What's new

Hypothetical What-If: Pakistan withdraws majority of its forces from Indian border

Counter-Errorist

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Oct 29, 2009
Messages
1,368
Reaction score
11
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
What happens if Pakistan were to withdraw the majority of its forces from the Indian border?
Which of the following are likely to follow?
  • India seizes the opportunity and launches a full scale invasion to take over Kashmir
  • India seizes the opportunity and commands strike corps to cripple PA and try to take over Pakistan's nuclear assets
  • India reciprocates the move by drawing down its own forces
  • China ceases all military support for Pakistan
  • US ceases drone strikes inside Pakistan expecting a determined campaign by the PA as forces settle to the east
  • US reinforces in Afghanistan to counter the potential for Pakistani influence
  • US expedites withdrawal from Afghanistan to allow Pakistan to stabilize the country
  • Mutiny within the Pakistani military

A stated in the title, this is a hypothetical scenario. Please avoid stating why it may or may not happen.
 
Indian forces are far from border except in kashmir, so there is nothing to withdraw.
 
India reciprocates the move by drawing down its own forces
 
India won't do anything. It would be a unilateral effort yielding nothing in return for Pakistan, thus the exercise is futile in the first place. If anything, the LoC would firmed up even more by the Indians.

This has to be a mutual demilitarization effort, otherwise its a waste of time even discussing it.
 
India won't do anything. It would be a unilateral effort yielding nothing in return for Pakistan, thus the exercise is futile in the first place. If anything, the LoC would firmed up even more by the Indians.

This has to be a mutual demilitarization effort, otherwise its a waste of time even discussing it.

If India wont do anything even if you withdraw your forces, then whats the purpose of having your forces on border? Picnic?

Your post doesn't sum up well.

India will seize the opportunity and launch a full scale invasion to take over Kashmir!

But then will you not nuke us?

Make up the mind who is deterring the indian invasion - PA or nukes?
 
India won't do anything. It would be a unilateral effort yielding nothing in return for Pakistan, thus the exercise is futile in the first place. If anything, the LoC would firmed up even more by the Indians.

This has to be a mutual demilitarization effort, otherwise its a waste of time even discussing it.
India will not withdraw because India's peacetime positions are much further from border deep inside our territory except kashmir. India will not withdraw from kashmir whatever song and dance you do, so basically no effort on us, unless you take us onboard.
We dont want you to withdraw from west. :)
 
India won't do anything , though US might get tensed by this move and a surprised China calling Nawaz.

I guess that is bad for India as PA will get an excuse to send more of their Terrorist assets into the Indian side.
 
India won't do anything. It would be a unilateral effort yielding nothing in return for Pakistan, thus the exercise is futile in the first place. If anything, the LoC would firmed up even more by the Indians.

This has to be a mutual demilitarization effort, otherwise its a waste of time even discussing it.

What happens if Pakistan were to withdraw the majority of its forces from the Indian border?
Which of the following are likely to follow?
  • India seizes the opportunity and launches a full scale invasion to take over Kashmir
  • India seizes the opportunity and commands strike corps to cripple PA and try to take over Pakistan's nuclear assets
  • India reciprocates the move by drawing down its own forces
  • China ceases all military support for Pakistan
  • US ceases drone strikes inside Pakistan expecting a determined campaign by the PA as forces settle to the east
  • US reinforces in Afghanistan to counter the potential for Pakistani influence
  • US expedites withdrawal from Afghanistan to allow Pakistan to stabilize the country
  • Mutiny within the Pakistani military

A stated in the title, this is a hypothetical scenario. Please avoid stating why it may or may not happen.
There is no demilitarization to be done from Indian side. India has holding corps/pivot corps on border with Pakistan except in Kashmir where we have offensive elements.

The strike corps are based in Central India - the teeth of the Indian Army.

What benefit would it yield us?
The only thing India is concerned about is Pakistan launching jihadis into Kashmir and smuggling from the rest of the border. Its not exactly a secret that India/Army is not worried about a Pakistani invasion.

Stop the damn jihadi infrastructure and you can raise another 5 battalions on the Indo-Pak border for all that India cares about.
 
India won't do anything. It would be a unilateral effort yielding nothing in return for Pakistan, thus the exercise is futile in the first place. If anything, the LoC would firmed up even more by the Indians.

This has to be a mutual demilitarization effort, otherwise its a waste of time even discussing it.
Why would we do some thing in return??? because of your troops pulled back??? We do nothing, it is the favor from our side...
 
India will seize the opportunity and launch a full scale invasion to take over Kashmir!

That is bull
We have a large conventional advantage over you which will only increase
Your nukes are the main thing which is stopping us
 
Modi is a terrorist, anything from a terrorist can be expected. so we should be ready for a befitting response !!
 
Well the nuclear deterrence will also grow proportional to the conventional disparity, thus the earlier point. Both sides should maintain status-quo on the border.
 
What happens if Pakistan were to withdraw the majority of its forces from the Indian border?
Which of the following are likely to follow?
  • India seizes the opportunity and launches a full scale invasion to take over Kashmir
  • India seizes the opportunity and commands strike corps to cripple PA and try to take over Pakistan's nuclear assets
  • India reciprocates the move by drawing down its own forces
  • China ceases all military support for Pakistan
  • US ceases drone strikes inside Pakistan expecting a determined campaign by the PA as forces settle to the east
  • US reinforces in Afghanistan to counter the potential for Pakistani influence
  • US expedites withdrawal from Afghanistan to allow Pakistan to stabilize the country
  • Mutiny within the Pakistani military

A stated in the title, this is a hypothetical scenario. Please avoid stating why it may or may not happen.
india will occupy azad kashmir, sindhu desh will come into being except for Karachi which wil become an independent port city state with teh fat toad in vilayet as nabob/king and baluchistan will be handed over the biggest medieval barbarian sardar they can find....and punjab will continue to be under ganja baradaran except they will now be called gopalaswamy schroffs [as in jackie schroff]....
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom