What's new

I believe in reunification of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh: French writer Francois Gautier

Famous indeed, but not a political scientist that his words should carry weight and merit. That being set, although reunification is an almost impossible task, I do feel that closer economic and political relations should nudge the region into the right direction. In 2006, I could have envisioned a collective framework in a few years time but then momentum broke and shortly there after 26/11 happened and everything went downhill.
I cannot speak for what would be with Pakistan, but India, Bhutan, Bangladesh and Myanmar are very clearly heading towards an economic union.

The sheer speed of progress of relations between these countries has been mind boggling.

Imagine - Just a couple of years ago, Bangladesh and Myanmar were heading towards war rhetoric over sea boundaries, India and Bangladesh were trying to kill terrorists and accusing each other over bad border management and fighting over trade rights....had the worlds most complex border (with the only 3rd order enclaves in the world) and maritime boundary disputes between India-BD, India-Myanmar, BD-Myanmar.

Today,

not only have India and Bangladesh resolved their borders and GPS marked the border, amicably resolved all the enclaves issues along with the tricky citizenship issue.
They have resolved their maritime boundary dispute.

Meanwhile, Bangladeshs and Myanmar also resolved their maritime sea dispute.
India and Myanmar also resolved their maritime sea dispute.

Now, India has given Bangladesh access to Bhutan and Nepal for trade and vice versa, Bangladesh has given India access to its territory for going to North East. Electricity lines are being built from Bhutan to Bangladesh, and Bangladeshi port has been earmarked for use by Nepal and Bhutan...

and an Asian Highway is being built(with construction set to complete by 2018, some parts already open) which would link India, BD, Bhutan, Myanmar...and Thailand.

Motor vehicles Treaty has already been signed with which vehicles of any of our countries can freely enter each other directly and we already have free trade. Imagine the trade that is just going to start because of this - trucking directly between India, BD, Nepal, Bhutan, Myanmar, Thailand!

So basically you will be able to drive down from Delhi to...Thailand. Covering Bangladesh, Myanmar, Bhutan and Nepal.


We also now have Visa-On-Arrival for between these countries for each other.


These are the first concrete steps to an economic union forming between these countries with free trade.
 
Last edited:
it is soo funny that people who get all the information about islam from those news channels which always misrepresent islam and from distorted history and they end up with their own biased views about islam....

I cannot speak for what would be with Pakistan, but India, Bhutan, Bangladesh and Myanmar are very clearly heading towards an economic union.

The sheer speed of progress of relations between these countries has been mind boggling.

Imagine - Just a couple of years ago, Bangladesh and Myanmar were heading towards war rhetoric over sea boundaries, India and Bangladesh were trying to kill terrorists and accusing each other over bad border management and fighting over trade rights....had the worlds most complex border (with the only 3rd order enclaves in the world) and maritime boundary disputes between India-BD, India-Myanmar.

Today,

not only have India and Bangladesh resolved their borders and GPS marked the border, amicably resolved all the enclaves issues along with the tricky citizenship issue.
They have resolved their maritime boundary dispute.

Meanwhile, Bangladeshs and Myanmar also resolved their maritime sea dispute.
India and Myanmar also resolved their maritime sea dispute.

Now, India has given Bangladesh access to Bhutan and Nepal for trade and vice versa, Bangladesh has given India access to its territory for going to North East. Electricity lines are being built from Bhutan to Bangladesh, and Bangladeshi port has been earmarked for use by Nepal and Bhutan...

and an Asian Highway is being built(with construction set to complete by 2018, some parts already open) which would link India, BD, Bhutan, Myanmar...and Thailand.

Motor vehicles Treaty has already been signed with which vehicles of any of our countries can freely enter each other directly.

So basically you will be able to drive down from Delhi to...Thailand. Covering Bangladesh, Myanmar, Bhutan and Nepal.

These are the first concrete steps to an economic union forming between these countries.

it is good for those nations which u have mentioned but i think it is unnatural for Pakistan to unite with india
 
it is good for those nations which u have mentioned but i think it is unnatural for Pakistan to unite with india
I am talking about an free trade economic union between India, Bhutan, BD, Nepal, Myanmar, Thailand - the starting seeds of which are already visible.

Not about political union. None of us want a political union.

But we have moved from war rhetoric in our region(eastern region of South Asia/start of South East Asia) to free motor vehicle movement, visa-on-arrival for each other, free trade, open access across each other...all this within a 2-3 year period.

I think it is worthy of commendation between the Governments of all our States involved - particularly India, BD and Myanmar. The three countries sorted their issues super fast and practically gave each other all what we wanted from each other!

BD got massive land and sea tracts from India, India got territorial connectivity pass from BD, both BD and India got territorial connectivity pass from Myanmar and Myanmar got sea resolution market and investment from India and BD.
 
Last edited:
That's great and its your opinion which does not even come close to echoing the voice of the three of nations... Reunification will never happen. Both nations are too different. All three countries are democratic and the people of all three are content with the partition. You can keep your idealistic dreams to yourself.

However the future may witness great economic co operation and great relations when we solve our disputes ofcourse.
 
it is better to respect the differences and have nice relations rather than thinking of uniting and all those stuff which wont happen peacefully...
 
IndiaTve5b01f_francois-gautier.jpg


New Delhi: French writer, journalist and noted Indophile, Francois Gautier, believes in "reunification of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh". "Whether it will happen violently or naturally, I don't know", he adds.

Sixtysix-year-old Gautier, who has made India his home since 1971, seconded the views of BJP General Secretary Ram Madhav on reunification of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh by pointing out that even Sri Aurobindo and The Mother of Pondicherry Sri Aurobindo Ashram had wanted the same.

Gautier says, "Indians have become clones because they do not take pride in their rich ancient culture and traditions".

In an exclusive conversation with indiatvnews.com, Gautier opened up on his journey from France to India, on his image as a ‘defender of Hindus’, on Islam and the theory of clash of civilisations and India-Pakistan relations.

Read Also: 'Intolerance' was always practiced in India by left-wing circuit: Bibek Debroy, NITI Aayog member

Interestingly, Gautier holds Mark Tully of BBC responsible for creating a bias in Western media against India in general, and Kashmiri Pandits in particular. He blames Tully of deliberately using the word ‘gunmen’ and not ‘terrorists’ for those who perpetrated violence in Kashmir, which the Western media is still following.

Here goes the full text of the interview:

Journey from a Catholic Family in France to India

I had a normal upper class education in Paris, France. My family was catholic. I also went to a school in London for some time. But I was searching for something and I was unsatisfied with my education. It just happened that in 1969, my best friend’s father was Governor of Pondicherry.

There was a caravan of 5 cars driving from Paris to Pondicherry and I thought it would be a good way to experience life and know the world. From India, I planned to go to South East Asia, Japan, America and come back after a year. This is why I drove from Paris to Delhi.

When I came to Delhi, I stayed in Sri Aurobindo Ashram on Aurobindo Marg. There I had a very strong experience that India was my country and destiny had taken me to a place that was a ‘country of my heart’. So, I stayed in India and did not proceed further. I stayed in Pondicherry for 7 years.

The Mother of Pondicherry (Sri Aurobindo’s companion who was French by birth) was still alive then and I met her twice. It was a turning point in my life actually.

I also read Sri Aurobindo who was not only a Yogi but a great poet, a great philosopher and also a nationalist. Not many people remember today that Sri Aurobindo was an intense nationalist in the spirit of Srimad Bhagwad Gita. He wanted the British to leave India and contrary to Gandhi, he believed that it should be achieved by force, if necessary. Sri Aurobindo was imprisoned twice by the British who thought he was the most dangerous man in nationalist India. So, that part of Sri Aurobindo influenced me a lot.

He was also a great defender of Hindus. He thought that the word ‘Hindu’ was a misnomer and that it is actually the spirituality that stands behind and props up Hinduism, that ancient knowledge which is universal in nature.

When The Mother died in 1973, I did not know what to do as I was totally lost. Since I had done a little bit of local journalism in France before I came to India, I started freelancing. I did some photo feature in the South as I was based in Pondicherry. Slowly, I became the political correspondent for the then most important Swiss newspaper and subsequently for Le Figaro, the French political newspaper. That’s how I became a journalist.

Defender of Hindu culture

Of course, I’m known as a defender of Hindus. There are not many foreign journalists who defend Hindus, at least I don’t know anybody.

I defend Hindus not because of Hinduism but because I believe, as Sri Aurobindo said very clearly, that this ancient knowledge that some people call dharma, some people call Hinduism is very precious because it’s the only one left in the world where people can understand who they are, where they come from, what happens when you die, what happens when you are reborn, what is karma, what is dharma etc. This knowledge is lost in the world. It’s there only in India.

This knowledge is under attack from all sides, not only from Marxists, Islamic state and Christian conversions but also from westernisation.

Islam and Clash of civilisations

I remember even Murali Manohar Joshi, who I used to defend in those days, kept saying that there was nothing like clash of civilisations. But there is one between Islam and the civilised, democratic or free world of which India is a part. It’s very much there. People don’t want to see it. They keep blinking and say there is no clash of civilisations and it’s only a minority, but there is a war going on.

It’s true that it’s a minority that is violent in Islam. But the problem is not with the people of Islam. Muslims are as good as anybody else in the world. If you meet Muslims in India, so many of them are wonderful people, they offer wonderful hospitality, many of them are very refined.

