How should Bangladesh Muslims deal with atheists who do not attack Islam?

[kalu_miah]

Not sure if this is a banned topic or not, similar threads were closed before:
http://www.defence.pk/forums/world-affairs/221391-atheists-islam.html

But this thread is regarding the current political situation in Bangladesh, where this issue of atheism was thrust to political forefront, because of atheist bloggers involvement with the Shahbag "movement".

In Bangladesh we see mainly two kinds of atheists:

1. Those who attack Islam openly such as atheist bloggers, who have been indoctrinated by materials from Islamophobia Industry associated websites and memes

2. Those who deal with atheism as a personal matter and choice and do not attack Islam using anti-Islam ideas and memes, examples are people like Farhad Mazhar, who admits his atheism, but supports religious people and religiosity and do outstanding social work for the country, as a responsible citizen

One Awami League supporter here was trying to use Farhad Mazhar's example and imply that all atheists are same and should be treated the same. Do Bangladeshi Muslims believe this is true and if not, why?

 

[marty]

Atheist should be jailed, they try to insult islam and the prophet (pbuh)

 

[Azazel]

Not sure if this is a banned topic or not, similar threads were closed before:
http://www.defence.pk/forums/world-affairs/221391-atheists-islam.html

But this thread is regarding the current political situation in Bangladesh, where this issue of atheism was thrust to political forefront, because of atheist bloggers involvement with the Shahbag "movement".

In Bangladesh we see mainly two kinds of atheists:

1. Those who attack Islam openly such as atheist bloggers, who have been indoctrinated by materials from Islamophobia Industry associated websites and memes

2. Those who deal with atheism as a personal matter and choice and do not attack Islam using anti-Islam ideas and memes, examples are people like Farhad Mazhar, who admits his atheism, but supports religious people and religiosity and do outstanding social work for the country, as a responsible citizen

One Awami League supporter here was trying to use Farhad Mazhar's example and imply that all atheists are same and should be treated the same. Do Bangladeshi Muslims believe this is true and if not, why?

What is your problem??Being an Athiest is not a crime.You sound like those Nazis who once asked how should we deal with the Jews??

 

[AUSTERLITZ]

Lol,some of the great men of human history were all atheists.Atheism fuels self sufficiency and independent thought,as long as they don't bother u why u bothering them.If a god has to persecute people to convince them, then he's no god at all.

 

[jaunty]

The punishment of apostasy is death. Murtids are wajib-ul-qatal.

 

[kalu_miah]

The OP question is addressed to Bangladeshi Muslims only. But Muslims from elsewhere are welcome to comment as well.

 

[jaunty]

The OP question is addressed to Bangladeshi Muslims only.

Do whatever your holy book decrees. Shouldn't that be as simple as that?

 

[marty]

What is your problem??Being an Athiest is not a crime.You sound like those Nazis who once asked how should we deal with the Jews??

if atheist insult islam they deserve to be punish severely.

 

[--,-'{@]

The OP question is addressed to Bangladeshi Muslims only.

pdf has not more than 10 bdians here so its inappropriate to ask questions pertaining his mis beliefs? go somewhere else to preach this is a pakistani site (best thing from pakistan yet, n nufin has been so entertaining than pdf n zaid zandu hamid.

 

[Azazel]

if atheist insult islam they deserve to be punish severely.

LOL,All major Religions deserved to be insulted for the countless crimes they have committed on the mankind through out the history.No religion or any form of political ideology is not outside the realm of criticism.If they think otherwise they are fascists.

 

[ares]

if atheist insult islam they deserve to be punish severely.

And if Islamist insult Atheism, what punishment should they get?

 

[LaBong]

The OP question is addressed to Bangladeshi Muslims only.

Then ask the question in your Bangladesh2070 forum. You are hurting my atheist sentiment by alluding that atheists are some kinda criminal who needs to be dealt with. You are wajb ul katl according to my lack of religion.

 

[marty]

And if Islamist insult Atheism, what punishment should they get?

you realise bangladesh is muslim country so it should be governed with muslim laws

 

[Rizwan Alam]

Islam itself protects Non Muslims. I guess from atheist you do not mean apostate, because for apostate there are different rulings from different scholars. Whosoever is insulting Islam should be punished BUT spare the questioners whether they are satisfied or not with the answers given to them.

 

[Azazel]

you realise bangladesh is muslim country so it should be governed with muslim laws

And who are you to decide that.Are you a Bangladeshi??