India heaven for Muslims, their economic, religious rights secure'

[SIPRA]

Saravana Brahmin now online to troll.

@Areesh @agnostic Muslim

Don't respond to such trolls. Concentrate your energies on confronting Hindutvadi scoundrels and rascals.

 

[Sharma Ji]

There was a thread on this yesterday.

PDF Pakistanis came down hard on Naqvi because he's a Shia kafir lol

 

[Areesh]

Oh look ...it's the Pakistani who loves the Indian flags. Why do you call your boyfriend Areesh to help you. Is he the dominant male ?

Why did you chose to be a female sanghi?

Is it because of your filthy sanghi fantasies towards women?

PDF Pakistanis came down hard on Naqvi because he's a Shia kafir lol

Actually Pakistanis didn't

But since you are a hateful sanghi you believe Pakistanis to be same

 

[Sharma Ji]

Actually Pakistanis didn't

But since you are a hateful sanghi you believe Pakistanis to be same

Where is that thread ? There were plenty of sectarian comments about him being a Shia etc

 

[Areesh]

Where is that thread ? There were plenty of sectarian comments about him being a Shia etc

No there weren't

 

[xeuss]

There was a thread on this yesterday.

PDF Pakistanis came down hard on Naqvi because he's a Shia kafir lol

Is that all you took away from that thread? The only one who was using the kafir word was one of your ilk who was insisting on being called a kafir for some weird reason.

 

[Sharma Ji]

No there weren't

Where is the thread ?

and sure there were,, Shia (like it's a bad thing), "sarkari muslim" .. he got a lot of hate from Pakistanis.

Is that all you took away from that thread? The only one who was using the kafir word was one of your ilk who was insisting on being called a kafir for some weird reason.

I agree with Naqvi sahab.

Muslim thing is overblown in India, righ wing TV anchors haven't helped, but things on the ground are pretty normal.

 

[Areesh]

Where is the thread ?

and sure there were,, Shia (like it's a bad thing), "sarkari muslim" .. he got a lot of hate from Pakistanis.

He got hate for being a sarkari muslim not for being shia

Go find that thread

 

[xeuss]

I agree with Naqvi sahab.

Muslim thing is overblown in India, righ wing TV anchors haven't helped, but things on the ground are pretty normal.

That is your majoritarian privilege speaking. IIRC you are a upper caste Hindu living in a majority Hindu country. Convert to Islam and then see how the shoe fits.

 

[Sharma Ji]

That is your majoritarian privilege speaking. IIRC you are a upper caste Hindu living in a majority Hindu country. Convert to Islam and then see how the shoe fits.

Leftists talk like that about the US that way too.

Are you oppressed/harassed by white supremacists where you are ?

Last I heard they're not very nice to 'mooslimz' out there.

 

[xeuss]

Leftists talk like that about the US that way too.

Are you oppressed/harassed by white supremacists where you are ?

Last I heard they're not very nice to 'mooslimz' out there.

So the treatment of Muslims in India is dependent on how the US treats Muslims?

Next time some misfortune befalls you in India, like a robbery or a crime, I am sure you would love it when people respond with similar attitude, and ask you to stop complaining because some other people have it worse.

You obviously have no interest in understanding issues, contrary to all your pretenses.

 

[Sharma Ji]

So the treatment of Muslims in India is dependent on how the US treats Muslims?

Next time some misfortune befalls you in India, like a robbery or a crime, I am sure you would love it when people respond with similar attitude, and ask you to stop complaining because some other people have it worse.

You obviously have no interest in understanding issues, contrary to all your pretenses.

Unlike you, I actually happen to live here and do not need to base my assertions on news reports etc.

The point was that no society is perfect, and when it comes to muslims in particular, there's a lot of nasty stuff that goes on in the west/US etc too.

 

[xeuss]

Unlike you, I actually happen to live here and do not need to base my assertions on news reports etc.

The point was that no society is perfect, and when it comes to muslims in particular, there's a lot of nasty stuff that goes on in the west/US etc too.

So over the last few posts, your (supposed) defense has been:

1. Muslims are not discriminated, because "you" have not seen it happened
Response: that is your majoritarian privilege
2. US is pretty nasty towards Muslims
Response: treatment of Muslims in India is not dependent on US actions
3. You don't live here, so don't know anything
Response: You do not need to live in the city/state/country to deduce the situation. If I was presently living there, my opinion would likely be far more detrimental to your claims.
4. No society is perfect
Response: Sure, no society is perfect, that is why we are speaking about it, so that it can improve. We don't just shrug our shoulders and move on.

You next argument will be:
5. But what about ".............."
Response: When whataboutery enters the debate, the person that is using whataboutery is not denying the discrimination, but simply justifying it based on certain unrelated events.

By now I am sure by reading the above, you realize the fallacy of your arguments. I have nothing more to offer on this subject.

 

[El Sidd]

Higher

 

[Sharma Ji]

1. Muslims are not discriminated, because "you" have not seen it happened

I didn't say that.

2. US is pretty nasty towards Muslims

I read the news, I browse twitter..

3. You don't live here, so don't know anything

Things are not nearly as bad as you seem to think, it's true.

4. No society is perfect
Response: Sure, no society is perfect, that is why we are speaking about it, so that it can improve. We don't just shrug our shoulders and move on.

I don't discriminate, haven't lynched anyone either, and happen to be quite fond of mullah food so they get my monies too.

Things are fine for the most part, or as good or bad as they've always been.

Hey @xeuss

as a muslim man? (I'm guessing)

say you went full mullah, skullcap, big stacheless beard, ankle high pyjamas, the whole 9 yards basically.

where are you more likely to be viewed with suspicion, India or the US ?