Modi may be a front for Amit Shah but certainly not for RSS.
Modi-Shah have been working overtime to make RSS irrelevant.
Infact Subramanian swamy is the front for RSS but he can't even get a ministry in Modi's cabinet.
Exactly! .
You are strengthening my argument. Urdu/Hindi are recent inventions with no historical/cultural ties to people of this land.
Comparing Urdu/Hindi with other native languages is like Sindhi, Punjabi, Kashmiri, Gujarati, Marathi Odiya, Pashto, Tamil, Kannada, Telugu, Nepali, Bengali, Assamese, Malayalam, Sinhala etc. is analogous to comparing History of the US to the History of the subcontinent.
The other native languages have 1000s of history while Urdu/Hindi are just few 100 years old.
I would rather take English over Urdu/Hindi any day.
Simple
British created divisions between Hindus and Muslims by dividing the ertwhile Hindustani into Urdu and Hindi.
They then created Indian Muslim League and Hindu Mahasabha to support the adoption of these languages to destroy the native languages and cultures.
The plan was to demonstrate that their English language is older than any South Asia languages overtime.
Jinnah has partially succeeded in making Urdu to replace Punjabi, Sindhi etc, in Pakistan but Sanghis have miserably failed to make Hindi replace original/native Indian languages.
When India gets balkanized, most of those part will merge with Pakistan, Nepal, Bhutan, China, Myanmar, Sri Lanka, Indonesia, Maldives etc.
So you just need to plan around 1/2 a dozen more embassies.
Sanskrit is not an artificial language like Hindi.
If Sanskrit is adopted then British can never claim their superiority over subcontinent.
British needs artificial languages with no history like Urdu and Hindi to be adopted to demonstrate their superiority.
Good one
There is nothing smart about this.
Imposing recent artificial languages like Urdu and Hindi on the people of the subcontinent was & is a nefarious design of the British.
These Sanghis will never declare native languages like Tamil, Malayalam etc.
They are hell bent on imposing artificial language like Urdu/Hindi to destroy the history & culture of the subcontinent.
As a South Indian, I would be happy to learn native languages like Gujarati & Marathi over Urdu-Hindi.
The concept of having a link language is understandable but the selection of Hindi is cruel, criminal and nefarious.
What do you mean by special article for Sikhs in Punjab? There is no such thing.
Hindi-Urdu has no history unlike other native languages. It is an artificial language with only few 100 years history. It is youngest of all the languages in the subcontinent.
None of the Indian religious/historical literature was written in Hindi-Urdu.
This would happen everywhere in India.
Enough of with this Hindi nonsense.
British are no longer ruling India.
Exactly.
Hindi-Urdu are the same language with Urdu having some loan words and script from Persian while Hindi having some loan words and script from Sanskrit.
Both are artificial languages imposed by the British to divide and rule India and idiots of this subcontinent still continue to propagate and support this nonsense.
Pakistanis should learn native languages like Sindhi, Punjabi, Pashto, Balochi, Balti etc. rather than alien and artificial languages like Arabic and Urdu-Hindi.
I couldn't have said it better.