What's new

India 5th most powerful nation, says govt index

pari.mehta

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Mar 20, 2011
Messages
200
Reaction score
0
NEW DELHI: India is the fifth most powerful country in the world, says the latest national security index (NSI) designed by the country's foremost security and economic experts. A part of India's National Security Annual Review 2010, which will be officially released by foreign minister SM Krishna on April 19, the NSI 2010 placed India fifth in the hierarchy of top 50 nations identified on the basis of their GDP.

According to Foundation for National Security Research director Satish Kumar, who edited the national security review, the NSI is based on an assessment of defence capability, economic strength, effective population, technological capability and energy security of the top 50 countries. The US is at the top of the list on the basis of these criteria followed by China, Japan and Russia.

South Korea emerged as the sixth most powerful nation followed by Norway, Germany, France and UK.

While India ranked third in the case of population and fourth in terms of defence capabilities, it was at the 34th position in technology and 33rd in energy security. Only US, China and Russia are ranked higher than India in defence capability. In economic strength, India ranked seventh.

Out of the five criteria, maximum weightage was given to defence capabilities at 30%. Economic strength, technology and effective population had weightage of 20% each. Energy security had the remaining 10%. The national security annual review governing body, which comprises a host of experts, is headed by former foreign secretary M K Rasgotra.

On the likelihood of people raising eyebrows over India's extremely high rank, the NSI report said the strategic community in India will still take time to get used to India being such a powerful country. "Of course, the variable that helps India most is the size of its skilled working population. But that variable helps China to a great deal,'' it said.

China ranked first in the assessment of effective population which was calculated on the basis of three variables -- size of population between 15 and 64, size of population educated up to secondary level and above and human development index based on UNDP reports. The US is at the second position in effective population category.

Norway's high position was attributed to its number one position in the field of energy security. The NSI said some of the most powerful countries in the world were not necessarily energy self-reliant. The weight given to various indicators in arriving at the above conclusions was based on judgment. According to the annual security review, a group of experts went over the indicators and their opinions were collated to arrive at the relative weightage given to indicators.

India 5th most powerful nation, says govt index - The Times of India

Congrats China and India : D

P.S: DONT F*&K WITH THE Scandinavians !!! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_War
 
.
India can be fourth most-powerful nation by 2025: SM Krishna



NEW DELHI: India can emerge as the world's fourth most-powerful nation by 2025, External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna said on Tuesday while releasing a government-sponsored National Security Index study that currently places India one place lower.

"The revised National Security Index, an analytical tool developed to understand where we stand on various security parametres, points to India emerging as the fourth most powerful in the world by 2025," Krishna noted. "I recollect what MS Dhoni, the captain of India's cricket World Cup winning team, said a few days ago about his team's ODI ranking: 'If we keep playing well, the rankings will take care of themselves'," Krishna added.

The index rates India as the fifth most-powerful nation in the world, behind only the US, China, Japan and Russia.

The study, conducted by an eminent group of security and diplomacy experts led by former foreign secretary M.K. Rasgotra, rated India from among the world's top 50 countries with high gross domestic product (GDP).

The 50 nations were measured in terms of their defence capability, economic strength, effective population, technological prowess and energy security to arrive at the study's conclusions, Foundation for National Security Research (FNSR) director Satish Kumar, who was part of the analysis, told media here.

The results of the study are included in "India's National Security Annual Review 2010", brought out by FNSR as part of a series with support from National Security Council Secretariat and the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII).

The series was conceptualised in 2000 in the wake of India's 1998 nuclear tests and the Kargil war that followed in 1999 to provide in-depth assessment of national security threats and challenges and to enhance the level of national security consciousness, Satish Kumar, who edited the annual review, said.

The last such study was carried out in 2007 and India had held the same position then, as in 2010. South Korea is sixth, Norway seventh and Germany, France and Britain positioned at eighth, ninth and tenth positions, respectively, in the 2010 study.

South Korea performed very high on its defence capability index, while Norway scored ahead of these European powers in its energy security index, explained Satish Kumar, who is a retired professor of diplomacy at the Jawaharlal Nehru University.

While India ranked third in population and fourth in terms of defence capabilities by the strength of its sheer numbers, it stood 34th in technological prowess and 33rd in energy security. On economic factors, India was ranked seventh.

Only US, China and Russia are ranked higher than India in defence capability, while in effective population China and United States were ahead. In economic strength, US, Japan, China, Germany, United Kingdom and France score more than India.

Pakistan, which stood 37th overall in the national security index, stood seventh in defence capability, 34th in economic strength, 48th in effective population, 40th in technological prowess and 32nd in energy security.

Pakistan stood ahead of India under the energy security parameter.

Of the five criteria taken to assess the 50 nations, 30 percent weightage was given to defence capabilities, with economy, technology and population providing 20 percent weightage each and energy security taking away the remaining 10 percentage points.

According to the report, the strategic community in India "will take some more time to get used" to India being a high-ranking power.

"Of course, the variable that helps India most is the size of its skilled working population. But that variable helps China to a great deal," it said.

India can be fourth most-powerful nation by 2025: SM Krishna - The Economic Times
 
. . . . . .
Dnt worry sir your post already reached to its proper place

The Live post just got live when I clicked the thread.. Hmnn well All these are Mind games, there is no such thing called Power, it just a Perception of Few...
 
. .
you dont see the usa china uk france japan germany or even russia media bragging how powerful their nation is. if you are really powerful you dont need to brag
 
.
India said "India is the 5th most powerful nation" but it is India's personal opinion only !

Yup...its our own opinion..and we know of ourselves the best and better than anyone else.
Government must have surveyed thoroughly before saying something like this...because "India is the 5th most powerful nation" statement is a heavy one...and can't be said just by whims and choices.

OT:Congratz! :D
 
.
you dont see the usa china uk france japan germany or even russia media bragging how powerful their nation is. if you are really powerful you dont need to brag

US france,UK not bragging about their power?? They don't need to!! What they are doing in Iraq,Afghanistan and now Libya..is enough to show their bragging nature!!
 
.
you dont see the usa china uk france japan germany or even russia media bragging how powerful their nation is. if you are really powerful you dont need to brag

there are two ways to show supremacy

1. Meddling in others internal affairs forcefully
2.Documented dossier or otherwise called bragging...

No1 is what most of the countries stated by you do... Adopting the 2nd policy is in no way harmful for both the parties, the safest way to showcase what you are...
 
. .
you dont see the usa china uk france japan germany or even russia media bragging how powerful their nation is. if you are really powerful you dont need to brag

Who said they do not brag? US constantly name itself as the most powerful country.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom