What's new

India and UK in talks to build Naval supercarrier under ‘Make in India’ initiative

Kailash Kumar

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 8, 2018
Messages
4,643
Reaction score
-1
Country
Suriname
Location
Netherlands
India, UK in talks to build Naval supercarrier under ‘Make in India’: Report

PTI

MAY 05, 2019

The United Kingdom is in talks with the Indian government on building a new state-of-the-art aircraft carrier along the lines of Britain’s HMS Queen Elizabeth as part of the ongoing ‘Make in India’ negotations, according to a media report.

The talks are under way for the Indian Navy to buy detailed plans for the 65,000-ton British warship to build a so-called “copycat supercarrier” to be named INS Vishal in 2022.

“An Indian delegation has already visited Rosyth dockyard in Scotland where HMS Queen Elizabeth was assembled and where a second supercarrier, HMS Prince of Wales, is now being built,” the Sunday Mirror reported.

“If a deal can be agreed, the new warship would be built in India but UK companies could supply many of the parts,” the media outlet claimed.

The report noted that such a new Naval carrier would serve alongside India’s 45,000-ton carrier INS Vikramaditya — bought from Russia in 2004 — and the currently under-construction 40,000-ton INS Vikrant, and could give India a larger carrier fleet than Britain.

“We have regular discussions with India on a range of equipment and capability issues. It would be inappropriate to comment further,” UK Defence Minister Stuart Andrew said, declining to comment on the reports.

The design for UK aircraft carriers is owned by the British and French aerospace giants BAE and Thales.

“Discussion have begun with India. The design can be modified to meet Indian Navy and local industry requirements,” a BAE spokesperson said.

The reported India-UK Naval deal would follow the sale of Britain’s Falklands War carrier HMS Hermes to India in 1987, which was renamed INS Viraat and decommissioned two years ago.

https://www.thehindu.com/news/natio...naval-supercarrier-report/article27039679.ece
 
. . .
Another grand scheme to loot tax payers money.

What are we going to do with a super carrier?

Save people from tsunamis in SE Asia? Our current strength is good enough.

China is anyway out of bounds. We can't even match Pakistan.

Why is this investment even considered? It is not that we will be able to maintain it either - considering our level of competence.
 
.
would it be a good idea to milk the indians build a carrier which will take a generation to build ruining our good name, or shall we pass and let the french come in and let them suffer?

both are good ideas @Vergennes what would you do?
 
.
India, UK in talks to build Naval supercarrier under ‘Make in India’: Report

PTI

MAY 05, 2019

The United Kingdom is in talks with the Indian government on building a new state-of-the-art aircraft carrier along the lines of Britain’s HMS Queen Elizabeth as part of the ongoing ‘Make in India’ negotations, according to a media report.

The talks are under way for the Indian Navy to buy detailed plans for the 65,000-ton British warship to build a so-called “copycat supercarrier” to be named INS Vishal in 2022.

“An Indian delegation has already visited Rosyth dockyard in Scotland where HMS Queen Elizabeth was assembled and where a second supercarrier, HMS Prince of Wales, is now being built,” the Sunday Mirror reported.

“If a deal can be agreed, the new warship would be built in India but UK companies could supply many of the parts,” the media outlet claimed.

The report noted that such a new Naval carrier would serve alongside India’s 45,000-ton carrier INS Vikramaditya — bought from Russia in 2004 — and the currently under-construction 40,000-ton INS Vikrant, and could give India a larger carrier fleet than Britain.

“We have regular discussions with India on a range of equipment and capability issues. It would be inappropriate to comment further,” UK Defence Minister Stuart Andrew said, declining to comment on the reports.

The design for UK aircraft carriers is owned by the British and French aerospace giants BAE and Thales.

“Discussion have begun with India. The design can be modified to meet Indian Navy and local industry requirements,” a BAE spokesperson said.

The reported India-UK Naval deal would follow the sale of Britain’s Falklands War carrier HMS Hermes to India in 1987, which was renamed INS Viraat and decommissioned two years ago.

https://www.thehindu.com/news/natio...naval-supercarrier-report/article27039679.ece
Pak shud go for Tyoe 55 DDG to counter it
 
.
Another grand scheme to loot tax payers money.

What are we going to do with a super carrier?

Save people from tsunamis in SE Asia? Our current strength is good enough.

China is anyway out of bounds. We can't even match Pakistan.

Why is this investment even considered? It is not that we will be able to maintain it either - considering our level of competence.
I feel your pain, mind coming up with suggestions?
 
.
Took the UK 5 years to build the HMS Queen Elizabeth. Apparently they will do it in 3 :rolleyes:....

Also the Queen Elizabeth didn't have catapults as they were too costly to install. What planes are they planning to fly?

Also what happened to their own designs?
 
. .
It seems like a purchase of Intellectual Property, to bolster own designs. Let’s see the cost benefit.
 
. .
Not invest in the military and more on social justice schemes and providing more internal security and education and business to minorities?
But less military spending will be antithetical to the idea of power projection and making the next guy pay more. Expenditure as a % of GDP has been stationary in real terms for some time now.

Would you rather wish to siphon off the meagre funds reserved for capital acquisition in defence sector towards say higher education, research and public health?
 
.
Buy off the shelf super power 2020
Its a first in the world, gratz
 
.
They should name the super carrier as "CHOWKIDAR" :lol:
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom