India Muslims Abandon Cow Slaughter in `Eid

[Sugarcane]

Indian Muslims should start smashing coconuts to avoid troubles with saffron chaddis.

 

[Indrani]

No.
Let us not become Saudi Arabia.

But this point is moot since its not compulsory to sacrifice a cow on Eid.

There is no comparison. Outlawing inhuman practices is not the same as outlawing something just for being different.

 

[Utkarsh]

No.
Let us not become Saudi Arabia.

But this point is moot since its not compulsory to sacrifice a cow on Eid.

No, but let us by all means become BHARAT.

 

[Menace2Society]

..I support Benazir..the PETA activist from Assam, who campaigned for Vegetarian Eid..at Bhopal..
Brave girl and Brave initiative..only for Brave people....
I hope there are enough brave people.

Are goats ok to sacrifice? Thats what people usually do on Eid.

Vegan Eid? What are you, a Vegetarian Nazi?

 

[Indrani]

India Muslims should start smashing coconuts to avoid troubles with saffron chaddis.

At least in the name of God, we should not kill. That we have to kill for getting food itself is bad enough.

 

[Cherokee]

my religion says our society should have caste system. Would you allow that?

My religion also says cow eaters should be treated as less than human. We should allow that.

my religion says our society should have caste system. Would you allow that?

Then your religion should be outlawed in India and its supporters thrown in Arabian sea or bay of bengal depending upon the location .

 

[Sugarcane]

My religion also says cow eaters should be treated as less than human. We should allow that.

You are treating even your own fallows less than human since 1000s of years, what's new in this.

 

[Cherokee]

Are goats ok to sacrifice? Thats what people usually do on Eid.

Vegan Eid? What are you, a Vegetarian Nazi?

Muslims should be free to slaughter any animal in EID . Till we cannot do that we are not a true democracy .

 

[StormShadow]

India Muslims should start smashing coconuts to avoid troubles with saffron chaddis.

Better take care about your minorities, green pyjama.

 

[Narashima]

Then your religion should be outlawed in India and its supporters thrown in Arabian sea or bay of bengal depending upon the location .

yeahh it should but same should be done to other religions.

 

[Cherokee]

Hindu mythology is famous for its diverse art forms and classical literatures but the most famous myth is about beef or killing of cows. According to the myth propagated by Hindu nationalists, cows are worshipped in ancient India and it was the invaders, both muslim and christian, who brought beef-eating to India. But, facts and religious scriptures prove that it was the vedic-hindus who were among the world's first urban consumers of beef. This was even before Jesus Christ was crucified and 1000 years before Islam was formed.

1)Mahabharata, 500 B.C.: King Rantiveda slaughters 2,000 cows a day in his royal kitchens and distributed beef along with grain to apparently grateful Brahmins, the Hindu priests.

2)Charak Samhita, 100 B.C.: Flesh of cow is prescribed as a medicine for various diseases. It is also prescribed for making soup and advised as a cure for irregular fever, consumption, and emaciation. The fat of the cow is recommended for debility and rheumatism.

3)Taittiriya Brahman , 500 B.C.: Verily the cow is food.

4)Yajnavalkya, one of the most popular hindu sages: ''Some people do not eat cow meat. I do so, provided it's tender.''

5)Sacrificial offering for Indra, the rain God and Agni, the fire God, are bulls and cows. (Perhaps that is why we are having less rain, as we stopped sacrificing cows.)

6)Vedas have mentioned 250 animals out of which at least 50 are fit for sacrifice and human consumption.

7)Manusmriti did not prohibit the consumption of beef.

In many states of India, beef consumption is legally banned, because of a false religious myth. This cow worship is not done out of animal love, as the same 'God' that exists in cows also exists in cockroaches. By this logic, we should be worshiping insects too. The central focus of cow worship is to show muslims as anti-hindus and to create a universal symbol for upper-caste hindu identification. What is not a myth is that, the so-called holy cow is used for un-holy purposes.

Source:1)hindu.com/2001/08/14/stories/13140833.htm2)nytimes.com/2002/08/17/books/holy-cow-a-myth-an-indian-finds-the-kick-is-real.html

 

[Utkarsh]

Indian Muslims should start smashing coconuts to avoid troubles with saffron chaddis.

Can we really expect such civilized behaviour ?

 

[bitter_truth]

Yes we are ready.. Just buy cows load them into truck and bang! We will bust every activity like this..
If you can slaughter goat.. Then why cows?
To irritate us?
Thats not gonna happen atleast in my area.. We all aware and alert here.

 

[Cherokee]

yeahh it should but same should be done to other religions.

Yeah it should if they support casteism and treating of people who eat cows lesser than human .

 

[Indrani]

You are treating even your own fallows less than human since 1000s of years, what's new in this.

That is more true of Islam than Hinduism. Anyways, as per your argument we should continue doing that.