What's new

IDPs IN BANNU CLAIM THE MILITANTS WERE INITIALLY WELCOMED, BUT SOON BECAME FIGURES OF DREAD

W.11

BANNED
Joined
Jan 20, 2011
Messages
15,032
Reaction score
-32
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
NORTH WAZIRISTAN: BEFORE AND AFTER THE TALIBAN
0 COMMENT
clock.png
JUL 19 2014
author.png
BY NAZAR UL ISLAM



Internally displaced tribesmen queue up for food in Bannu. A. Majeed—AFP

TRIBESMEN WHO HAVE SOUGHT REFUGE IN BANNU CLAIM THE MILITANTS WERE INITIALLY WELCOMED, BUT SOON BECAME FIGURES OF DREAD.
It took Ambroz Khan two days of standing in a torturously slow-moving queue before he could register as an internally displaced person at Bannu. The 28-year-old, who works as a driver, had to abandon his home and most of his belongings when he and his family fled North Waziristan after Pakistan’s military launched Operation Zarb-e-Azb on June 15. But while he appreciates the need to exterminate terrorism from Pakistan, he says the Taliban helped introduce a better way of life to the residents of the tribal areas. He isn’t the only one.

One of over 900,000 tribesmen who have sought refuge in Bannu, Khan says he had fled to Afghanistan when the government announced Zarb-e-Azb. “I had to return because some members of my family had stayed behind in Waziristan,” he says, referring to the 29 family members he is currently sharing a small house with, including his brother’s entire family. “There isn’t much difference between the [refugee camp] in Afghanistan and the one in Bannu. But the weather was better,” he adds.

According to Khan, North Waziristan was transformed when the Taliban started to exert control in 2004. He claimed that the Taliban had “won the hearts and minds” of locals after killing members of Afghan Hakeem Khan’s gang, who were charging protection money from shopkeepers and transporters and were involved in several other criminal activities. However, he said, shortly after evicting Hakeem Khan, the Taliban started to engage in similar activities.

Mirwaiz Khan Wazir, a 60-year-old who is also seeking refuge in Bannu, agreed with Khan. “The Taliban completely changed our lives,” he said. “They eliminated the role of elders in our society and hampered the effectiveness of the political administration,” he said.

The father of 14 said he blamed the Taliban for destroying the peace of North Waziristan. “The Army and the U.S. drones followed the Taliban, destroying our peaceful region,” said Wazir, adding, “ [Before the Taliban] I had only seen chickens and cattle being slaughtered. They showed us the bodies of slaughtered humans.” He said that after the brutal massacres perpetrated by the Taliban, no one dared to interfere in their business.

However, Khan said that while the Taliban progressively became more oppressive, at one point they were considered vital to the local economy. “The Taliban paid well [so we embraced them],” he said. “They would often hire the services of the local community.” According to Khan, the Taliban seldom haggled and were “good customers.” He also appreciated the technological advances they introduced to North Waziristan. “They brought in electronic gadgets to the region, like laptops, and mobile and satellite phones,” he said. “Before they introduced us to mobile phones, we were completely reliant on landlines, which would often get damaged and be out of service for weeks at a time,” he said. “They would also frequently visit Afghanistan and return with exotic food that was alien to the local community,” he added.

Lajbar Khan, a 38-year-old who used to sell fruits and vegetables in Mir Ali, said the Taliban had revitalized his business. “Thanks to them, I could afford to bring in fruit from across the country, which they paid very well for,” he said. He said people in North Waziristan barely cared about fruit before the Taliban started demanding more variety. “They were good customers. My business expanded [thanks to their money], and I also started selling goats to them,” he said. “They were fond of eating mutton and were not interested in cows and buffaloes. I earned a lot of money from them,” he added, saying the Taliban would often order from him in bulk.

But while the local community appreciated the advances introduced by the Taliban, they were accompanied by greater fear over their sophisticated weaponry, said Khan. “A decade ago, we did not fear anyone [because we had our own weapons],” said Khan, “But the Taliban [and their affiliates] introduced weapons that scared us.” According to Khan, the Khorasan faction of the Taliban was the most feared. “People would hide as soon as they saw their vehicles with tinted windows,” he said. “I was always terrified of dealing with them, but had no other choice since they were responsible for my livelihood.”

Lajbar Khan agrees, saying the Taliban virtually ruled the entire tribal region and you had no choice but to obey them. “They were wrong,” he says. “Because of them, our lives eventually became hell. We had to worry about [U.S.] drone strikes, unannounced curfews, and checkpoints.”

According to both Lajbar and Khan, the biggest change was the cultural shift that the Taliban enforced. “Our wedding ceremonies used to be full of music, fun and dance, but the Taliban banned all this,” said Lajbar. “They said it was against Islam and sharia and forced us to adopt piety.” Khan admits that even drivers had to be careful about what kind of music they played. “We would play the latest Pashto music when driving to Bannu,” he said. “But when we would return home, we would only play jihadi anthems and religious hymns.”
 