The problem is not with the Muslim people but it is with their scriptures which were written 1500 years ago and never adapted to modern times. Even the Christians, somehow, have adapted to modern times. The Pope accepts that Buddhism is more politically correct than Christianity or Hinduism. More and more Christians are opening to the world. There is a need to adapt to 21st century but Islam has not.

When the scriptures of Islam, including the Holy Quran, were written, it was OK in those times because the mentality was different, humanity was different. It was OK in those times to behead people, to wage war against infidels but it’s totally inappropriate today. That battle is happening now. People don’t want to see it. They are crazy. The conflict is not with the armed terrorists only, it is also with those Muslims who believe that the Holy Quran is the ultimate truth and that Islam is the only true religion. That is the problem. Islam does not want to change.

I Believe In Reunification Of India, Pakistan And Bangladesh: French Writer Francois Gautier (Exclusive) Mobile Site

@SarthakGanguly @dadeechi @ranjeet @AHAM BRIHMASMI @jamahir
Reunification of India? India was never unified nor it was a single country; only two times has an INDIAN empire ever conquered major parts of Pakistan and only that being briefly. We are different people, with different ethnicity, different cultures, different behaviors and different religions.

And then this random guy brings in Islam, whatever has been going on the Middle East is because of politics and not religion. Before war on terrorism there were "200" estimated terrorists, now there is over 100,000.

Most of the world's countries have death penalties, but now have different ways to carry them out - I have no problem with replacing "beheading" with some other method of execution. Much of Shariah law was made hundreds of years after the death of the Prophet and it isnt as harsh or oppressive as people think it is; many of its so called "punishments" such as stoning women, killing adulterers and many other things have no place in Shariah or Quran but in the culture of those who practice it and practiced it along before Islam ever came.

Even killing apostates is misunderstood,

I just agree with the last statement that Islam has to adapt to the new reality. Even Hinduism has changed because of great reformers in the past. What was practiced in the past like child marriages, Sati etc are either banned or shunned from the modern world.
What practices does Islam have to change or adapt?
 
it'll never happen. the area is split along religious,cultural, and linguistic lines.

Wrong .
We Indians are diversified .But Hinduism is the common factor in between us ,something that make us one soul ,one nation from Kashmir to Kanyakumari.
On topic:With due respect ,we Indians dont want any burden .We have enough problems .
Those gen who had relation with Pakistan and BD is already gone .Now new generation born after 80's makes the overwhelming majority in this nation .For us those emotional bonding are nothing but some small part of history.
 
Wrong .
We Indians are diversified .But Hinduism is the common factor in between us ,something that make us one soul ,one nation from Kashmir to Kanyakumari.
On topic:With due respect ,we Indians dont want any burden .We have enough problems .
Those gen who had relation with Pakistan and BD is already gone .Now new generation born after 80's makes the overwhelming majority in this nation .For us those emotional bonding are nothing but some small part of history.
so basically Pakistan and Bangladesh would have to reject Islam and accept Hinduism for reunification :pop:

now it certainly will never happen.
 
so basically Pakistan and Bangladesh would have to reject Islam and accept Hinduism for reunification :pop:

now it certainly will never happen.

Do you have any comprehension problem?
Where did I mentioned about rejecting Islam?
Even if they reject Islam still we wont allow them .Indians are Indians ,the son of soils,religion is not a matter in here ..
 
it'll never happen. the area is split along religious,cultural, and linguistic lines.
religious mostly, not that much cultural and linguistic, for large parts of north India, that is.

historically, the partition was one of the great tragedies but too much blood has been split, of course it'll never happen.

good thing too, just look at all the chaos in the Islamic world, middle east and Pakistan in particular.
 
Both the ideologies "Akhand Bharat" & "Ghazw-e-Hind" say the same thing.. its just the difference of the leadership
 
There is no chance of Reunification but there is a brighter chance of some changes in india when muslims becomes majority in respect of hindus and the trend is already showing this
 
I've always admired the far sightedness of the French , English , US & other western ex colonial powers .One of the reasons they succeeded was to get others to fight their battles .

The Europeans , particularly the French , Brits Russians among others realize that their goose is cooked. On a slow simmering fire thanks to Daesh, the refugee crisis & the ever worsening relations between Shias & Sunnis .

Hence this attempt by them to inspire nostalgia among desis ( read Indians ) for re unification thereby dragging us to the level of the Pakistanis & Bangladeshis .

This is called real politik at its best .As an aside China seems to have learned the right lessons.Their actions seem to resemble the ex colonialist powers that so ravaged their nation during the 100 years of humiliation & all their actions vis a vis their immediate & extended neighbourhood pretty well reflects deep internalization of these lessons learnt.

I'm a believer .
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom