How flawed is India's foreign policy that China is threatening war with us?

[DesiGuy]

I don't remember India being aggressive? What I remember is that we being docile or ever ready to take the guilt trip. Heck Muslims all over world feel pain for Al Qqsa but when hindus tried to reclaim the Ram janam bhoomi we had faggots shouting out we must build a hospital there and whatnot.

this is the bottom line and there is where oscar is plain wrong...the hindus as whole are incapable (consider it curse or blessing, i consider it a curse for hindus and blessings for others) of inflicting same amount of damage on minorities as muslims have done in the past and are presently doing it.

 

[Great Sachin]

very flawed....unless China would have never claimed disputed area...

ha ha ha

All anti India element is in full swing....

 

[ranjeet]

You just demonstrated exactly what I was taking about . The "majority" privilege that is pushing the extremism within India.

No this is not majority privilege sounds like, people who stayed back knew very well what they are resigning themselves to.

 

[Stephen Cohen]

I don't remember India being aggressive? What I remember is that we being docile or ever ready to take the guilt trip. Heck Muslims all over world feel pain for Al Qqsa but when hindus tried to reclaim the Ram janam bhoomi we had faggots shouting out we must build a hospital there and whatnot.

You must have heard of a NEW TERM
It is called POST truth -- Google it if necessary

It says that ONLY all the Left; SICKULAR ; Liberals have all the intelligence in the world
and the majority is simply reactionary and Intolerant

The same accusation was also made towards Trump supporters and for Brexit supporters

The point being made repeatedly is that we have elected
a " murderer " ; hence we are all guilty by association

SO what is left unsaid is that we must tolerate
Mind Boggling corruption ; Incompetence and Appeasement politics

But cannot elect a proven capable leader like Modi
who is doing exemplary work for INDIA
just because it offends the sensibilities of some people

 

[Dash]

Those were alignment times; India had to pick a side seeing how Pakistan was, but the more we dig into each sides domestic and international policies we will find things to nitpick on.

That was not alliginment times atall!!? it was right after Independence! The fact of the matter was such tht Churchill had to call Neheru to figure out which side were we on

Everyone has an opinion that is not always fair and accurate but it can be viral because humans in general prefer simpler explanations for things.

If thats the outcome of any social debate then Hindus too prefer simpler outcome, ad if they dontn then they are not general public? Since when it has been restricted to others alone?

s I mentioned, the "common" Indian Hindu and by that I mean the daily get in their car/bike go to work middle class is now divided as either quiet "keep my head down" folks, Modi "makes me my money" category and the more bigoted and hateful recently Bhakt converts; what they dont realize is that bot

ee
Sir, the common general Hindu is questionig nd askig where are my jobs? and if its a question about converts then there are religious converts ad then there are ideological ones and I prefer the latter

"underrepresented majority" e

Minority has 50% representation here, in all walks of life!

(200 mil at the least with every other religion combined I think).

As I said above, but you ca come up with intnernal probelms I kow

incidents like Gujrat or the train burning, or Babri masjid leave a bad taste but they did not matter in daily lives, now however with an ever greater majority of Indian Hindu extremists posting anti-Islam or other extreme messages on facebook and people from minorities seeing their erstwhile "normal" friends liking these posts is leading to a day by day increase in chasm that will sooner or later spill over.

I can also say that the biggest gangsters, mafias and drug trafickers are also from teh same community.

This is what is amiss in the minds of those that control India, as long as you hated Pakistan as some bothersome singular extremist entity and took it on as India..India of Amar, Akbar & anthony.. who were always going to come out on top; take it on as Yogi Amarnath of Akhand Bharat however and you are screwing yourself both inside and out.

You oe way talk about Indian diplomats what makes you think that tey have chaged course?

But the West does not complain at all

I know buddy, and I dont care about west at all

 

[Stephen Cohen]

I know buddy, and I dont care about west at all

But that is what really matters in the world we live in

If you observe closely all the accusations against India
on the Kashmir issue as well as events else where
are CONFLATED with Modi's ascent to power

By the way why does not the TWO percent Christians of India
clamour for Beef

We have also closed down the Christian missionaries engaged in conversions

But Indian Christians are not complaining ;Neither is the West

All complaints are pouring in from One country only

 

[ranjeet]

You must have heard of a NEW TERM
It is called POST truth -- Google it if necessary

It says that ONLY all the Left; SICKULAR ; Liberals have all the intelligence in the world
and the majority is simply reactionary and Intolerant

The same accusation was also made towards Trump supporters and for Brexit supporters

The point being made repeatedly is that we have elected
a " murderer " ; hence we are all guilty by association

SO what is left unsaid is that we must tolerate
Mind Boggling corruption ; Incompetence and Appeasement politics

But cannot elect a proven capable leader like Modi
who is doing exemplary work for INDIA
just because it offends the sensibilities of some people

Yeah, Forceful conversion of Hindu girls never made any Diplomat ashamed but beef stories are taking Indian diplomats on a guilt trip.

