Imran Khan Answers his Religious critics in this New interview.

[Zarvan]

@Norwegian please get your facts straight. Qadianis are declared non-muslims for a reason, they believe in their own prophet of 18th century, dont confuse and mix them with shias, a sect of islam. Ask a shia whether he believes in Mirza qadiani's faith , he would say no. That being said, Qadianis are pakistanis, just like christians, sikhs, hindus and other religous minorities.

Qadyanis are non Muslims and soon all Muslim countries will officially make this part off there law

 

[SekrutYakhni]

If IK is for justice, first thing he has gotta do is to remove anti-Qadiani bigotry from constitution of Pakistan. It was PPP and later Zia's Islamization policies that destroyed secular irreligious nature of our once prosperous state of the 60's. IK often quotes 60's as the best times of our history in his speeches. If so, then he has got to repeal those acts of constitution that are unjustified in constitution of Pakistan.

It is interesting to see whoever the pup was - I mean the one that started this Qadyani thang - He is successful fooling couple million people.

On the flip side, Imam E Kaba and his brother in crime - Have fooled billions.

There won't be any Prophet coming.

So Qadyani babes should really understand - If that was the case, we would have seen more Prophets coming after Qadyani babe. Guess what - No one came!

 

[Yogijaat]

Weren't those leaders who brought Islamization close aides of Jinnah like Liaquat Ali Khan and can also tell me how you going to create a secular Pakistan on the basis of Two nation theory.

bhai naya pakistan in making. Let them spread any story they want to.

 

[Dr. Strangelove]

i dont really understand the nonsense on these types of threads
holy quran clearly states the definition of a muslim
are qadianies fit the definition the answer is no so why should we call them muslims
shias are muslims by every known definition of islam do they believe there is one god allah yes they do
do they believe prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is last prohet of allah yes they do
so keep shias out of this i have a lot of shia friends and niether do i have any beaf with qadianies or any other religion
its an entirely different religion with its own books and it should be given this status
second amendment should stay
to save them from religious bigots these should be legislation in the parliment

 

[Fracker]

Lol Imran Khan gonna lead us, this Islamic Nation while he dont know how Eid prayers are performed, while dont know anything about Islam, we can see his behavior in dharna.. His interview on Islamic viewpoint will be a joke..

No Time to see the video of a Liar.

 

[Norwegian]

Qadianis are declared non-muslims for a reason, they believe in their own prophet of 18th century, dont confuse and mix them with shias, a sect of islam. Ask a shia whether he believes in Mirza qadiani's faith , he would say no. That being said, Qadianis are pakistanis, just like christians, sikhs, hindus and other religous minorities.

Qadianis are declared non-Muslim only in handful of Islamic countries. In rest of the world where governments do not meddle with people's religious affairs, they are declared Muslim as rest of Islamic sects. Qadianis in India are still considered Muslims where this faith was born. Its not secular state's JOB to declare who is Muslim and who is not. And then punish those who still defy this ban on calling themselves Muslims. LOL

 

[Zarvan]

Qadianis are declared non-Muslim only in handful of Islamic countries. In rest of the world where governments do not meddle with people's religious affairs, they are declared Muslim as rest of Islamic sects. Qadianis in India are still considered Muslims where this faith was born. Its not secular state's JOB to declare who is Muslim and who is not. And then punish those who still defy this ban on calling themselves Muslims. LOL

100 % Muslims consider Qadyanis kafir because they are even those who hadn't made it official consider them kafirs

 

[Norwegian]

Qadyanis are non Muslims and soon all Muslim countries will officially make this part off there law

Yes, they are non-Muslims to religious bigots like yourself. Ask any secular guy in the West or East, he would call Qadianis Muslims as their practices are Islamic, even when their beliefs differ from traditional Muslims. One cannot ban people from calling themselves Muslims just because they hold different kinds of beliefs, ideologies than traditional Muslims. If same bigoted "logic" was applied to Christianity and Judaism, it would form thousands of new religions in both of these Abrahamic religions when in fact they are just new modern sects who break from traditionalists.

holy quran clearly states the definition of a muslim

Really? All it says it that anyone saying Shahadah is a Muslim. Qadianis say Shahadah so they are Muslim, per Quran.

shias are muslims by every known definition of islam do they believe there is one god allah yes they do

Qadianis believe in Allah too.

do they believe prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is last prohet of allah yes they do

Qadianis too believe Muhammad (pbuh) as the last law bearing prophet. Still they are not Muslims? LOL

its an entirely different religion with its own books and it should be given this status

Don't Shias, Deobandis, Barelvis and other sects of Islam etc have their own books?

to save them from religious bigots these should be legislation in the parliment

Save them? Are you insane? Read this Ordinance XX from 1984 and then let me know if this legislation in parliament was meant to save Qadianis or attack them even more:
Ordinance XX - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Lol Imran Khan gonna lead us, this Islamic Nation while he dont know how Eid prayers are performed, while dont know anything about Islam, we can see his behavior in dharna.. His interview on Islamic viewpoint will be a joke..

You want Maulana Diesel to lead this Islamic nation instead? Then why not declare Pakistan a theocracy like Iran? Rule of the Mullahs. Then all Muslims are happy, right?

Weren't those leaders who brought Islamization close aides of Jinnah like Liaquat Ali Khan and can also tell me how you going to create a secular Pakistan on the basis of Two nation theory.

True. It was closest companions of Jinnah that turned Pakistan from liberal secular state to Islamic extremist.They didn't understand or deliberately did this in order to make Maulanas and Maulvis happy.

100 % Muslims consider Qadyanis kafir because they are even those who hadn't made it official consider them kafirs

Muslims may consider Qadiyanis non-Muslim, still they have no right to punish them for calling themselves Muslim or pray in their prayer houses which they call Mosques. Secular democracy does not allow discrimination of religion or discrimination of sects within a religion.