.
================================

conclusion:

talibans were welcomed because

1) they filled the void of absence of law enforcement, there was no one to arrest criminal gangs and extortionists

2) they brought modern facilities to waziristan like mobile phines, laptops etc

3) the eliminated age old traditions like role of elders etc

4) they helped the economy of waziristan

so it means that because of federal inability to bring waziristan to the modern world and the lack of administration in FATA encouraged talibans to take over

the civil govt has to learn to improve their governance otherwise it will give rise to more lawlessness and outlaws
 
Last edited:
.
what an article. amazing read!

in short, its all about the economy. Talibans were welcomed because of how they opened the tribal economy to outside world while the govt had kept it tribal since the inception and plans to do the same as far as i can judge from its seriousness.

Another thing which is interesting to note is the tribals were very cultural despite being religious. Taliban slowly suffocated them by confusing them between culture and religion; ultimately taking life out of both.
 
.
No idea why they are giving credit to Taliban for mobiles, laptops etc In Pakistan laptops, mobiles started to become mainstream only after 2003. Its not like Taliban were distribuiting free mobiles and laptops.
 
.
No idea why they are giving credit to Taliban for mobiles, laptops etc In Pakistan laptops, mobiles started to become mainstream only after 2003. Its not like Taliban were distribuiting free mobiles and laptops.

excellent post

NORTH WAZIRISTAN: BEFORE AND AFTER THE TALIBAN
0 COMMENT
clock.png
JUL 19 2014
author.png
BY NAZAR UL ISLAM



Internally displaced tribesmen queue up for food in Bannu. A. Majeed—AFP

TRIBESMEN WHO HAVE SOUGHT REFUGE IN BANNU CLAIM THE MILITANTS WERE INITIALLY WELCOMED, BUT SOON BECAME FIGURES OF DREAD.
It took Ambroz Khan two days of standing in a torturously slow-moving queue before he could register as an internally displaced person at Bannu. The 28-year-old, who works as a driver, had to abandon his home and most of his belongings when he and his family fled North Waziristan after Pakistan’s military launched Operation Zarb-e-Azb on June 15. But while he appreciates the need to exterminate terrorism from Pakistan, he says the Taliban helped introduce a better way of life to the residents of the tribal areas. He isn’t the only one.

One of over 900,000 tribesmen who have sought refuge in Bannu, Khan says he had fled to Afghanistan when the government announced Zarb-e-Azb. “I had to return because some members of my family had stayed behind in Waziristan,” he says, referring to the 29 family members he is currently sharing a small house with, including his brother’s entire family. “There isn’t much difference between the [refugee camp] in Afghanistan and the one in Bannu. But the weather was better,” he adds.

According to Khan, North Waziristan was transformed when the Taliban started to exert control in 2004. He claimed that the Taliban had “won the hearts and minds” of locals after killing members of Afghan Hakeem Khan’s gang, who were charging protection money from shopkeepers and transporters and were involved in several other criminal activities. However, he said, shortly after evicting Hakeem Khan, the Taliban started to engage in similar activities.

Mirwaiz Khan Wazir, a 60-year-old who is also seeking refuge in Bannu, agreed with Khan. “The Taliban completely changed our lives,” he said. “They eliminated the role of elders in our society and hampered the effectiveness of the political administration,” he said.

The father of 14 said he blamed the Taliban for destroying the peace of North Waziristan. “The Army and the U.S. drones followed the Taliban, destroying our peaceful region,” said Wazir, adding, “ [Before the Taliban] I had only seen chickens and cattle being slaughtered. They showed us the bodies of slaughtered humans.” He said that after the brutal massacres perpetrated by the Taliban, no one dared to interfere in their business.

However, Khan said that while the Taliban progressively became more oppressive, at one point they were considered vital to the local economy. “The Taliban paid well [so we embraced them],” he said. “They would often hire the services of the local community.” According to Khan, the Taliban seldom haggled and were “good customers.” He also appreciated the technological advances they introduced to North Waziristan. “They brought in electronic gadgets to the region, like laptops, and mobile and satellite phones,” he said. “Before they introduced us to mobile phones, we were completely reliant on landlines, which would often get damaged and be out of service for weeks at a time,” he said. “They would also frequently visit Afghanistan and return with exotic food that was alien to the local community,” he added.

Lajbar Khan, a 38-year-old who used to sell fruits and vegetables in Mir Ali, said the Taliban had revitalized his business. “Thanks to them, I could afford to bring in fruit from across the country, which they paid very well for,” he said. He said people in North Waziristan barely cared about fruit before the Taliban started demanding more variety. “They were good customers. My business expanded [thanks to their money], and I also started selling goats to them,” he said. “They were fond of eating mutton and were not interested in cows and buffaloes. I earned a lot of money from them,” he added, saying the Taliban would often order from him in bulk.

But while the local community appreciated the advances introduced by the Taliban, they were accompanied by greater fear over their sophisticated weaponry, said Khan. “A decade ago, we did not fear anyone [because we had our own weapons],” said Khan, “But the Taliban [and their affiliates] introduced weapons that scared us.” According to Khan, the Khorasan faction of the Taliban was the most feared. “People would hide as soon as they saw their vehicles with tinted windows,” he said. “I was always terrified of dealing with them, but had no other choice since they were responsible for my livelihood.”

