Immediate return of refugees impossible: Afghan envoy

[Vortex]

Guys, ok sending back them is good move, but if we send back them on short notice, remember there are women, children and elders among them. Is it the way we, as muslims, behave ? Agreed geoploitics are playing alot, but we can think better way to send them back...

 

[Menace2Society]

Guys, ok sending back them is good move, but if we send back them on short notice, remember there are women, children and elders among them. Is it the way we, as muslims, behave ? Agreed geoploitics are playing alot, but we can think better way to send them back...

They have been warned for years now.

How can you have a Afghan government which is anti Pakistani and then host their refugees? How does that work?

Why has US banned 7 countries? Because they are enemy.

If they stay then terrorism will continue. They have to leave, they are costing billions in lost revenue every year.

Who cares about their women and children when Pakistani women and children are dieing at the hands of afghan terrorism. Im sick of apologists who don't see what reality is.

 

[Rusty]

I used to view Afghans as a brotherly people and a brotherly country. I was very proud that Pakistan hosted our brothers and sisters from Afghanistan.

But then I met Afghans and heard what the Afghan government says about Pakistanis..... F-THEM!!!

They are so ungrateful for all the things Pakistan has done for them.
If it wasn't for us, they would be living in a communist hell hole where being Muslim would have been illegal.

Enough is enough, Demand that Afghanistan sign a treaty recognizing the border, seal the border, send the refugees back (humanly) and tell Afghanistan that if they want good relations with Pakistan, they need to act brotherly, like we have.

 

[Vortex]

They have been warned for years now.

How can you have a Afghan government which is anti Pakistani and then host their refugees? How does that work?

Why has US banned 7 countries? Because they are enemy.

If they stay then terrorism will continue. They have to leave, they are costing billions in lost revenue every year.

Who cares about their women and children when Pakistani women and children are dieing at the hands of afghan terrorism. Im sick of apologists who don't see what reality is.

I undestand your point of view and i had said same what you said. But the proper way to send back them would be to tell to Afghan governement, you have 12 months to build facilities for 3 millions of your refugees. After these 12 months, we will start to send your nationals back to your country, facilities build or not, they will be send back.

That's all. Refugees won't blame Pakistan for sending them back in 30 days, and instead will have all arguments to blame their own governement.

Do you got my point of view ? We have to take a decision, but how to manage this decision is more important because... you know politics.

And just to your point about apologists... who care of our children and women who are raped kille burnt and what ever inside Pakistan by pakistani themselves ? When you don't take care about your owns in your own country, don't expect other take care of you.

 

[Menace2Society]

I undestand your point of view and i had said same what you said. But the proper way to send back them would be to tell to Afghan governement, you have 12 months to build facilities for 3 millions of your refugees. After these 12 months, we will start to send your nationals back to your country, facilities build or not, they will be send back.

That's all. Refugees won't blame Pakistan for sending them back in 30 days, and instead will have all arguments to blame their own governement.

Do you got my point of view ? We have to take a decision, but how to manage this decision is more important because... you know politics.

And just to your point about apologists... who care of our children and women who are raped kille burnt and what ever inside Pakistan by pakistani themselves ? When you don't take care about your owns in your own country, don't expect other take care of you.

They have been told to do this for years but they keep delaying because they are using Pakistan for their own gain. Enough is enough now I am sick of niqab radicalist Afghan Islam invading Pakistani culture.

Domestic crime is one thing but terroism is totally another, don't confuse the two.

 

[El Sidd]

Nothing is Impossible for the great Aryan Republic of Afghanistan.

Take your people back or let them wander the Tora Bora.

Either you own them or leave them to fate. They are being returned like the gift they were presented to us.

#ThankYouAfghanRefugees
#Goodbye

 

[Vortex]

They have been told to do this for years but they keep delaying because they are using Pakistan for their own gain. Enough is enough now I am sick of niqab radicalist Afghan Islam invading Pakistani culture.

Domestic crime is one thing but terroism is totally another, don't confuse the two.

Crime is Crime.I don't buy that there are differences in crimes

Well if in the past we had given them deadline, then did we do what we said ? Now we should give a formal deadline to Afghan gov, UNO, NATO, ISAF, not necessarly 12 months, but definetely not 30 days, and do what we said...

 

[gutto786]

Pakistan should ask UN to provide money for food and shelter for afghan immig-rants.
Keep them isolated in a valley near afghanistan. Camp site or something. Throw food on them provided by UN from planes
Dont let them eat the jobs and business deserved by a pakistani

 

[Radio Mirchi]

US installed india supported Afghan government can not show any action or progress made in last 17 years in this regard. Since Afghanistan unwilling to do that Pakistan can sure do if it is really sincere.

Create a buffer zone inside Afghanistan, transfer refugees there and retract to Pakistani border and seal it with physical and security barrier.

But India installed and India supported Bangladesh government has done fantastic economic progress and provided stability in last 10 years. Lets see how many years BD will take to return the Rohingyas to Myanmar. Please give the same suggestion to your government to create a buffer zone in Myanmar and .....

 

[Sully3]

send these namak harams back home

 

[Maarkhoor]

PESHAWAR (Pajhwok): The immediate return of around two million Afghan refugees from different parts of Pakistan to their homeland is a near-impossibility, says an Afghan diplomat.

Afghan Consul General Prof. Moen Marastiyal stressed the need for evolving an effective mechanism for the voluntary repatriation of all Afghans to their country with honour and dignity.

Speaking to journalists in Peshawar on Wednesday, he said the Afghan government had taken measures for the resettlement of refugees. But the repatriation should take place in phases to avoid complications, he suggested.

Committed to providing residential, education and healthcare facilities to the returnees, the envoy argued, Kabul would find it hard to meet the needs of the repatriated Afghans.

Marastiyal noted the federal cabinet had asked the Ministry of States and Frontier Regions (Safron) during its last meeting to prepare modalities and strategy for the voluntary return of Afghan nationals.

Earlier, addressing a condolence reference in the memory of Pak-Afghan Peoples Forum founder Alamzeb Khan, the consul general said Kabul and Islamabad to make joint efforts to restore peace and boost the region’s economy,

Confronted with common challenges, the neighbours needed to strengthen cooperation on dealing with threats to their stability. Greater people-to-people contacts would help resolve issues between the two countries, he believed.

Peace in Pakistan and Afghanistan was in the best interest of the entire region, he said, urging the neighbours to develop cordial relations, including trade and economic links.

Members of civil society, political workers, lawyers, journalists and people from different walk of life attended the condolence reference at the Peshawar Press Club.

Marastiyal commended the efforts of Alamzeb Khan for bringing the people of Afghanistan and Pakistan closer to each other. “Our mission is common. We want to give a peaceful and prosperous future to coming generations.”

mud




https://www.pajhwok.com/en/2018/01/11/immediate-return-refugees-impossible-afghan-envoy

Afghan refugees return not possible but bad mouthing against the nation who are feeding whole Afghan nation for past 30 years is possible.....don't listen then just deport them imediatly...they need to learn a lesson...

 

[koolio]

How many times is Pakistan going to extend the deadline, just because the ungrateful Afghans cant handle the mass exodus of refugees, its not Pakistan's problem anymore, the Afghan government is constantly bad mouthing Pakistan and then doesn't want their own citizens back in Afghuniland bunch of two faced hypocrites.

 

[ziaulislam]

If you couldn't develop a mechanism in the past 30 years, rest assured you wont now irrespective of how many months Pakistan extend. And besides whats the point when Pakistan is always portrayed as the bad guys. So its high time we drop the ax. Whether the mechanism exists or not should not/is not our concern.

Exactly. Usa can easily pore billions if dillars to help them even india can chip in...

Afghans should ask them for help

I do think that we should wait till april till winter is over

 

[Imran Khan]

send back this guy also with afghan migrants

 

[YeBeWarned]

Afghans should read this, your politicians are not even ready to take your own people where in Pakistan they are seen as snakes and NAMAK Haram .. if afghans have any shame left they should leave Pakistan.