Imran Khan Announces to give Pak Citizenship to Afghan Refugees

[Fawadqasim1]

Ik does not sympathize with extremists it's a
Noona and peepa propaganda.

 

[I.R.A]

Pakistan as a state has no social net, no Medicare no social security no free education

????? Pakistan has all these things, its only that these institutions are marred with corruption, but they do exist. Employee Old Age Benefit (EOBI) search on google. Government hospitals and dispensaries exist in almost all cities, government schools exist in almost cities and villages.

You cannot compare Pakistan's refugee crisis with any other country.

I mean literally you are on your own yet some think that people who are already living in Pakistan and contributing to it for decades will all of a sudden become a burden, I mean really?

I live in Islamabad and I daily see Afghan children mostly female children and women in the markets, torn clothes, no shoes, no slippers, dirty .......... begging ........ the only thing they know is begging. Young children 3 to 4 years .... what their parents taught them is begging and nothing else. And you will be mistaken if you think there is only type of Afghan refugees. There are clearly two types of them, one who migrated from cities like Kabul and they are well off, they have been and are living bungalows in Islamabad, have their own businesses .... but at the same time these are same people who hate Pakistan from the core of their heart. @Sarah Ahmadzai is a prime example of such people. Then there are piss poor Afghans, living in slums ..... in areas where crime is rampant, they have been found sheltering terrorists, and they don't care much about anyone (Pakistan or Afghanistan) except their own benefit.

We had our own internally displaced Pakistanis due to this war on terror.

 

[Fawadqasim1]

You often repeat yourself. There is no indic civilization, not in tribal sense. 1947 proved that. You people also don't realise that baloch get along more with brahui and sindhis then iranic speaker pashtuns.
It's not going to happen and Pakistan won't last with such divisive racial and ethnic tendencies ether.

We just need to take care of intruders from Afghanistan, huge mistake Zia made. If giving nationalities to afghanis born till certain year in Pakistan mean we can deport rest and control border, then it will not mean much. But if citizenship will become a joke and will be given to any and every afghani then Pakistan will not last.

It's not going to happen and Pakistan won't last with such divisive racial and ethnic tendencies ether.

 

[Kabira]

So a fix to my previous comments.

It seems that I was partially right, and the OP title was misleading.

The citizenship is being offered to PAKISTAN BORN Afghan refugees, not all Afghans refugees. Though I have certain issues, this is nowhere near as bad, and may end up being a good thing.

However, I maintain that despite his proclamation, Imran Khan does not actually have the authority to do so, without the support of both the Parliament and Judicial system.

He kept interior ministry for this purpose. My guess is interior minister can clear all those 400k blocked CNIC of afghanis who got them through illegal means. He will not need approval from parliament if I'm not wrong.

I'm waiting for more details but seem like if Sindh and Balochistan doesn't speak up then may as well give every afghani citizenship. RIP Pakistan

 

[Fawadqasim1]

He kept interior ministry for this purpose. My guess is interior minister can clear all those 400k blocked CNIC of afghanis who got them through illegal means. He will not need approval from parliament if I'm not wrong.

I'm waiting for more details but seem like if Sindh and Balochistan doesn't speak up then may as well give every afghani citizenship. RIP Pakistan

It's not going to happen and Pakistan won't last with such divisive racial and ethnic tendencies ether.

 

[Kabira]

It's not going to happen and Pakistan won't last with such divisive racial and ethnic tendencies ether.

Another case of victim card, speak about afghanis and you people bring in pathans. For f sake Pakistani PM is pashtun. Pashtun party is ruling Pakistan. But that doesn't mean bringing more afghanis to create unrest and civil war in Pakistan. What are you doing to do with Pakistani citizenship if Pakistan will not remain to begin with because of afghanis.

They have similar mindset to that of bengalis when it comes to Pakistan.

 

[Imran Khan]

میرا غصہ ابھی تک ٹھنڈا نہیں ہوا کس بی سی نے یہ مشورہ دیا ہے ؟

 

[padamchen]

You often repeat yourself. There is no indic civilization, not in tribal sense. 1947 proved that. You people also don't realise that baloch get along more with brahui and sindhis then iranic speaker pashtuns.

We just need to take care of intruders from Afghanistan, huge mistake Zia made. If giving nationalities to afghanis born till certain year in Pakistan mean we can deport rest and control border, then it will not mean much. But if citizenship will become a joke and will be given to any and every afghani then Pakistan will not last.

How will you separate the children from their parents?

It's something that is causing a HUGE uproar in the US currently. Most Americans also.are concerned about illegals. But when it came to the human angle of kids being ripped from dad's and mom's and grandparents the people just did not have the stomach.

Do you?

Baloch and Pashtun from what I hear intermarry more regularly than they do with other Pakistani ethnicities. Call me naive, but I see a raciocultural thing in that.

Over to you.

Sorry, one last question. How are you going to identify birth of an illegal Afghan. How are your birth records and registration mechanisms structured in Pakistan. Especially in rural and tribal areas.

More especially in the NW which used to be federally administered for the longest time?

Cheers, Doc

 

[Fawadqasim1]

Another case of victim card, speak about afghanis and you people bring in pathans. For f sake Pakistani PM is pashtun. Pashtun party is ruling Pakistan. But that doesn't mean bringing more afghanis to create unrest and civil war in Pakistan. What are you doing to do with Pakistani citizenship if Pakistan will not remain to begin with because of afghanis.

They have similar mindset to that of bengalis when it comes to Pakistan.

I am not speaking for Afghanis I don't care about them i absolutely think they are a menace. But I think people like you are a greater threat and menace for the unity of my country.

 

[Beast]

Imran Khan wanted more pasthun into Pakistan. That is his plan.

 

[Imran Khan]

Imran Khan wanted more pasthun into Pakistan. That is his plan.

then he should request our pashtoon that kam chuk ke rakho our pashtoons can generate our needs . our bengali kiyoo chayee ?

 

[Fawadqasim1]

Imran Khan wanted more pasthun into Pakistan. That is his plan.

Pushtoons are part and parcel of this country
They occupy two provinces of this country since the last 2000 years deal with it or there will be no Pakistan.and as far as Afghanis are concerned I am against their naturalisation.

 

[Lucky Breeze]

Sahab ki tashreef main great banny ka keera kuch zyada he bara ho gya hai.

 

[Fawadqasim1]

At least 40% of Afghanis are non pushtoons farsiwan as they are called

 

[Kabira]

How will you separate the children from their parents?

It's something that is causing a HUGE uproar in the US currently. Most Americans also.are concerned about illegals. But when it came to the human angle of kids being ripped from dad's and mom's and grandparents the people just did not have the stomach.

Who said anything about separating children from parents?

Baloch and Pashtun from what I hear intermarry more regularly than they do with other Pakistani ethnicities. Call me naive, but I see a raciocultural thing in that.

I was talking in political sense in case of Balochistan. You see current Balochistan CM is Sindhi speaker. Brahui and Baloch for all intent and purposes are one people. They are more closer to each other then to pashtuns even when it comes to marriages.

Sorry, one last question. How are you going to identify birth of an illegal Afghan. How are your birth records and registration mechanisms structured in Pakistan. Especially in rural and tribal areas.

More especially in the NW which used to be federally administered for the longest time?

Cheers, Doc

Again I don't know the details and I can bet goat that neither does Imran Khan. He just like to say what ever he want and think about that later on. As I said CM Sindh briefed him about Karachi increasing street crime after terrorism has been taken care off, and blamed on illegals living there. And obviously taking care of illegals is federal government job.

There may exist record of birth of those afghanis who have refugee cards.

I am not speaking for Afghanis I don't care about them i absolutely think they are a menace. But I think people like you are a greater threat and menace for the unity of my country.

I don't even matter dear. Just giving my opinion on what may happen if you nationalise anti-state population.