Featured “India cannot decisively defeat either Pakistan or China on the battlefield”

[Falcon26]

Moderators please clean up the thread. @waz

 

[Sinnerman108]

China and Pakistan are not two but one.

India needs to reconcile with that reality.

NO
What india needs to realize is that it is located in South Asia.
and by that virtue, it has to fix it's existence and it's ambitions.

India has to realize that USA is on another continent; NOT near south Asia.
No matter what India cannot rewrite history, nor will it be able to erase the 800 years.
It is best to reconcile, accept and move forward.

 

[kongn]

NO
What india needs to realize is that it is located in South Asia.
and by that virtue, it has to fix it's existence and it's ambitions.

India has to realize that USA is on another continent; NOT near south Asia.
No matter what India cannot rewrite history, nor will it be able to erase the 800 years.
It is best to reconcile, accept and move forward.

What pakistan needs to realize is it is located in south asia,of which india is the natural hegemon and by that virtue,it has to fix its existence and ambitions.
Pakistan has to realize china wont save it if it crosses the line regarding india.
No matter what pakistan can't rewrite the current reality of enmity with an united indian behemoth at its doorstep.Gone are the days of a fractured subcontinent of feudal clans vulnerable to steppe hordes from central asia.You face the worlds 3rd largest economy,2nd largest army and a nuclear power with a bankrupt state.It is best to reconcile,accept that kashmir will never be pakistan and move forward.

 

[doorstar]

@waz Can you ban him for another one month

what's the point? they have given him at leas 2 more spare IDs just in-case they have to ban him (to look unbiased)

BTW. have you visited Padmchen profile page yet? please do see what you think of his new undeletable avatar https://defence.pk/pdf/members/padamchen.180810/

 

[PakFactor]

what's the point? they have given him at leas 2 more spare IDs just in-case they have to ban him (to look unbiased)

BTW. have you visited Padmchen profile page yet? please do see what you think of his new undeletable avatar https://defence.pk/pdf/members/padamchen.180810/

I want to fry this particular India in the fryer,

 

[doorstar]

I want to fry this particular Indian in the fryer,

which one? ghalib or padamchen?

 

[Figaro]

But isn't converse also true, that China or (China + Pakistan alliance) can not decisively defeat India due presence of nuclear weapons?

A country that has to import virtually all its weaponry and has less than 10 days of ammunition looks like a country that will be decisively defeated in a war.

 

[doorstar]

A country that has to import virtually all its weaponry and has less than 10 days of ammunition looks like a country that will be decisively defeated in a war.

please visit https://defence.pk/pdf/members/padamchen.180810/

 

[Bossman]

india can defend it from pakistan and china . we are ready .

But not against the Covid. Where is your bluster about India being so well prepared against the virus. Remember our exchange of a few months ago.

 

[Bossman]

we have long history of conflicts even then hindus and muslims live amicably in india from thousands of years .
no doubt there happened cases of lynching by extreme hindutva criminals , but that does not mean all hindus are enemy of muslims .

Wrong, being dominated by Muslims is not living amicably.

 

[Bossman]

we have relatives in pakistan , sarfaraz ex pakistani captain's mother is from our uttar pradesh , his mamu lives in etawah ,i know him . when sarfaraz plays we support him .
similarly ex pak wicket keeper rashid latif's family lives in our city sultanpur uttar pradesh .we liked and supported him .

They now wish they had moved to Pakistan in 1947.

 

[Figaro]

please visit https://defence.pk/pdf/members/padamchen.180810/

His profile picture ... wow .

 

[Old School]

Agree. 1971 war in the Eastern theater was an 'special case' which will not and can not be replicated in any future battlefield. It had very much to do with our own military and political decision making process than that of the Indians. All military decision makers in the country are aware of this fact. Whether they acknowledge this fact in public or not, that is another question. Any opinion on 1971 that comes from any quarter other than that of our military and diplomatic Corps , is bound to be flawed in part , if not in entirety. Thank you.

 

[Falcon26]

Agree. 1971 war in the Eastern theater was an 'special case' which will not and can not be replicated in any future battlefield. It had very much to do with our own military and political decision making process than that of the Indians. All military decision makers in the country are aware of this fact. Whether they acknowledge this fact in public or not, that is another question. Any opinion on 1971 that comes from any quarter other than that of our military and diplomatic Corps , is bound to be flawed in part , if not in entirety. Thank you.

It had to do with geography. The same way the US couldn’t win in Vietnam. It was an anomaly which will never repeat.

 

[danger007]

We sliced and diced you in 1947 and we didn't need some Muktis to watch our back.
First learn to fight your own wars.

You didn't sliced.. we met in midway fought war... there are no troops deployed by India.. we intercepted Pakistan...