "We (Bangladesh) have good relations with her. She is universally called 'didi' and we do not have any problem with it."
 
.
Bangladesh already accepting deportee from India after varification. So if Indians want to send their unwanted population to Bangladeshi then they have to give proof.Bangladesh will not accept any people just to honor Indian whims.As simple as that.Follow Internationally recognised method and bilaterally acceptable procedure and deport illegal migrants.Rather than giving communal hate speech to Hindu voters.
 
Last edited:
. .
If the govt officials handling these cases don't expect kickbacks and are clean in their reports, this could easily be done
 
.
If the govt officials handling these cases don't expect kickbacks and are clean in their reports, this could easily be done
NRC proved that there are no muslim immigrant in Assam.
BD never denied that there were hindu migrant in Assam who lost BD citizenship once they accepted Indian citizenship. If India claims that those were recent migrant and not given Indian citizenship then they are free to deport them and BD should not have problem accepting them.

PS: They should receive 100 Dhurra (whipping) in their as$ before coming back to Bangladesh.
 
.
NRC proved that there are no muslim immigrant in Assam.
BD never denied that there were hindu migrant in Assam who lost BD citizenship once they accepted Indian citizenship. If India claims that those were recent migrant and not given Indian citizenship then they are free to deport them and BD should not have problem accepting them.

PS: They should receive 100 Dhurra (whipping) in their as$ before coming back to Bangladesh.

Specially for promoting lie about Bangladesh that hindus are persecuted in Bangladesh.
 
.
Bureaucracy is time taking. We should simply push them into Bangladesh (by hook or crook) and let Bangladesh prove if they are not Bangladeshis.
 
.
Bureaucracy is time taking. We should simply push them into Bangladesh (by hook or crook) and let Bangladesh prove if they are not Bangladeshis.

Instead of talking here, take some action. Do it.

Why sit around and wait? Inspire all your buddies in the shakha now! :-)
 
.
Instead of talking here, take some action. Do it.

Why sit around and wait? Inspire all your buddies in the shakha now! :-)

We ain't Bangladesh. Our foreign policy is much more polished. It ll be quiet and effetcive when we chose to do it. It wont be a slug fest like the Bangladesh Rohingya case.

Probably some other naive like you in Myanmar taunted Bangladeshi government into doing what it did, and Bangladesh government was stupid enough to do it the way it did.

Anyways, i dont think shear force can do this. However denying every possible govt and private service to suspect migrants just might reverse the natural flow of economic immigrants back to Bangladesh. Bangladesh is growing fast and so is the standard of living there. I dont think any non-Bangladeshi origin person would want to go back to Bangldesh simply because of cultural attachment to India. This will be statistically and practical way to address the issue. However there will be collateral damage in adjoining communities.

I think this this identification process is already underway and DOS will begin by next year.
 
.
We ain't Bangladesh. Our foreign policy is much more polished. It ll be quiet and effetcive when we chose to do it. It wont be a slug fest like the Bangladesh Rohingya case.

Probably some other naive like you in Myanmar taunted Bangladeshi government into doing what it did, and Bangladesh government was stupid enough to do it the way it did.

Anyways, i dont think shear force can do this. However denying every possible govt and private service to suspect migrants just might reverse the natural flow of economic immigrants back to Bangladesh. Bangladesh is growing fast and so is the standard of living there. I dont think any non-Bangladeshi origin person would want to go back to Bangldesh simply because of cultural attachment to India. This will be statistically and practical way to address the issue. However there will be collateral damage in adjoining communities.

I think this this identification process is already underway and DOS will begin by next year.

Great plan! Eagerly awaiting formulation of said plan. :-)

By the way the word is 'sheer', not 'shear'....
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom