If it comes down to this, will Pak-Army kill its own people?

[474474]

Fucked up thing is that every single ummah dreaming Pakistani is worshipping morsi right now without even knowing the other side of the story.

Depend upon what kind of protest will it be. If protests are for separate country then pak army would open fire on 'rebels' even if they are unarmed, may even use tanks.

They have protests in sindh every month

 

[jbond197]

PA is already killing its own people. Look at Balochistan, KP.. People it is fighting against are Pakistani citizens so I don't know why this question was raised. Unless you think killing people in those 2 regions is OK but not in other parts of Pakistan.

 

[Panther 57]

"A is already killing its own people. Look at Balochistan, KP.. People it is fighting against are Pakistani citizens so I don't know why this question was raised. Unless you think killing people in those 2 regions is OK but not in other parts of Pakistan."


Only propaganda funded by you know who five. A mix of cultural and commercial interest.

 

[Developereo]

Pakistan and Pakistanis are mature enough NOT to turn into any spring this and spring that as some were suggesting arab spring like situation.

It's not maturity that's holding back a Pakistani revolution, it's cowardice and apathy.

The 1971 situation is relevant to the question. The PA generals are fully allied to the feudal vampires.

Rest assured that if the Pakistani public rebels against the feudals, as the Bengalis did, the PA generals will give the order to mow down the people and the army will obey.

 

[Bilal.]

So you are saying a planned armed insurgency hatched in agartala is comparable? No it's not. Protests against Ayub Khan and more recently Musharaf are comparable.

 

[Developereo]

So you are saying a planned armed insurgency hatched in agartala is comparable? No it's not. Protests against Ayub Khan and more recently Musharaf are comparable.

I am not talking about sporadic protests, but contesting the results of national elections.

The Bengalis were massacred, not because of Indian involvement, but because they dared to challenge the military-feudal alliance that has a choke-hold on Pakistan. PML-N is part of this unholy alliance, because it is a surrogate for the feudals.

Anyone or anything that poses a serious challenge to this cabal will be put down.

 

[revived rafidi]

Another fact is taking out a rebellion or militant group is not as same as taking out its own people. my point of question was with reference to a situation created in Egypt, that an elected government is overthrown by military and people of egypt are resisting the coup... God forbid if same happens in Pakistan, and people go out on streets to restore their elected representative (unlike 99 coup and others), will our army open fire like Sissi is doing?

As per Muhammad Abu Zahra (1898–1974) an Egyptian public intellectual, scholar of Islamic law, and author who also served as a member of al-Azhar's Academy of Islamic Research, Al-Sisi's current rule in Egypt fulfils the conditions of Ahl-sunnah Wal Jama rule of law and is the legitimate Muslim Ruler. The MB opposing the current rule are basically equivalent to khawarijs and the ones dying are dying a death of Jahil which basically means are dying as kafirs.
In line with the Islamic Sharia and Ahl-sunnah was Jama prospective. Muhammad Abu Zahra's stand is in line with Sheikh Ahmed Ibn Taymiah and Imam Ibn Hanbal's (and the majority of Ulema's) stand point.

Islamic Paksitan's situation is no different. No so called muslim has a rigth to take up arms and fight against the government of Paksitan and the Paksitan Army. Any muslim and specially Ahle-Sunnat and Jamat, be it ahl-hadees, brailve, deobandi, quranees, wahabi, salafi, if they adhere to the philosophy of the sheikhs of Islam as referenced above can claim to fight the pakistan army and the government in power (be it civilian or military). Take a lesson from Egypt, any one using 'Muslims' using arms, terrorism or violence (TTP and the terrorist in Blauchistan, Sindh and elsewhere) are to be checked by the Paksitan Army and these 'Muslims' will die 'Jahil's and 'kafirs'.

So save Pakistani assets, people and their properties. Do not take up arms unless you want to die as infidels. Each and every Pakistani be it muslim, christan, hindu or belonging to another religion, minority has equal right in Pakistan.

Current law and order situation in Pakistan is government's responsibility and any degradation of law and order situation does not justify arms struggle and is deemed unislamic. Peaceful protest without any form of violence by people (even down to blocking roads, tyre burnings on the roads let alone arms struggle) needs to be checked by the paksitan armay and the violent protestors/arms groups who die in the process confronting the Pakistan Army/authorities will die Jahils and kafirs as per Islamic Jurisprudence.

 

[Bilal.]

I am not talking about sporadic protests, but contesting the results of national elections.

The Bengalis were massacred, not because of Indian involvement, but because they dared to challenge the military-feudal alliance that has a choke-hold on Pakistan. PML-N is part of this unholy alliance, because it is a surrogate for the feudals.

Anyone or anything that poses a serious challenge to this cabal will be put down.

It was all already planned in Agartala conspiracy in mid 60s and has been accepted by Bangladeshi leadership lately... So no it's not what you said it is.

 

[Pakistani E]

what a stupid thread...Pakistan army has been killing fellow Pakistanis ever since its inception. It's controlled by over weight lazy tools who spend their time and energy on building rich exclusive zones for the wealthy. Nothing against regular soldiers and patriotic officers. The generals and the policy makers of pak army are mentally retarded I think, there is no other explanation of the many blunders they have committed.

 

[dilpakistani]

it came to that in Musharaf's era. And our army haven't done that.

 

[sjs84]

Yes, as Pak Army already supported terrorists like LEJ to hunt down BLA in Balochistan .

And then they supported Lashkar-i-Islam in KP to hunt down TTP..

Believe me, our army is not that innocent

...............................................

U r the most stupid person who think.....or with with extremists......

If u don't know kindly don't open the mouth..... as u belong to India.... Kindly don't interfere..... if u r Pakistani..... No issue People like u we will find easily who are against ARMY..... But We Nation are with them and will always be with them!!!

 

[Spring Onion]

PA is already killing its own people. Look at Balochistan, KP.. People it is fighting against are Pakistani citizens so I don't know why this question was raised. Unless you think killing people in those 2 regions is OK but not in other parts of Pakistan.

And Indian Army did not Kill Sikhs in Golden temple ??

And Indian army was NOT the one infact the first one to use airforce and air bombardment against own citizens in Mezoram.

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

And Indian army was NOT the one infact the first one to use airforce and air bombardment against own citizens in Mezoram.

And our Jet fighters are dropping roses and gulab jamans on tribal areas?

 

[Azeem Fahim]

Seriously army and innocentinnocent people cant defend thier country only brave and clever people can stop the enemy and thier plans.Even evil people can defend thier country

 

[Hobo1]

just a poll to get an idea.

if Egypt like situation comes to Pakistan, will Pakistan Army do the same?

p.s.

Its a public poll.

opinions are also welcome

Remember 71, when PA did far worse . They killed millions in Bangladesh , What is happening in Egypt is walk in Park compared to the genocide of Bangladeshis.