Hypothetical War Scenario: Who Would Prevail, Iran or Israel?

[WinterNights]

You guys are over-estimating your home made SAM's .. but good luck

How exactly? Maybe you should try and substantiate your claims.

 

[YeBeWarned]

How exactly? Maybe you should try and substantiate your claims.

its not a claim bro, its an assessment .. SAM's are good but there are numerous way to evade RADAR coverage and Jamming . if you need to give Israel Air force a bloody nose you does need 3 tier SAM coverage along with good Modern 4/4.5/4++ Generation fighters .

 

[Śakra]

Israel has no hope to "pound" Iran using their airforce. People are so clueless they just focus on Iran airforce alone. Iranian airdefences can take care of Israeli planes with ease. Saying "Iran's anti air defences could also probably down a few Israeli aircraft" shows how clueless you are.

Have you seen this war simulation done by KSA? Their Armed forces have shown they can take your country single-handedly. Just imagine a 2 front war with KSA and Israel together (likely) against you.

 

[zectech]

You guys are over-estimating your home made SAM's .. but good luck

If bavar 373s and Talaash Air Defense System are truly as good as S-300s, then they are more than adequate for the next 5 years.

 

[WinterNights]

its not a claim bro, its an assessment .. SAM's are good but there are numerous way to evade RADAR coverage and Jamming . if you need to give Israel Air force a bloody nose you does need 3 tier SAM coverage along with good Modern 4/4.5/4++ Generation fighters .

A clear false assessment though. I do agree Iran should bolster it's airforce but the point is, Iran air defence is more than enough to deal with the israeli airforce.

Iran has a very robust 3 tier, integrated air defence systems with many radar dedicated for stealth detection etc. This air-defence was made to counter an American strike, nevermind the israelis...

The israeli airforce is one of the most overhyped and overated things in the history of military. Just go watch their own documentaries regarding their strikes against Iraq for example to see just how much of their success actually relied on the incompetence of the Iraqi AD.

Iran's airdefence would make mincemeat out of them. Don't even doubt it. They're airfrce is just too small (and they're too far away)

You may not know much about Iranian airdefence, that's fair enough. So let me tell you this, Iran's airdefece is as potent as it's missiles forces. What Iran's missile forces is to offence, it's AD is to defence!

Have you seen this war simulation done by KSA? Their Armed forces have shown they can take your country single-handedly. Just imagine a 2 front war with KSA and Israel together (likely) against you.

How old you? seriously? 12?

 

[zectech]

its not a claim bro, its an assessment .. SAM's are good but there are numerous way to evade RADAR coverage and Jamming . if you need to give Israel Air force a bloody nose you does need 3 tier SAM coverage along with good Modern 4/4.5/4++ Generation fighters .

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/02/israel-shot-iranian-drone-syria-180210053946323.html

Also, Putin is not selling SU-35s to Iran. All Iran needs is a dozen of them to maintain air superiority.

 

[Oldman1]

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2018/02/israel-shot-iranian-drone-syria-180210053946323.html

Also, Putin is not selling SU-35s to Iran. All Iran needs is a dozen of them to maintain air superiority.

Even a dozen is not enough.

 

[zectech]

Even a dozen is not enough.

Indonesia ordered about a dozen in exchange for goods. Indonesia is triple the population and stretches across multiple Irans in area.

2 SU-35s flanked by 4 F-14s with an additional 3 Mig-29s, as a unit to provide superiority in the air. Have 6 squadrons like that with supporting F-4s and F-5s.

You don't put them all in one air squadron and watch cruise missile blow up 1 billion in aircraft.

 

[T-72B]

Have you seen this war simulation done by KSA? Their Armed forces have shown they can take your country single-handedly. Just imagine a 2 front war with KSA and Israel together (likely) against you.

That's Mr @Śakra is a propaganda

Indonesia ordered about a dozen in exchange for goods. Indonesia is triple the population and stretches across multiple Irans in area.

2 SU-35s flanked by 4 F-14s with an additional 3 Mig-29s, as a unit to provide superiority in the air. Have 6 squadrons like that with supporting F-4s and F-5s.

You don't put them all in one air squadron and watch cruise missile blow up 1 billion in aircraft.

Are you kidding me 6 squadrons of Su-35? Hell even Russia only have 71 of those
I think 24 Su-35 would be enough, it would be deterrent for Israelis F-35 and US F-22
What about retiring all of F-5s and F-4s and replace with Su-30s about 72 Su-30s would be enough for Iran and also lincesed production for Su-30

 

[Hamza913]

Israel has no hope to "pound" Iran using their airforce. People focus too much on Iran airforce alone. Iranian airdefences can take care of Israeli planes with ease. Saying "Iran's anti air defences could also probably down a few Israeli aircraft" shows you don't know much about Iran's airdefence bro. Go see my comments to Starlord in this thread.

They have some of the best pilots in the world and fly some of the best aircraft in the world. You will be able to take out a few but you will still be hit pretty hard.

 

[WinterNights]

They have some of the best pilots in the world and fly some of the best aircraft in the world. You will be able to take out a few but you will still be hit pretty hard.

What type of reply is that? You basically just repeated the same thing. There's no evidence their pilots are anything special. Just because their enemies were incompetent, it does not make their pilots super. They also claimed their army was great because they defeated the arabs in the 60's, but we saw what Hezbollah did to them in 06.

Furthermore, they have barely any F-35's and the rest of their planes are nothing but easy targets for Iranian AD.
You have to be pretty clueless to think Iran's massive integrated AD would take out "a few". Like I said previously, Iran's AD would make mincemeat of them. Iran's air defence is vastly more advanced, larger and more competent than anything these israelis ever came across. At least do some basic research before commenting.

 

[T-72B]

What type of reply is that? You basically just repeated the same thing. There's no evidence their pilots are anything special. Just because their enemies were incompetent, it does not make their pilots super. They also claimedsepaka their army was great because they defeated the arabs in the 60's, but we saw what Hezbollah did to them in 06.

Furthermore, they have barely any F-35's and the rest of their planes are nothing but easy targets for Iranian AD.
You have to be pretty clueless to think Iran's massive integrated AD would take out "a few". Like I said previously, Iran's AD would make mincemeat of them. Iran's air defence is vastly more advanced, larger and more competent than anything these israelis ever came across. At least do some basic research before commenting.

Speaking of Iran air defence, how many Sayyad 2 and 3 (talaash system) that Iran has? Do Iran already retired their S-200 and S-75?

 

[Hamza913]

Iran's AD would make mincemeat of them.

I highly doubt that.

 

[WinterNights]

I highly doubt that.

Doubt it all you want.

Speaking of Iran air defence, how many Sayyad 2 and 3 (talaash system) that Iran has? Do Iran already retired their S-200 and S-75?

Even if I knew, I would never reveal that information. As for s-200 and S-75, I don't think the S-75 is being used anymore. Iran has heavily upgraded it's s-200 to a point it's a completely new systems, it has some still in use but they will be replaced soon.

 

[Aramagedon]

Some images for dumbs....