India Muslims Abandon Cow Slaughter in `Eid

[bitter_truth]

How can be that humanity? Are you a cannibal?

exactly..where is humanity in eating cows?
I was just giving you an example by that question.. I am pure veggie..

 

[Biplab Bijay]

NO my dear goats are not sacrificed for one family. even if you sacrifice a goat you have to make three shares.

above all in Pakistan we can NOT get three goats at Rs50K. Goats cost more

Then buy one goat. Sacrifice it. Divide it into 3 . and then distribute.

 

[Spring Onion]

It is about benefit. Since cow is giving milk, that is why it is treated as a holy animal in our religion : This is the explanation. See I know you are intentionally offending my sentiments.

Not offending you . as you said yourself its all about benefits it is NOT religious thing for you

Then buy one goat. Sacrifice it. Divide it into 3 . and then distribute.

oh bhai everyone cant afford a decent goat at Rs40k. wake up

 

[Biplab Bijay]

Not offending you . as you said yourself its all about benefits it is NOT religious thing for you

I did not say . I said the explanation is since it is giving us milk, it is holy : explained in our religion and we worship it.

 

[liall]

will reply your post tomorrow am hurry now will show you how much you waste on those two dozen hindu rituals a year

pffft

 

[Biplab Bijay]

what do you mean selective? lol

selective secular.

 

[Murat Sulemaniyyeh]

Hindus, I have a proposition.

If you are prepared to give up the worship of idols/animals and accept One God, as we find idol,animal worship the biggest sin and injustice ever made, we may talk about cow slaughter.

Until then

 

[halupridol]

37 pages of your "honesty" and "jingoism" against Indian Muslims, Bengalis for merely following their religious dietary laws. Threatening them with violence and claiming they are eating cattle just to anger you.

It is forbidden for a Muslim to follow the prohibition of cow slaughter because it is the belief of another faith. Muslims don't consider idol worship or animal worship legitimate. For us, it is blasphemy and an insult to God.

I quoted you the Quran that cattle slaughter is mandatory on Muslims. We are not allowed to make exceptions to our religion because you don't like it. We disagree with your worship of stone and wooden idols, but we don't force you to abandon your religion.

It is an obligation on every Muslim head of a family to slaughter cattle. We only are required to do this every year, for our holiday to commemorate our father Abraham's dedication when God tested him. God asked him to slaughter his own son, and when he was willing to obey, God stopped him to reward him instead with an animal to sacrifice. Eid is about conviction. We can't change our faith because you don't like it. Sorry.

so no compromise,,just like hindutvas...
btw that Abraham story,,i think he sacrificed a lamb(not cow)

 

[Biplab Bijay]

Not offending you . as you said yourself its all about benefits it is NOT religious thing for you



oh bhai everyone cant afford a decent goat at Rs40k. wake up

That does not mean you offend other's religion. What the poor people do who can not afford a cow ?

 

[bitter_truth]

No it's not. Red meat is more nutritional.

Brother, I wasn't trying to belittle you over your English. I was merely asking you to make it more understandable. I don't write perfect English. I just try to get people to understand what I'm saying.
You're relating Cannibalism to, eating beef? Even I wouldn't expect you to stoop that low. You simply cannot tie a human, to a cow. I don't see you guys giving cows representation in your Government, and building schools for them

no..its a matter of giving respect to other religions.. We worship cow.. Can't you respect it?
And I was just giving an example buddy.. There is no question eating humans as i am pure veggie.

 

[liall]

selective secular.

so you want me to sacrifice an animal even tho I am Hindu?

 

[Biplab Bijay]

so you want me to sacrifice an animal even tho I am Hindu?

I dont know . I think you are supporting cow slaughter ?

 

[liall]

I dont know . I think you are supporting cow slaughter ?

I am not supporting cow slaughter. I am just saying dont force your ideas on others.

 

[Biplab Bijay]

I am not supporting cow slaughter. I am just saying dont force your ideas on others.

I am not forcing anything. I am even requesting that please dont do cow slaughter since it is offending me. Also it is not mandatory in your religion.

 

[monitor]

PETA VOLUNTEER ATTACKED BY ISLAMIC MOB AFTER CALLING FOR VEGAN EID

4491
19
189

View attachment 106496
by JORDAN SCHACHTEL 24 Sep 2014 188POST A COMMENT

An employee of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) was attacked by an angry mob on Monday after the animal rights’ organization insisted that Muslims should observe a Vegan Eid, which is an Islamic holiday that Starts in October.
Eid al Adha (Festival of the sacrifice) is an Islamic holiday that involves sacrificing their most prized halal animal to symbolize the biblical story of Abraham (Ibrahim) willing to sacrifice his son. Some estimates state that more than 100 million animals are slaughtered during the two-day holiday.

PETA employee Benazir Suraiya and others approached the worshippers at India’s Taj-ul-Masajid mosque, one of the biggest in Asia, with signs in hand that read: “Make Eid Happy for All. Try Vegan.” Suraiya reportedly donned a green hijab to stress the commitment to a vegetarian lifestyle, the India Times reports.

Reports on the ground stated that the local Muslims were so infuriated that they immediately began threatening the woman and throwing rocks at her. After seeing the angry mob develop, Suraiya and other PETA supporters ran away from the mosque for fear of their lives and into a marketplace. Local police then quickly stepped in and took Suraiya away to safety

However, instead of going after the angry mob, Police have instead shockingly prosecuted the activists, who have been charged with “outraging religious feelings,” according to Police Inspector General Yogesh Choudhary.

PETA India CEO Poorva Joshipura said about the incident: "PETA organizes peaceful animal protection awareness programs for Christmas, Easter, Diwali, Janmashtami and other holidays, as well as Eid" and "it is shameful that in working to stop violence, our volunteers were made to suffer violence".

PETA Volunteer Attacked By Islamic Mob After Calling For Vegan Eid



PETA activists beaten up for calling on Muslims to observe vegetarian Eid
News18 | Tue Sep 23, 2014 | 08:51 IST#Bhopal #Madhya Pradesh Campaigning by PETA activists calling on Muslims to observe vegetarian Eid-ul-Adha (Bakra Eid) proved costly when they were badly beaten up by the local protesters in Bhopal on Monday.

The campaign was met with violent protest with the activists being roughed up. The volunteers were later rescued by the police.

According to report, Peta activist Benazir Suraiya led by other volunteers went to legendary Taj-ul-Masajid with placards which read “Make Eid Happy for All. Try Vegan".

Suraiya was wearing a hijab (veil) made of green leaves to highlight the importance of vegetarianism.

View attachment 106497
The local protesters challenged the volunteers to go back and shouted slogans against the Suraiya.

With only a few policemen for security, the crowd of protesters gheraoed the activists and forced them to flee, said a volunteers Divya.

City SP Sunil Patihar later reached the spot to take control of the situation. "The protesters were targeting the girls activists so they fled the scene, said a Bhopal based PETA volunteer Akash.

According to PETA sources, Suraiya works as media and celebrity projects specialist for the animal rights group.

Suraiya is based in Mumbai and the event was organised through a network of activists in Bhopal and Indore.

A local protester named Naved Khan expressed his outrage saying the group’s move has offended their religious sensitivities and it’s a direct attack on their religious belief.

So far no arrest has been reported. Police have taken away Suraiya to an undisclosed location.


..I support Benazir..the PETA activist from Assam, who campaigned for Vegetarian Eid..at Bhopal..
Brave girl and Brave initiative..only for Brave people....

I hope there are enough brave people.

right treatment how can we observe so called veg Eid when this Eid is about sacrificing animal .stupidity and hypocrisy need some limit .