Lajbar Khan agrees, saying the Taliban virtually ruled the entire tribal region and you had no choice but to obey them. “They were wrong,” he says. “Because of them, our lives eventually became hell. We had to worry about [U.S.] drone strikes, unannounced curfews, and checkpoints.”

According to both Lajbar and Khan, the biggest change was the cultural shift that the Taliban enforced. “Our wedding ceremonies used to be full of music, fun and dance, but the Taliban banned all this,” said Lajbar. “They said it was against Islam and sharia and forced us to adopt piety.” Khan admits that even drivers had to be careful about what kind of music they played. “We would play the latest Pashto music when driving to Bannu,” he said. “But when we would return home, we would only play jihadi anthems and religious hymns.”

These tribals look no different than other typical Pakistanis in other parts of Pakistan.

They are connected to their brethren all over Pakistan.

Also, who was stopping the waziris from buying laptops and mobile phones from Dera Ismail Khan near by, or Peshawar or Karachi?

I believe this article is not the whole story.
 
Last edited:
.
These tribals look no different than other typical Pakistanis in other parts of Pakistan.

They are connected to their brethren all over Pakistan.

Also, who was stopping the waziris from buying laptops and mobile phones from Dera Ismail Khan near by, or Peshawar or Karachi?

I believe this article is not the whole story.

you talk about laptops, mobile phones, merey bhai they don't even have electricity, is laptop more widely available comodity or laptops, mobile phones?
 
.
you talk about laptops, mobile phones, merey bhai they don't even have electricity, is laptop more widely available comodity or laptops, mobile phones?

TTP didnt bring them electricity
 
. .
================================

conclusion:

talibans were welcomed because

1) they filled the void of absence of law enforcement, there was no one to arrest criminal gangs and extortionists

2) they brought modern facilities to waziristan like mobile phines, laptops etc

3) the eliminated age old traditions like role of elders etc

4) they helped the economy of waziristan

so it means that because of federal inability to bring waziristan to the modern world and the lack of administration in FATA encouraged talibans to take over

the civil govt has to learn to improve their governance otherwise it will give rise to more lawlessness and outlaws

1) Instead filling the void they became even worst version of previous crimnals.

2) BS, only after 2003 these gadgets started to become mainstream in Pak watan.

3) Agreed

4) they sure helped few local businessmen because of foreign funding which Taliban used to get.
 
. . .
Gen. Musharraf had it all under control, Army was doing a great job under his leadership but then the real problem started when PPP came to power, then we saw the real face of dajjal iftekhar, Memo gates, Raymond Davis, freely roaming CIA, Black water, armed drones, secret or shadow deals with US by PPP, most importantly Gen. Kayani the spineless General who allowed every bad thing to flow in Pakistan, where he had the chance to stop all the bad for good, he chose to be with the bad & so on.
 
.
I have been saying this all alone. Contrary to the belief that the military establishment handed over these areas to militants in conspiracy against the local Pakhtuns, it was the locals themselves who welcomed them as heroes. Even Swatis welcomed them as saviors and celebrated their suicide attacks back in 2007 until when a 19 year old terrorist could slap an old man with no fear of a crowd interfering. This was the local version of French reign of terror. And it is also true that Waziristanis hosted them as they had arab money and paid handsome sums to the local businessmen and landlords.

But I don't blame the locals alone, though not in the case of Swat. Waziristan was neglected throughout the history of Pakistan along with Balochistan. Swat on the other hand, though, was the second Murree with a strong agriculture and tourism economy, but the locals were too brainwashed by Deoband and Tablighi jamaat to make a better judgement. Swat had Islamabad esque big houses before Fazlu ruined their economy as a gift to them.
 
.
We should not be surprised with the IDPs stories. The terrorists were never indigenous people they came and took over Waziristan. They had fire power and money; the two powerful ingredients to take over a community. It is obvious that the local population were afraid of the new comers. Who not only enforced their own laws on the people but forced drastic changes on their local culture! The initial euphoria of money coming in was shattered when the tribal laws were set aside and the Taliban brutal justice in many cases injustice took over.

It must be difficult times for both the IDPs who had to leave behind their homes and possession and the Pakistani government who are trying to look after a million or so of them. Our hope is that the areas are cleared of terrorists and peace prevails so all displaced people can go back to their home soon.


Abdul Quddus
Digital Engagement Team, USCENTCOM
https://www.facebook.com/CENTCOMUrdu
 
.
It only takes one idiot to ruin it for everyone else. Sadly these people from Fata have stopped 10 years of economic progress by their negligence.

Any sane rational thinking person would understand, "hey you are a foreigner and you look mean, maybe I should report you to the army".

But no, instead the whole town joins and becomes an IED manufacturing plant with absolute no concern over the repercussions to the country. How do they react when they turned on the news to see dead Pakistanis and bombs exploding?

They should be thankful Pakistanis are generous people otherwise most armies would have mass murdered them all for justice. Everyone loves a hand out, nobody likes justice being served do they. Stupid f**kers.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom