India is a Hindu nation, says RSS Chief Mohan Bhagwat

[INDIC]

Perhaps @INDIC wants to point out the intellectual dishonesty or ignorance on your part. Pls don't take offense.

But yes, we should focus on India, not Bangladesh.

Bangladeshi and Pakistani definition of secularism and secular certification is always baffling. I am still not able to figure out how can some country be a secular state with two nation theory and a state religion.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Bangladeshi and Pakistani definition of secularism and secular certification is always baffling. I am still not able to figure out how can some country be a secular state with two nation theory and a state religion.

Scholars and stalwarts have discussed this to their wit's end but failed to come up with an unanimous answer.

Perhaps we need to wait for our afterlife, or may the taste of hell as unbelievers to understand. <---Heard this so many times in my village. In front of schools these young lads would scare us children about the stories of hell fire.

No offense meant to anyone.

 

[INDIC]

Scholars and stalwarts have discussed this to their wit's end but failed to come up with an unanimous answer.

Perhaps we need to wait for our afterlife, or may the taste of hell as unbelievers to understand. <---Heard this so many times in my village. In front of schools these young lads would scare us children about the stories of hell fire.

I was too told by many amateur preachers how I am going to burn in hellfire for being a polytheist.

 

[jbond197]

I was too told by many amateur preachers how I am going to burn in hellfire for being a polytheist.

Funny these guys, while living a life of hell, gives others lessons of burning in hell fire in afterlife!! Mullah logic is really amusing I must say!!

 

[Bilal9]

You mean malcontent like you who is trying to gain self-respect by putting down Indians now?

Actually, you could not be more wrong about RSS. It is the largest volunteer organization in the world yet how many times does it make any news at all? It is only Digvijay Singh out of some OCD who kept pulling out RSS' name the last few years in his bid for Muslim appeasement why RSS made it to the front pages of any newspaper at all. Otherwise this organization with 50 million membership is hardly ever talked about. Most urban Indians have no clue about it even. So neither their behavior nor their attitude displays any signs of being malcontent or socially dispossessed.

Indranijee aap shant ho jaiye, I am not putting anyone down. Not looking for a troll-fest here, Just sane reasonable conversation.

I am only saying that personally I'm opposed to what I've heard are the primary principles of RSS which is discrimination along national and religious lines.

Turns out a lot of people agree with me - including the Govt. of many Western countries. Say you're an RSS member living in the US. Your citizenship could certainly be in question because the RSS is considered to be an organization that supports discrimination along religious lines. Same with Australia, the UK etc.

In any case we were talking about 'what defines Hindu culture' and not RSS...let's bring back the discussion on-topic.

I hope you will increase our understanding on what constitutes (a list of things in) Hindu culture. And where the minorities of India such as Muslims fare in such a culture.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Indian Muslims are fine with that statement they will seek a seperate state for their own self from Hidvata or what ever India

 

[NKVD]

Indian Muslims are fine with that statement they will seek a seperate state for their own self from Hidvata or what ever India

Seprate state is already provided to them if they they want they can go to there Seprate state like do it before in 1947

 

[SarthakGanguly]

where the minorities of India such as Muslims fare in such a culture.

Indian minorities in India follow the same culture as I and @Indrani or @scorpionx do.

Thanks for the concern though.

Don't paint all Muslims with the same wide brush now

He said - many. Not all.

Turns out a lot of people agree with me - including the Govt. of many Western countries. Say you're an RSS member living in the US. Your citizenship could certainly be in question because the RSS is considered to be an organization that supports discrimination along religious lines.

Ok. This is the US branch of RSS -
http://www.hssus.org/

 

[Bilal9]

I was too told by many amateur preachers how I am going to burn in hellfire for being a polytheist.

Don't paint all Muslims with the same wide brush now

 

[INDIC]

Indian Muslims are fine with that statement they will seek a seperate state for their own self from Hidvata or what ever India

If you want more Muslim countries in South Asia, use the same land judiciously which was given to you in 1947 and second Muslim country was created out of the same land in 1971 and if you want third use the same land.

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

No they are indian why would they use Pakistani land , they will demand Indian Land which they own and live on

Make Muslimanistan

They are indian Muslims , they will seek their own land based on their population etc and if they get ample positions in economy I hear they can't get rental properties

 

[SarthakGanguly]

No they are indian why would they use Pakistani land , they will demand Indian Land which they own and live on

Make Muslimanistan

 

[Bilal9]

I

Indian minorities in India follow the same culture as I and @Indrani or @scorpionx do.

Thanks for the concern though.

He said - many. Not all.

Interesting... but ektoo bhengey bolley bhalo hoina Dada?

What culture would that be? Tar boishishto-ta ektoo byakkha korben? Especially because I don't know you or @Indrani or @scorpionx...

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

We are already crowded and have no land resources sorry , India is big and has lot of forest and farms etc

Population 177 million , they can easily ask for a mini country lot of people

Secular identity of the state is what keeps such demographics integrated however partial announcements segregate sadly and it could happen

 

[possumlot]

I


Interesting... but ektoo bhengey bolley bhalo hoina Dada?

What culture would that be? Tar boishishto-ta ektoo byakkha korben? Especially because I don't know you or @Indrani or @scorpionx...

LOL....since you claim to have first hand knowledge of RSS recruitment process, why now stop at claiming you do not know the various cultures of the posters ?