India gets Afghan peace talks slot

[Secur]

When USSR entered into Afghanistan......... Why did Pakistan support US to take them out?

Aren't you guys equally responsible for the current situation of Afghanistan? I would say you guys are more responsible then any one else.

You were the people, who have used Afghanistan as a Ginni Pig.

Because Pakistan itself was under threat from the USSR ... Once they won the Afghanistan war , they would have attacked Pakistan so it was more than obvious to support the US to neutralize the very threat ... and more responsible even more than USSR and USA ?

 

[MilSpec]

Just google how Taliban came into being or Birth of the Taliban and you will understand what caused their ideology to flourish ...

For how long are you going to hide behind the cover that cia made the muhahideens and they became the taliban... the truth remain that these taliban were trained in your madrasas armed by your ISI and sent there... not only that your ISI and Military advisors were also embedded in their fighting formations to lead and provide military assistance. later your country was the first to recognise them as a legitimate government and also considered them as strategic depth... I just wonder how you guys are not ashamed of the evil that you brought upon the people of Afghanistan... what if similar rule was set upon your families .. how would have you guys felt....

 

[zhenkexiao]

Indians are dirty people. the mughals should have killed them all and done the world a favor.
nuke india and be done with this little 'problem'.

 

[POPS]

With deu respect to all senior members kindly explain why so much fuss about this matter

 

[53fd]

I feel for the Afghan people: they continue to be caught up in a proxy war again, their land being used for proxy wars. They unfortunately have no steel, they continue to think others can solve their problems, & then, when they suffer, they blame it on others than themselves.

 

[Developereo]

Cmon ..Mullah omar's taliban and justice... please enlighten me .. would you like your family to be raised in a similar society...taliban destroyed what was left of Afghanistan and you ISI supported it

It's an American documentary so it's not exactly pro-Taliban. Go to part 3 about 6 minutes when it talks about Mullah Omar's rise.

 

[Secur]

For how long are you going to hide behind the cover that cia made the muhahideens and they became the taliban... the truth remain that these taliban were trained in your madrasas armed by your ISI and sent there... not only that your ISI and Military advisors were also embedded in their fighting formations to lead and provide military assistance. later your country was the first to recognise them as a legitimate government and also considered them as strategic depth... I just wonder how you guys are not ashamed of the evil that you brought upon the people of Afghanistan... what if similar rule was set upon your families .. how would have you guys felt....

No need to play the victim here monsieur ... Long before the Soviets came , the Afghans were having a civil war in their country .... The Afghan Govt itself invited the Soviets to invade Afghanistan ... What Pakistani involvement do you see here ? and then afterwards when our existence was threatened , we teamed up with USA to neutralize it ... Do you see any wrong here ? and Yes , we supported Taliban ( they weren't created by us ... they flourished because of the injustice of the then Afghan Govt ) after Soviets left so that Indian led Northern Alliance couldn't take over the country ... No need to shift the blame if you lost that NA gamble ... The RAW tried to play the game but it failed ...

 

[POPS]

I feel for the Afghan people: they continue to be caught up in a proxy war again, their land being used for proxy wars. They unfortunately have no steel, they continue to think others can solve their problems, & then, when they suffer, they blame it on others than themselves.

You are 100% right sir kindly tell me how to thank a post im a little week in computre dept.

 

[Secur]

This is exactly what Pakistanis do in front of IMF,US,china,EU.Some habits dont go away

Tell you what ! There are better ways to increase post count instead of the usual childish tactics ...

 

[Developereo]

So you still support Taliban?? In that case....... God bless Pakistan.

We just want Afghanistan to stabilize so all Afghans can return to a stable country, including the Taliban. Even Americans believe there are some moderate Taliban that they can reason with.

 

[Contract Killer]

Because Pakistan itself was under threat from the USSR ... Once they won the Afghanistan war , they would have attacked Pakistan so it was more than obvious to support the US to neutralize the very threat ... and more responsible even more than USSR and USA ?

So you mean to say that to save your Country, you scr..wd others. And even after that, you are not letting it on its own.

---------- Post added at 05:11 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:08 PM ----------

We just want Afghanistan to stabilize so all Afghans can return to a stable country, including the Taliban. Even Americans believe there are some moderate Taliban that they can reason with.

Now this is the attitude and thinking one shd have. All Taliban Hard or moderate, shd come to the discussion table. and work together for a peace full Afghanistan.

 

[karan.1970]

Pakistan is being punished for winning the proxy war against American interests.

The main thing holding Pakistan back is the security situation. This will improve dramatically as soon as the Americans leave Afghanistan (if they ever do). The Afghan Taliban (assuming they are holed up in Pakistan) will go back to their homeland; presumably with some negotiated settlement. As for the TTP and BLA, they will be neutralized quite easily once their NATO-supplied sanctuary in Afghanistan disappears.

That's one of the probabilities, but the chances of that are so low, that any leader with vision would rather rethink Pakistan's strategy than banking on the existing one to come to fruit..

---------- Post added at 05:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:43 PM ----------

Because Pakistan itself was under threat from the USSR ... Once they won the Afghanistan war , they would have attacked Pakistan so it was more than obvious to support the US to neutralize the very threat ... and more responsible even more than USSR and USA ?

So you did it for yourself.. Now why do you expect the world to treat you as a martyr for their cause.. You saw a threat, and adopted a strategy to counter it. It worked in the short term but then the long term impact is also yours to bear.

You cant take a loan and not expect to pay the installments..

 

[Saifullah Sani]

Pakistan's backfired because of this:

India succeeded because of this

you need more practice kid

 

[Secur]

So you mean to say that to save your Country, you scr..wd others. And even after that, you are not letting it on its own.

Were the common Afghans happy with foreign presence on their soil then ? ... Who were the people resisting Soviet rule then ? Afghans right ? but yes with the help of US and Pakistan ( + several others ) , we helped them defeat USSR and in the meantime neutralized the threat too ... The Afghans screwed themselves up ... Just study the history of Afghanistan and you will come to know what exactly Afghans have done to their country !!! War after War ... Inviting foreign powers for the personal gain of the warlords ? All Pakistan's fault is it ?

 

[MilSpec]

No need to play the victim here monsieur ... Long before the Soviets came , the Afghans were having a civil war in their country .... The Afghan Govt itself invited the Soviets to invade Afghanistan ... What Pakistani involvement do you see here ? and then afterwards when our existence was threatened , we teamed up with USA to neutralize it ... Do you see any wrong here ? and Yes , we supported Taliban ( they weren't created by us ... they flourished because of the injustice of the then Afghan Govt ) after Soviets left so that Indian led Northern Alliance couldn't take over the country ... No need to shift the blame if you lost that NA gamble ... The RAW tried to play the game but it failed ...

But your then ISI chief claims that US just paid the money... it was the ISI who recruited trained and armed he taliban... i am pretty sure the taliban was not generating ak 47's rpg's mortars and ammo out of thin air and prayers right..

India supported Northern Alliance led by Ahmed Shah Massoud, please read about massoud and his governance of panjshir. btw ISI was directly responsible for his murder....


Just answer this ...
would you prefer a democratic progressive Afghanistan or TALIBAN RULE...








.