 

[Black Widow]

100 % Muslims consider Qadyanis kafir because they are even those who hadn't made it official consider them kafirs

Sorry India don't consider them Kaffir and if any Muslim/Hindu in India call them Kaffir , Law can punish them under religious intolerance.

Due to such strict law, Indian Sunnis don't utter a word against Shia and Ahmedi in India... Along with USA , India is safest place for Shia and Ahmedi..

 

[IceCold]

The intolerance in our society is way too much thanks to that Bigot Zia. We really need to tone it down. To hell with the fake Mullah Brigade who uses religion only to savour personal gains, the likes of Fazul Rehman, Mullah FM and others.

Pakistan would had been a much better place under different circumstances.

 

[Luffy 500]

Qadianis are non-muslims and there simply cannot be any argument abt that. Their theology is against the very basic tenet of islam and what it means to be a muslim. Plenty of lunatics claimed to be prophet and they were dealt accordingly as per shareeah. If India was under muslims rule when this lunatic british stooge Mirza qadiani came up with his claim , he just like all other false prophets would have been lynched to death and his followers obliterated and justly so.

They now should simply accept their status as non-muslims rather than being extreme islamophobic bigots. But i guess they find if more comforting to act as western and Indian pawns in the crusade against Islam and muslims.

 

[Biplab Bijay]

Qadyanis are non Muslims and soon all Muslim countries will officially make this part off there law

Disobeying your prophet will lead you to eternal hell.

 

[Black Widow]

Qadianis are non-muslims and there simply cannot be any argument abt that. Plenty of lunatics claimed to be prophet and they were dealt accordingly as per shareeah. If India was under muslims rule when this lunatic british stooge Mirza qadiani came up with his claim , he just like all other false prophets would have been lynched to death and his followers obliterated and justly so.

Is it? where? In Bangladesh?


Few days ago I was talking about same intolerance and Hate.. I was educating a Muslim by telling him the story of *****, how a temple was looted by invaders, idols were broken and converted to holy site of different Qaum..

What else can be expected? Almost all religion started with peace except "BEEP"..

 

[Biplab Bijay]

Qadianis are non-muslims and there simply cannot be any argument abt that. Their theology is against the very basic tenet of islam and what it means to be a muslim. Plenty of lunatics claimed to be prophet and they were dealt accordingly as per shareeah. If India was under muslims rule when this lunatic british stooge Mirza qadiani came up with his claim , he just like all other false prophets would have been lynched to death and his followers obliterated and justly so.

They now should simply accept their status as non-muslims rather than being extreme islamophobic bigots. But i guess they find if more comforting to act as western and Indian pawns in the crusade against Islam and muslims.

What a tolerant muslim you are. You should be the face value of all the muslims.

 

[ShahidT]

Yes, they are non-Muslims to religious bigots like yourself. Ask any secular guy in the West or East, he would call Qadianis Muslims as their practices are Islamic, even when their beliefs differ from traditional Muslims. One cannot ban people from calling themselves Muslims just because they hold different kinds of beliefs, ideologies than traditional Muslims. If same bigoted "logic" was applied to Christianity and Judaism, it would form thousands of new religions in both of these Abrahamic religions when in fact they are just new modern sects who break from traditionalists.


Really? All it says it that anyone saying Shahadah is a Muslim. Qadianis say Shahadah so they are Muslim, per Quran.


Qadianis believe in Allah too.


Qadianis too believe Muhammad (pbuh) as the last law bearing prophet. Still they are not Muslims? LOL


Don't Shias, Deobandis, Barelvis and other sects of Islam etc have their own books?


Save them? Are you insane? Read this Ordinance XX from 1984 and then let me know if this legislation in parliament was meant to save Qadianis or attack them even more:
Ordinance XX - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


You want Maulana Diesel to lead this Islamic nation instead? Then why not declare Pakistan a theocracy like Iran? Rule of the Mullahs. Then all Muslims are happy, right?


True. It was closest companions of Jinnah that turned Pakistan from liberal secular state to Islamic extremist.They didn't understand or deliberately did this in order to make Maulanas and Maulvis happy.


Muslims may consider Qadiyanis non-Muslim, still they have no right to punish them for calling themselves Muslim or pray in their prayer houses which they call Mosques. Secular democracy does not allow discrimination of religion or discrimination of sects within a religion.

you are repeating propaganda of lahori sect of qadianis who hide their belief saying mirza lanti was a reformer only not nabi. problem is it means they still hold him in high regards, so they endorse his views. if he viewed himself as prophet, and all muslims who refused to bow to him as kafir, then they really can't weasle their way out of disowning the core beliefs of that cult.

even christians as liberal or carefree as they are, consider Hazrat Isa a.s. as last prophet and son of God etc. it is basic tenet of their faith. now someone who worship satan openly then goes to christians calling himself a christian, would also be told to eff off i'm sure.

deobandi barelvi etc. do not have their own books. Holy Qur'an and authentic hadith/sunnah of Prophet are supreme. they may have different tafsir amongst scholars, but even then they subscribe to fiqh of Imam Abu Hanifah in subcontinent and are much closer in outlook than people think.

@Norwegian whats up with the tone, are you a non-muslim?
And why confusing shias with Qadianis?. Shias are muslims, qadianis are not. If you have problem with this and you believe that mirza ahmad qadiani is the last prophet, you can leave islam (you would be safe on being murtid as you live in west)

most shiia can be reasoned with and live in peace despite differences without subscribing to radical belief. i had personal experience with a particular fellow when discussing politics out of nowhere he started insulting Bibi Aisha r.a. one must be careful to separate non muslims who insult sahabah from normal respectful muslims whether sunni, shia.