 

[Stephen Cohen]

Yeah, Forceful conversion of Hindu girls never made any Diplomat ashamed but beef stories are taking Indian diplomats on a guilt trip.

The Original topic and the original post has been forgotten
The fact is that in India ; Freedom of Expression is BADLY misused

So any number of journalists can write anything against INDIA
and get paid for it

By the way here is an example of INTOLERANCE

The Two people Umar Khalid and Shehla Rashid
who chanted slogans like " Bharat Tere Tukde Honge ; Inshallah Inshallah
on 9 th Feb 2016 are TODAY provided
POLICE protection by the same MODI GOVERNMENT

 

[Dash]

But that is what really matters in the world we live in

The less we care about them the more Importace you get, thats the logic

All complaints are pouring in from One country only

They will not remain silence they'll create noise thatsa fact and we are well prepared for that.

 

[ranjeet]

The Original topic and the original post has been forgotten
The fact is that in India ; Freedom of Expression is BADLY misused

So any number of journalists can write anything against INDIA
and get paid for it

By the way here is an example of INTOLERANCE

The Two people Umar Khalid and Shehla Rashid
who chanted slogans like " Bharat Tere Tukde Honge ; Inshallah Inshallah
on 9 th Feb 2016 are TODAY provided
POLICE protection by the same MODI GOVERNMENT

Such student leaders will die their own slow death. Plus there is nothing to discuss on Original topic when we have someone like Ashok swine talking about Indian foreign policy.

 

[DesiGuy]

The Original topic and the original post has been forgotten
The fact is that in India ; Freedom of Expression is BADLY misused

So any number of journalists can write anything against INDIA
and get paid for it

By the way here is an example of INTOLERANCE

The Two people Umar Khalid and Shehla Rashid
who chanted slogans like " Bharat Tere Tukde Honge ; Inshallah Inshallah
on 9 th Feb 2016 are TODAY provided
POLICE protection by the same MODI GOVERNMENT

na...you wanna know whats even stupidly funny?
The guys in kashmir who attack security fores to kill them gets their bodies return to their people and are allowed proper islamic burial.

keep aside politics aside....how coward forces must be to even consider doing this...!!!

 

[Stephen Cohen]

na...you wanna know whats even stupidly funny?
The guys in kashmir who attack security fores to kill them gets their bodies return to their people and are allowed proper islamic burial.

And more over their Funerals are ATTENDED by Known Militants

The security forces know them ; identify them in the crowd
But do not arrest them because of the solemn occassion

 

[Rollno21]

And more over their Funerals are ATTENDED by Known Militants

The security forces know them ; identify them in the crowd
But do not arrest them because of the solemn occassion

We should stop giving the dead terrorists a islamic burial,one it will make the terrorists think without the islamic burial,they won't reach the and get their reward.that will actually deter terrorists

 

[salimpheku]

China's best friends are Pakistan & North Korea.

Enough said

The issue with Indian foreign(and domestic) policy(ingrained into diplomats & bureaucracy from the Nehru years) is that for far too long its relied on a watch and wait sniveling attitude with larger powers which has led to a frustrated public. This has allowed extremists to push their agenda and now that they control the thoughts and morals of the Indian majority, they are trying to push their attitude in foreign policy as well. Unfortunately, the problem with that is the Indian extremists are so used to their bully mentality as being part of the majority that they cannot stand even an iota of being stood up to and when a larger bully confronts them they are lost for action.

The Bold part you are spot on.
The Italics part shows your bias. Don't confuse cause & effect. Just because you don't like the change in our foreign policy does not mean it's not the best for us.
Regarding who has 'lost for action', unless I am mistaken, it's the Chinese who are lost for action. Or may be it's them you are referring to as bullies.

 

[SQ8]

China's best friends are Pakistan & North Korea.

Enough said



The Bold part you are spot on.
The Italics part shows your bias. Don't confuse cause & effect. Just because you don't like the change in our foreign policy does not mean it's not the best for us.
Regarding who has 'lost for action', unless I am mistaken, it's the Chinese who are lost for action. Or may be it's them you are referring to as bullies.

i think your deduction applies to you more than me.